First Majestic Silver (AG) — Stock Analysis 2026 [2.4]

Silver Precious Metals Company Analysis
USD

Analysis as of 1 October 2026. First Majestic Silver stock analysis. A point-in-time snapshot, not an evergreen guide. Fundamentals come from First Majestic Silver’s 2025 Annual Information Form and audited financial statements (year ended 31 December 2025) and its Q2 2026 results (30 July 2026); market data is the NYSE close on 1 October 2026 ($17.66; 492.9 m basic, 501.6 m fully diluted shares). Rating: ★★½, Average — Overvalued (wide band) → Full: the market already sees it. Price deck: base silver $60/oz — the representative trailing average on the fixed $40–80 grid — with gold co-moved at $4,000/oz, and every grid price run as a scenario (deep bear $40 · $3,000 / bear $50 · $3,500 / base $60 · $4,000 / bull $70 · $4,500 / deep bull $80 · $5,000), the World Bank April 2026 forecast as a 0% cross-check — no spot price; 5% real discount rate. The share price embeds a market-implied deck of ~$124/oz silver. All figures are US dollars. Refreshed on each annual report and on material events. For information only, prepared with AI assistance — see the disclaimer at the end.

First Majestic Silver is the most silver-weighted of the large listed producers: four underground mines in Mexico that took 57% of their 2025 metal revenue from silver. The thesis in one line: a mid-sized, Mexico-only operator with short reserve lives, priced as if silver stayed far above even its January 2026 peak. Why now: the Gatos Silver deal and the 2025–26 silver rally lifted revenue 124% and filled the treasury, while $1.28 billion of Mexican tax reassessments and a 2027 Jerritt Canyon restart are still open. To screen First Majestic against every listed silver producer on grade, cost and reserve life, go to Metal Pilot’s silver mining stock screener.

1. Snapshot & thesis

First Majestic Silver Corp. (NYSE: AG; TSX: AG) is a silver-led producer/operator headquartered in Vancouver, with 5,535 employees and contractors. It runs four producing mines in Mexico — Los Gatos (70%, Chihuahua), Santa Elena (Sonora), San Dimas (Durango–Sinaloa) and La Encantada (Coahuila) — plus the suspended Jerritt Canyon gold mine in Nevada, the First Mint bullion facility and a silver stream on First Mining’s Springpole project. By archetype it is a producer, valued sum-of-the-parts, with gold and Los Gatos zinc and lead as material by-products; the full nine-dimension rubric applies (Section 9). (AgEq = silver-equivalent ounces; AISC = all-in sustaining cost; P&P = proven and probable reserves; M&I = measured and indicated resources; Moz = million ounces, koz = thousand ounces.)

Figure 1. First Majestic Silver in numbers

$17.66
Share price (1 Oct 2026)
$8.70 bn
Market capitalisation
$8.05 bn
Enterprise value (Section 7)
$1,257 m
Revenue, 2025
56.8%
Cash margin, 2025
4 + 1
Producing mines + restart project
15.4 Moz
Silver produced, 2025 (+147 koz gold)
101.1 Moz
P&P silver reserves (31 Dec 2025)
$0.79 bn
Net cash, 30 Jun 2026 (1.2× 2025 EBITDA)
$0.046
Dividend, last four declarations (0.26%)
2.4/5
Quality rating — Average
Overvalued
Valuation read (wide band)

Figure data: the FY2025 audited financial statements (revenue, cost of sales, dividends), the FY2025 MD&A (production, EBITDA), the 2025 Annual Information Form (reserves) and the Q2 2026 financial statements (cash, debt); share price per stockanalysis.com, NYSE close 1 October 2026. Enterprise value, rating and valuation read per Sections 7 and 9.

Table 1. First Majestic Silver in numbers

Metric Value As of
Share price / market capitalisation $17.66 / $8,704.7 m 1 Oct 2026
Shares outstanding (basic) 492.9 m 29 Jul 2026
Revenue / cash margin $1,257.2 m / 56.8% FY2025
Revenue, first half $892.2 m H1 2026
Production 15.44 Moz silver; 147.4 koz gold; 31.06 Moz AgEq FY2025
2026 production guidance 14.6–15.5 Moz silver; 128–135 koz gold 8 Jul 2026
AISC $21.17/AgEq oz (2025); guidance $27.69–28.77 (2026) 8 Jul 2026
Proven & probable reserves 101.07 Moz silver; 0.61 Moz gold; 184.79 Moz AgEq 31 Dec 2025
Cash / total debt / net cash $1,093.3 m / $302.8 m / $790.6 m 30 Jun 2026
Dividend policy / last four declarations 2% of net revenue / $0.0458 a share 29 Jul 2026
NAV per share (Section 7, base deck) $3.71 1 Oct 2026
Quality rating / valuation read 2.4/5 (Average) / Overvalued (wide band), −61.9% to a $6.73 blended fair value 1 Oct 2026

Source: the FY2025 audited financial statements, FY2025 MD&A and 2025 Annual Information Form (reserves under NI 43-101 / CIM, struck at $35/oz silver and $3,100/oz gold, Los Gatos at 70%); the Q2 2026 production and guidance release, Q2 2026 MD&A and Q2 2026 financial statements; share price per stockanalysis.com, 1 October 2026. Cash margin is revenue less cost of sales before depreciation, over revenue; net cash is cash less both convertible notes and the revolver at carrying value (Section 7 bridges the notes at face). Listed: Public (NYSE: AG / TSX: AG).

Thesis in brief. Bull: silver is the price that moves this company most — 57% of 2025 metal revenue, no hedges — and the business has turned: $526 m of operating cash flow in 2025 after four loss years, $1.09 bn of cash, a Los Gatos mine with the group’s lowest costs, and a Nevada gold restart that would add a non-Mexican mine from 2027. Bear: the mines are mid-sized and short-lived — 101 Moz of silver reserves is 6.5 years of 2025 output — all four sit in Mexico, which raised mining duties for 2025 and is reassessing $1.28 bn of San Dimas taxes, and the share count has nearly doubled since 2021. What tips it: the silver price, and whether the drill programme keeps converting resources into reserves faster than the mines deplete them. The rating and its rationale are in Section 9.

How to read this analysis: here for the verdict? The statcards above and the rating in Section 9 are the whole story. Want the evidence? Read Section 2 (the assets) through Section 7 (the valuation).

2. Assets & operations

Silver averaged $63.63/oz over June–August 2026, after a January peak of $92.10. For how silver is priced and why silver miners carry more torque than the metal, see Silver — A Complete Market Guide; this section spends its words on the company.

2.1 Portfolio overview & map

Table 2. Asset base (attributable)

Asset Location Interest Stage 2025 production P&P reserves, 31 Dec 2025 Reserve life from 30 Jun 2026 2026 AISC guidance
Los Gatos Chihuahua, Mexico 70% (Dowa 30%) Producing — underground Ag-Zn-Pb 5.87 Moz Ag; 8.91 Moz AgEq 35.28 Moz Ag; 66.13 Moz AgEq 8.9 yr $20.35–21.11/AgEq oz
Santa Elena (incl. Ermitaño) Sonora, Mexico 100% Producing — underground + leach pad, Ag-Au 1.42 Moz Ag; 88.1 koz Au 11.14 Moz Ag; 0.25 Moz Au 4.8 yr $25.09–25.83/AgEq oz
San Dimas Durango–Sinaloa, Mexico 100% Producing — underground Ag-Au 5.39 Moz Ag; 55.7 koz Au 23.16 Moz Ag; 0.289 Moz Au 3.7 yr $25.38–26.42/AgEq oz
La Encantada Coahuila, Mexico 100% Producing — underground + tailings, Ag 2.76 Moz Ag 31.50 Moz Ag 5.7 yr $31.18–32.36/AgEq oz
Jerritt Canyon Nevada, USA 100% Suspended since March 2023; restart targeted H2 2027 342 oz Au (in-circuit) none (4.10 Moz Au M&I) — —
San Martín Jalisco, Mexico 100% Care and maintenance since July 2019; sale agreed July 2026 — none — —
First Mint Nevada, USA 100% Bullion mint — 1.07 Moz Ag sold in 2025 — — — —
Springpole stream Ontario, Canada 50% of payable silver Development (First Mining) — — — —
Group 15.44 Moz Ag; 147.4 koz Au; 31.06 Moz AgEq 101.07 Moz Ag; 0.61 Moz Au; 184.79 Moz AgEq 6.5 yr (Ag ÷ 2025 output) $27.69–28.77/AgEq oz

Source: the 2025 Annual Information Form (reserves under NI 43-101 / CIM, effective 31 December 2025, Tables 1, 10, 16, 22 and 28; Jerritt Canyon Table 2), the FY2025 MD&A (production by mine) and the 8 July 2026 guidance release. Production is attributable (Los Gatos at 70% from 16 January 2025). Reserve life is the reserve tonnage left at 30 June 2026 over the first-half 2026 milling rate, doubled — the basis Section 7 runs on; for Los Gatos it is the AIF’s 9.4-year plan less the half-year mined. The group AISC adds $2.69–2.86/AgEq oz of corporate cost to the mines’. Every asset is operated by First Majestic. Listed: Public (NYSE: AG / TSX: AG).

Concentration. All four producing mines are Mexican, and three of them — Los Gatos, Santa Elena and San Dimas — earned 88% of 2025 segment revenue (Figure 3). A proportional-symbol asset map is not drawn here (Section 10.1); the table and this paragraph carry its read.

2.2 Where the revenue and the value sit

Figure 2. Revenue by metal, 2025

Silver
Gold
Zinc
Lead
Copper
57.3%
32.4%
6.9%
3.2%
0.2%
Share of 2025 gross revenue from payable metals, % (total $1,265.2 m before $8.0 m of smelting and refining)

Figure data: the FY2025 audited financial statements, Note 6, “Gross revenue from payable metals” — silver $724.3 m, gold $409.4 m, zinc $87.7 m, lead $41.0 m, copper $2.7 m; shares computed to one decimal (the note prints whole percentages).

Figure 3. Revenue by asset, 2025

Los Gatos (100%)
Santa Elena
San Dimas
La Encantada
First Mint & Jerritt Canyon
38.0%
26.9%
23.4%
7.8%
3.9%
Share of 2025 segment revenue, % (segments sum to $1,289.5 m before a $32.3 m intercompany elimination)

Figure data: the FY2025 audited financial statements, Note 5, “Segmented Information” — Los Gatos $489.8 m (consolidated at 100%, 30% owed to the non-controlling interest), Santa Elena $346.4 m, San Dimas $301.6 m, La Encantada $100.9 m, First Mint $49.4 m and Jerritt Canyon $1.3 m. First Mint buys its silver from the mines, hence the elimination.

Silver leads the metal split, but gold is a third of revenue. By asset, three mines each bring in a quarter to two-fifths; La Encantada trails.

2.3 Los Gatos

Los Gatos, in Chihuahua, came with the Gatos Silver acquisition that closed on 16 January 2025. First Majestic holds 70% of the Los Gatos Joint Venture; Dowa Metals & Mining holds 30%, has offtake rights on the zinc concentrate, and under the amended joint-venture agreement effective 1 January 2025 major decisions need 90% of the participating interests — in practice a Dowa veto — while First Majestic earns a $6 m annual management fee. It is a high-grade underground silver-zinc-lead mine: in 2025 it milled 867,467 attributable tonnes at 240 g/t silver and produced 5.87 Moz of silver, 56.7 Mlb of zinc and 32.3 Mlb of lead (70%) at an AISC of $15.15/AgEq oz, the group’s lowest. Reserves are 35.28 Moz of silver in 9.55 Mt at 115 g/t (70%), and the mine plan runs 9.4 years from January 2026. The La Cuesta royalty ended in Q3 2025; the mine now carries none. The asset-level risk is grade: the first half of 2026 milled 204 g/t against a 115 g/t reserve, so unit costs rise as the plan moves into lower-grade stopes — guidance is already $20.35–21.11/AgEq oz for 2026, while throughput rises to 4,000 tonnes per operating day in the second half.

2.4 Santa Elena

Santa Elena, in Sonora, combines the Santa Elena underground mine, the Ermitaño mine and a leach pad around one plant, and is the group’s gold mine: 88.1 koz of gold and 1.42 Moz of silver in 2025, from 1.10 Mt at 2.65 g/t gold, at an AISC of $17.96/AgEq oz. Reserves are 11.14 Moz of silver and 0.25 Moz of gold in 6.30 Mt, two-thirds of it at Ermitaño at 1.35 g/t gold — about half the 2.65 g/t milled in 2025. Two encumbrances apply at their filed terms: Royal Gold (formerly Sandstorm) takes 20% of the gold from the leach pad and a designated area at the lesser of market and $487.3/oz, and Ermitaño carries a 2% NSR to Minera Inmet and a 2% NSR to Osisko — $14.0 m of royalties in 2025. Growth is next door: the plant is expanding from 3,200 to 3,500 tonnes a day, underground mining at Santa Elena resumed on 15 May 2026, and the Navidad (6.42 Mt inferred, 89 g/t silver, 2.21 g/t gold) and Santo Niño discoveries received portal permits in June 2026. The key risk is the grade step-down to reserve.

2.5 San Dimas

San Dimas, on the Durango–Sinaloa border, has been First Majestic’s since the May 2018 acquisition of Primero Mining. It produced 5.39 Moz of silver and 55.7 koz of gold in 2025 from 928,352 t at 203 g/t silver and 2.00 g/t gold, at an AISC of $19.62/AgEq oz. Reserves are 23.16 Moz of silver and 0.289 Moz of gold in 3.70 Mt at 195 g/t and 2.43 g/t — under four years at the current milling rate — but the mine has replaced its ounces for decades, and 2026’s 117,000 m drilling programme returned new high-grade intercepts in September. The encumbrance is Wheaton Precious Metals’ stream on 25% of gold-equivalent production, at a fixed 70:1 silver-to-gold ratio and the lesser of market and $641/oz (rising 1% a year; $648/oz in Q2 2026) — 31,539 oz delivered in 2025. San Dimas is also the subject of the SAT tax reassessments (Section 6).

2.6 La Encantada

La Encantada, in Coahuila, is a silver-only mine that blends underground ore with reprocessed tailings: 2.76 Moz of silver in 2025 from 1.11 Mt at 114 g/t and 68% recovery, at an AISC of $29.26/AgEq oz, the group’s highest. Its 31.50 Moz probable reserve includes 15.63 Moz in the No. 4 tailings deposit, which lengthens the life to 2032 in the company’s cost tables but at a 25% tailings recovery. A Metalla royalty takes the first 1,000 oz of gold a year ($0.3 m in 2025), and the 2025 technical report gives no economic analysis. At 2026 guidance of $31.18–32.36/AgEq oz it is the mine most exposed to a lower silver price.

2.7 Jerritt Canyon

Jerritt Canyon (Nevada) is held 100% through Jerritt Canyon Gold LLC, bought from Sprott Mining in April 2021, and has been suspended since March 2023. It holds no reserves but carries 4.10 Moz of M&I gold (54.26 Mt at 2.35 g/t) and 3.66 Moz inferred. On 2 April 2026 the company committed $75 m in 2026 to restart it — of which $9.8 m was spent in the first half. First production is targeted for the second half of 2027; no year-by-year ramp is published before the Stantec pre-feasibility study due in Q4 2026. Approvals outstanding: Nevada’s regulator approval of an updated reclamation plan, expected in mid-2026, with bonding to rise by $23–27 m; 14 notices of alleged air-permit violations from 2021–22 remain under appeal. Encumbrances: NSRs of 1.5–10% on certain claims, a 33% NSR on fee land, a per-ton royalty on the processing facilities and a 0.5% NSR over the property to Gold Royalty. Its $119.3 m reclamation provision is the group’s largest.

2.8 Other assets & the pipeline

San Martín (Jalisco), idle since July 2019 and under the de facto control of an organised criminal group, is being sold to Flextronics Supply and Service for $90 m in cash under a 6 July 2026 agreement, most of it payable from 2027 to 2032; closing awaits Mexican antitrust approval. Del Toro was sold to Sierra Madre Gold and Silver, closing 19 June 2026, for $20 m in cash and $10 m in Sierra Madre shares, with up to $30 m deferred and contingent. First Mint sold 1.07 Moz of silver as bullion in 2025, at $46.32/oz. The Springpole stream — 50% of payable silver from First Mining’s Ontario gold project, at 33% of spot capped at $7.50/oz — gained a positive federal environmental-assessment decision on 30 June 2026.

2.9 Group production, reserves & costs

Table 3. Production and cost by mine

Mine Ag 2025 Au 2025 AISC 2025 Ag H1 2026 AISC H1 2026 Ag 2026 guide Au 2026 guide AISC 2026 guide
Los Gatos (70%) 5.87 Moz 3.1 koz $15.15 2.46 Moz $20.76 5.1–5.5 Moz 3–4 koz $20.35–21.11
San Dimas 5.39 Moz 55.7 koz $19.62 2.24 Moz $25.56 4.6–4.9 Moz 52–56 koz $25.38–26.42
La Encantada 2.76 Moz 0.1 koz $29.26 1.86 Moz $29.43 3.4–3.6 Moz — $31.18–32.36
Santa Elena 1.42 Moz 88.1 koz $17.96 0.78 Moz $24.57 1.4–1.5 Moz 72–76 koz $25.09–25.83
Group 15.44 Moz 147.4 koz $21.17 7.35 Moz $27.67 14.6–15.5 Moz 128–135 koz $27.69–28.77

Source: the FY2025 MD&A (mine tables and Key Performance Metrics), the Q2 2026 MD&A (six months to 30 June 2026) and the 8 July 2026 updated guidance. AISC in $ per AgEq ounce, the company’s basis (gold at a fixed 75:1 in the guidance); the group AISC includes corporate costs. Group 2025 gold includes 342 oz from Jerritt Canyon.

Table 4. Mineral reserves and resources, 31 December 2025

Mine P&P tonnes Ag grade Au grade P&P silver P&P gold P&P AgEq M&I silver Inferred silver
Los Gatos (70%) 9.55 Mt 115 g/t 0.19 g/t 35.28 Moz 0.058 Moz 66.13 Moz 42.35 Moz 10.71 Moz
La Encantada 7.87 Mt 121 g/t — 31.50 Moz — 31.50 Moz 36.43 Moz 17.13 Moz
San Dimas 3.70 Mt 195 g/t 2.43 g/t 23.16 Moz 0.289 Moz 48.75 Moz 45.42 Moz 43.76 Moz
Santa Elena 6.30 Mt 55 g/t 1.25 g/t 11.14 Moz 0.25 Moz 38.42 Moz 21.09 Moz 41.87 Moz
Total 27.43 Mt 101.07 Moz 0.61 Moz 184.79 Moz 145.30 Moz 113.47 Moz

Source: the 2025 Annual Information Form, Tables 1–3 (proven and probable reserves; measured and indicated, and inferred, resources), prepared under NI 43-101 / CIM, effective 31 December 2025; reserves at $35/oz silver and $3,100/oz gold (Los Gatos also $1.25/lb zinc, $0.95/lb lead), resources at $38.50 and $3,400. M&I is inclusive of reserves. Mineral resources are not mineral reserves and have no demonstrated economic viability. Jerritt Canyon adds 4.10 Moz of M&I gold and 3.66 Moz inferred; the 31 March 2026 release’s “101.7 million ounces” of silver reserves is a typo for the 101.07 Moz the AIF tables sum to.

Figure 4. Attributable silver production, 2022–2026

Silver (Moz)
20
15
10
5
0
10.52
10.25
8.40
15.44
15.05
2022
2023
2024
2025
2026G
Attributable silver production, Moz; 2026G is the midpoint of the 14.6–15.5 Moz guidance, not an achieved figure

Figure data: the FY2024 MD&A (2022–2024, “Silver Ounces Produced”), the FY2025 MD&A (2025) and the 8 July 2026 guidance (2026). Earlier years are outside the filings in the source set.

Costs. The 2025 group AISC of $21.17/AgEq oz rises to $27.69–28.77 in the 2026 guidance — partly price-linked (worker profit-sharing alone is $2.16–2.29/AgEq oz) and partly grade, as Los Gatos and Santa Elena mine toward reserve grade. Reserves. 101.07 Moz of silver is 6.5 years of 2025 output, and every mine but Los Gatos is under six years at its first-half 2026 milling rate. The company’s answer is conversion: 145.30 Moz of M&I and 113.47 Moz of inferred silver sit beside the plans, and 2026 drilling was raised to about 308,000 m. Those are resources, not reserves — the valuation credits them in one risked row (Section 7).

Figure 5. Reserves and resources by operating mine, 31 December 2025 (silver-equivalent)

Los Gatos (70%)
San Dimas
Santa Elena
La Encantada
66.1 Moz AgEq
80.8 Moz AgEq (+14.7 M&I)
48.8 Moz AgEq
96.4 Moz AgEq (+47.7 M&I)
38.4 Moz AgEq
76.8 Moz AgEq (+38.4 M&I)
31.5 Moz AgEq
36.4 Moz AgEq (+4.9 M&I)
Proven and probable reserves Measured and indicated resources (inclusive of reserves, as reported)
Silver-equivalent, Moz AgEq attributable — one scale for both bars; the second bar prints the M&I beyond the reserve (inclusive M&I less the reserve)

Figure data: the 2025 Annual Information Form, Tables 1–2 — proven and probable reserves (as in Table 4) and measured plus indicated resources in silver-equivalent ounces as the company computes them (gold, and at Los Gatos zinc, lead and copper, converted at the AIF’s metal prices, recoveries and payables — reserves at $35/oz silver and $3,100/oz gold, resources at $38.50 and $3,400, so the two bars carry slightly different conversion ratios); NI 43-101 / CIM, effective 31 December 2025, Los Gatos at 70%. First Majestic reports M&I inclusive of reserves, so the second bar is the M&I as reported and the printed addition is derived as M&I less the reserve. Not drawn: Jerritt Canyon (suspended; 4.10 Moz gold of M&I, 362 Moz AgEq) and San Martín (care and maintenance). Inferred resources (113.5 Moz silver) are not drawn.

By mine (Figure 5), Los Gatos carries the largest silver-equivalent reserve — its zinc and lead make 66 Moz AgEq of 35 Moz of silver — but San Dimas and Santa Elena hold the most resource beyond their reserves, about twice their reserve each in M&I. La Encantada has the least: 36 Moz of M&I against a 32 Moz reserve, so its 5.7-year life has little behind it.

2.10 Peer positioning

The peer set for every “vs peers” claim is the listed silver and silver-gold producers of more than 15 Moz a year: Fresnillo, Pan American Silver, Coeur Mining and Hecla Mining. None was under an unclosed takeover on 1 October 2026.

Table 5. Peer positioning — quality metrics, 2025

Company Listing Silver Gold Revenue Cash margin Silver reserves · life Largest country 2026 silver guide vs 2025
Fresnillo Public (LSE: FRES) 48.7 Moz 600 koz $4,561 m 69.2% 362.6 Moz · 7.4 yr Mexico, 100% −9%
Pan American Silver Public (TSX/NYSE: PAAS) 22.8 Moz 742 koz $3,619 m 52.6% 452.3 Moz · 19.8 yr Chile, 23% +14%
Coeur Mining Public (NYSE: CDE) 17.9 Moz 419 koz $2,070 m 56.6% 274.4 Moz · 15.3 yr US, 57% of sales +10%
Hecla Mining Public (NYSE: HL) 17.0 Moz 151 koz $1,423 m 55.0% 231.1 Moz · 13.6 yr US, 82% of silver −7%
First Majestic Silver Public (NYSE/TSX: AG) 15.4 Moz 147 koz $1,257 m 56.8% 101.1 Moz · 6.5 yr Mexico, 100% −3%

Source: each company’s own 2025 filings — Fresnillo 2025 preliminary results, Coeur 2025 fourth-quarter results and year-end 2025 reserves, Hecla 2025 results and year-end 2025 reserves; Pan American per its 2025 MD&A, 2025 financial statements and 2026 guidance release; First Majestic per Tables 1–3 here. Cash margin = revenue less cost of sales excluding depreciation, over revenue. Reserve life = silver reserves ÷ 2025 silver output (Pan American’s is 8.2 years excluding Escobal); guidance change = midpoint of 2026 silver guidance against 2025 output. Screen the silver producers on grade, cost and reserve life at Metal Pilot’s silver mining stock screener.

First Majestic is the smallest of the five by silver output and has the shortest reserve life by a margin; its cash margin is second only to Fresnillo’s, and it is the only one besides Fresnillo with all its production in Mexico. For First Majestic against Fresnillo, Pan American, Coeur and Hecla on one construction, see Silver Producers Compared; ranked on silver output and placed on five measures, the group lines up in Best Silver Stocks.

3. Financials & balance sheet

Table 6. Five-year financial summary (years ended 31 December)

Metric 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025
Revenue $584.1 m $624.2 m $573.8 m $560.6 m $1,257.2 m
Revenue YoY — +6.9% −8.1% −2.3% +124.3%
Cash margin 37.3% 24.4% 26.2% 38.5% 56.8%
Net earnings attributable $(4.9) m $(114.3) m $(135.1) m $(101.9) m $164.9 m
EPS (diluted) $(0.02) $(0.43) $(0.48) $(0.34) $0.34
Operating cash flow $68.7 m $19.0 m $55.6 m $152.0 m $526.0 m
Capex, all (cash) $189.0 m $217.7 m $146.0 m $115.1 m $210.7 m
Sustaining capex (attributable; Los Gatos at 70%) $85.7 m $83.9 m $64.6 m $44.9 m $55.4 m
Free cash flow (OCF − all capex) $(120.2) m $(198.7) m $(90.4) m $36.8 m $315.4 m
Net debt (net cash) $(56.7) m $58.9 m $94.2 m $7.3 m $(501.2) m
Net debt / EBITDA net cash 0.6× n/m 0.06× net cash
Diluted shares (weighted) 244.7 m 263.1 m 282.3 m 295.5 m 484.6 m
Dividend declared per share n/d $0.0261 $0.0208 $0.0179 $0.0202

Source: the audited consolidated financial statements for 2025 (2025, 2024), 2023 (2023) and 2022 (2022, 2021) — revenue, cost of sales, net earnings, EPS, cash flows, debt (Note 21), shares and dividends (Note 25); sustaining capital from the FY2025, FY2024, FY2023 and FY2022 MD&As (non-GAAP; 2021–22 from the FY2022 MD&A’s AISC tables, p.46–47). Net debt = debt facilities (convertible notes and revolver at carrying value) less cash; EBITDA rebuilt as in Table 24 — earnings before tax + finance costs + D&A ($162.9 m in 2021, $94.7 m in 2022, −$45.0 m in 2023, $125.6 m in 2024, $684.7 m in 2025; the MD&As report $33.4 m for 2022). Cash margin as Table 1; 2023 includes $13.4 m of standby costs. 2021’s dividend per share is n/d: the FY2022 statements (Note 25(g)) list 2022’s declarations only and the FY2022 MD&A gives dividends paid in total. Sustaining capital is the MD&A’s attributable measure, all-in capex the cash-flow statement’s consolidated one.

2022–2024 were loss years — weak silver and the Jerritt Canyon suspension, impaired $125.2 m in 2023 — and free cash flow was negative three years in four. 2025 changed scale: Los Gatos and a rising silver price doubled revenue, operating cash flow ($526.0 m) ran well ahead of attributable earnings ($164.9 m), as it should with $263.4 m of depreciation, and the first half of 2026 added $445.4 m more. Read against the Financial Metrics for Commodity Investing guide: the margin is real but price-made (the 2025 realised price was $41.52 per AgEq ounce, H1 2026 $74.83 per silver ounce); the cash backs the profit; the red flag is dilution — weighted diluted shares rose from 244.7 m to 484.6 m in four years, through at-the-market issues in 2021–2024 and the 177.4 m shares paid for Gatos — and capex is mostly discretionary, with attributable sustaining capital of $55.4 m in 2025 against $210.7 m of consolidated cash capex.

Table 7. Balance sheet and liquidity, 30 June 2026

Line Value Note
Cash and cash equivalents $1,093.3 m up from $793.4 m at 31 Dec 2025
Restricted cash (non-current) $159.4 m $138.9 m frozen by the SAT; $20.5 m Nevada trust
Marketable securities $155.1 m incl. Sierra Madre and Silver Storm stakes
Debt (carrying value) $302.8 m 2027 notes $55.3 m face (0.375%, convert at $16.56); 2031 notes $350.0 m face (0.125%, convert at $22.36)
Revolving credit facility $175 m, $159.9 m undrawn matures 17 Jun 2030
Lease liabilities $28.4 m
Decommissioning liabilities $188.3 m Jerritt Canyon $119.3 m at 31 Dec 2025
Income taxes payable $286.1 m incl. the accrued 2012 SAT reassessment
Working capital $876.0 m
Non-controlling interest (Dowa) $409.3 m 30% of the Los Gatos Joint Venture

Source: the Q2 2026 condensed interim financial statements — statement of financial position, Notes 14, 19, 21, 22 and 25; the Jerritt Canyon provision from the FY2025 statements, Note 23.

Leverage and liquidity. Net cash is $790.6 m and liquidity $1.04 bn, so leverage does not bind at any price on the Section 7 grid: on 2025 EBITDA of $686.1 m the company carries no net debt. The two real claims on that cash are the $286.1 m of income taxes payable and the $1.28 bn of SAT reassessments (Section 6) — $138.9 m of cash is already frozen against them. The rehabilitation provision of $188.3 m is mostly Jerritt Canyon, where bonding is expected to rise by $23–27 m. The hedge book: the company does not use long-term derivatives against silver or gold and held only $0.1 m of short-term currency contracts at 30 June 2026 — unhedged. Capital returns: the dividend was raised from 1% to 2% of net revenue from January 2026, 1.2 m shares were bought back in the second quarter for $22.7 m, and no at-the-market shares have been sold since 2024.

Table 8. Cost deck handed to the valuation

Item Value Basis
Guided AISC, 2026 $27.69–28.77/AgEq oz (mines $25.00–25.91; corporate $2.69–2.86) 8 Jul 2026 guidance, at $52 silver, $3,900 gold, MXN 18.25
Guided cash cost, 2026 $19.27–19.85/AgEq oz same
Worker profit-sharing (PTU) 10% of taxable profit — $2.16–2.29/AgEq oz in the AISC price-linked
Special Mining Duty / environmental duty / income tax 8.5% of the EBITDA-like base / 1% of precious-metal revenue / 30% Mexico, 2025 reform rates
Wheaton stream (San Dimas) 25% of gold-equivalent output at $648/oz, +1% a year price-linked
Royal Gold stream (Santa Elena) 20% of designated gold at the lesser of market and $487.3/oz price-linked
Ermitaño royalties 2% + 2% NSR price-linked
Grade profile reserve vs H1 2026 milled: Los Gatos 115 vs 204 g/t Ag; Santa Elena 1.25 vs 2.36 g/t Au; San Dimas 195 vs 179 g/t Ag unit cost rises toward reserve grade
Cost trend AISC $21.11 (2024) → $21.17 (2025) → $27.67 (H1 2026) AgEq basis
Tax pools Mexican losses $498.5 m ($381.8 m unrecognised), expiring 2026–2035; cash tax $78.6 m in 2025, $142.3 m in H1 2026 already a full cash taxpayer

Source: the 8 July 2026 guidance release (AISC build and price assumptions), the 2025 Annual Information Form (Risk Factors — Taxation; stream and royalty terms), the FY2025 financial statements (Note 24 tax pools; Note 6 royalties) and the Q2 2026 MD&A and statements (grades, Wheaton price, cash tax). No cost-inflation rate is disclosed; the AISC trend stands in for it.

4. Management, strategy & corporate structure

4.1 Management & governance

Keith Neumeyer founded First Majestic in 2001 and has run it since — President and CEO until December 2025, CEO since; he was the founding President of First Quantum Minerals and chairs First Mining Gold, the Springpole stream counterparty. He owns 4.73 m shares, about 0.96%. Mani Alkhafaji, who led the Gatos acquisition, became President and Chief Corporate Development Officer on 1 January 2026; Steven Holmes, COO since February 2020, came from Barrick and KGHM International; Neil Beaumont became CFO on 2 July 2026, succeeding David Soares, who had held the role since March 2022. The board has six directors, five independent, chaired by Thomas F. Fudge, Jr., a mining engineer from Tahoe Resources and Hecla, with Audit (chair Colette Rustad), Compensation, Corporate Governance & Nominating (chair Marjorie Co) and Sustainability (chair Raymond Polman, the CFO until 2021) committees.

Governance is where shareholders have pushed back. In 2025 the say-on-pay vote failed with 41.01% support and Fudge was re-elected with 50.44%; after outreach to 16 large holders both recovered in June 2026, to 65.64% and 69.87%. Neumeyer was paid $6.61 m in 2025. Neumeyer and Polman both sit on First Mining’s board and audit committee — a disclosed interlock on a related party in which First Majestic exercised 32.1 m warrants in December 2025.

4.2 Strategy & capital allocation

The stated aim is to be the world’s largest primary silver producer, buying only silver assets with low costs and exploration upside, while the treasury builds. The 2026 plan, raised on 8 July, spends $318–344 m of capital — $62–70 m sustaining and $256–274 m expansionary, of which $75 m restarts Jerritt Canyon and $41–45 m is exploration — to lift Los Gatos to 4,000 tonnes per operating day, expand Santa Elena to 3,500 tonnes a day and drill about 308,000 m. Returns run through the dividend (2% of net revenue) and a buyback of up to 24.5 m shares that expires on 13 October 2026.

4.3 Ownership & corporate structure

No holder owns more than 10%; directors and officers together hold about 1.05%. The producing mines are held through Mexican subsidiaries — Primero Empresa Minera (San Dimas), Nusantara de México (Santa Elena), Minera La Encantada and, at 70%, the Los Gatos Joint Venture entities — with Jerritt Canyon Gold LLC and First Mint LLC in the US. After share sales in October and November 2025 it held 19.07% of Silver Storm and 27.72% of Sierra Madre, before the Sierra Madre shares received for Del Toro in June 2026.

Table 9. Major transactions, 2018–2026

Date Counterparty Transaction Consideration Result
May 2018 Primero Mining Acquisition not in the source set San Dimas, 100%; the Wheaton gold stream
Jul 2020 First Mining Gold Springpole silver stream $22.5 m in cash and shares 50% of payable silver; First Mining may buy back half for $22.5 m
Apr 2021 Sprott Mining Jerritt Canyon acquisition 26.7 m shares + 5 m warrants; $478.9 m Suspended March 2023; impaired $125.2 m
Mar 2023 Sierra Madre La Guitarra sale $35 m in shares + 2% NSR Non-core exit
Aug 2023 Golden Tag (Silver Storm) La Parrilla sale up to $33.5 m Non-core exit
Jan 2025 Gatos Silver Acquisition, 2.55 shares per Gatos share 177.4 m shares; $1,054.2 m 70% of Los Gatos
Dec 2025 Bond investors 2031 convertible notes $350.0 m at 0.125% Repurchased $174.7 m of 2027 notes for $214.7 m
Jun 2026 Sierra Madre Del Toro sale $20 m cash + $10 m shares; up to $30 m more Closed 19 Jun 2026
Jul 2026 Flextronics (Meridian Capital) San Martín sale $90 m cash, mostly 2027–2032 Close expected Q4 2026

Source: the 2025 Annual Information Form (General Development of the Business; Capital Structure), the FY2025 and 2022 financial statements (Note 4, acquisitions; Note 21, debt), the Q2 2026 MD&A (Del Toro; Springpole) and the San Martín sale release, 7 July 2026.

5. ESG & sustainability

Table 10. ESG snapshot

Pillar Programme or metric Attribute Status
Safety Total recordable injury frequency rate 0.55 in 2025, from 1.19 in 2022; one fatality in 2023, none in 2024–25; 0.63 in Q2 2026 Improving
Climate Scope 1 + 2 emissions 77,251 t CO₂e in 2025, up 24% with Los Gatos; intensity 0.018 t per tonne of ore, from 0.023 Reported (SASB, TCFD-aligned)
Energy Santa Elena 24 MW LNG plant; Las Truchas hydro at San Dimas 99.9% of Santa Elena’s power; about 41% of San Dimas’s Operating
Water Water intensity 0.81 m³ per tonne of ore (0.59 excluding Los Gatos dewatering); target 0.50 by 2030 In progress
Tailings 13 facilities, 8 filtered; 5 active Phased adoption of the global tailings standard In progress
Community Community investment $2.4 m in 2025, from $1.2 m in 2024 Ongoing
Liabilities Jerritt Canyon 14 notices of alleged violation from Nevada’s regulator (2021–22), under appeal; $119.3 m reclamation provision Open

Source: the 2025 Sustainability Report and its data download (safety, emissions, water, tailings), the 2025 Annual Information Form (power, Jerritt Canyon) and the Q2 2026 MD&A (Q2 2026 safety).

Injury rates halved between 2022 and 2024 and held there, LNG and hydro power cut Scope 1 and 2 emissions 36% from the 2019 baseline, and ISS ESG ranks the company in the top 10% of miners. The open items are Jerritt Canyon’s air-permit notices and San Martín, whose tailings facility the company cannot reach while criminals control the site.

6. Risks

Table 11. Risk register

Risk Type Likelihood / impact (1–⁠5) Who or what is exposed Mitigant
R1 Silver falls back from its 2026 highs Commodity 4 / 5 The whole equity — $1.04 of NAV a share per co-moved $10/oz silver and $500/oz gold step, $0.80 for silver alone (Section 7) Net cash; gold and base metals 43% of revenue
R2 SAT tax reassessments Tax 3 / 5 $1.28 bn on San Dimas for 2010–2018; the 2012 year lost $147.2 m already accrued; $1.09 bn NAFTA claim; court ruling due H2 2026
R3 Mexico jurisdiction Jurisdiction 4 / 4 All four producing mines — 2025 duty reform, 2023 concession and water rules, security Amparo challenges; Jerritt Canyon from 2027
R4 High cost base Operational 3 / 4 2026 AISC $27.69–28.77/AgEq oz; La Encantada above $31 Los Gatos at $20–21; by-product credits
R5 Short reserve lives Operational 3 / 3 San Dimas 3.7, Santa Elena 4.8, La Encantada 5.7 years 145.3 Moz of M&I silver; 308,000 m of drilling
R6 Jerritt Canyon restart Execution 3 / 2 $75 m in 2026; $119.3 m reclamation Pre-feasibility study before production
R7 Los Gatos joint venture Partner 2 / 3 90% approval threshold; Dowa offtake; zinc and lead prices First Majestic operates; $6 m management fee
R8 Dilution Balance sheet 2 / 2 19.0 m shares on conversion of both notes; past at-the-market issues No issuance since 2024; buyback
R9 Governance Governance 2 / 1 2025 chair vote 50.44% and failed say-on-pay 2026 votes recovered to 69.87% and 65.64%

Source: the risk factors in the 2025 Annual Information Form and the Q2 2026 financial statements, Note 27 (contingencies); the 2025 and 2026 voting results. Likelihood and impact are the author’s assessment, not company figures.

Figure 6. Risk matrix — likelihood against impact

Impact (1–5)
5
4
3
2
1
R1 Silver falls back 20
R3 Mexico 16
R2 SAT reassessments 15
R4 High cost base 12
R5 Short reserve lives 9
R6 Jerritt restart 6
R7 Los Gatos JV 6
R8 Dilution 4
R9 Governance 2
1
Rare
2
3
4
5
Likely
Likelihood (1–5)

Figure data: Table 11; each point prints its likelihood × impact score, and the shaded region is the high-likelihood, high-impact quadrant. Ratings are the author’s assessment, not company figures.

The top-right corner is where the thesis breaks: a lower silver price and Mexico compound, because a high-cost, Mexico-only producer has no other region or margin to fall back on. The SAT dispute is the risk most specific to First Majestic: Mexico’s Supreme Court declined to hear the 2012 appeal in October 2025, the company accrued $147.2 m, and the rest of 2010–2018 remains open — including a $115 m reassessment for 2018 issued in April 2026. Section 7 bridges only the accrued year and prices the open years as a sensitivity: −$0.92 a share at an expected value, −$2.22 if all are lost.

7. Valuation

Valuation as of 1 October 2026, in US dollars (First Majestic reports in US dollars and the valuation is struck on the NYSE listing, so no FX conversion is needed). Horizon: spot fair value. Price deck: base silver $60/oz — the 3-month trailing average of $63.63/oz (June–August 2026), against a 6-month average of $70.45 and a 12-month average of $66.80, all monthly averages per the World Bank Pink Sheet release of 2 September 2026, the latest before the valuation date. The 3-month window is the representative one because the 6- and 12-month windows still carry the January 2026 peak of $92.10; it sits nearest the $60 grid price. Every grid price from $40 to $80/oz is run as a scenario (deep bear $40 / bear $50 / base $60 / bull $70 / deep bull $80). Gold, 36.7% of enterprise NAV, is decked at $4,000/oz — its own 3-month average of $4,237 (6-month $4,479, 12-month $4,398, same series) taken to the nearest price of the $3,000–5,000 gold grid — and co-moves step-for-step with silver in every scenario (silver $50 pairs with gold $3,500), because the two are a documented co-moving pair (five-year monthly correlation 0.95, same series); the ratio is not fixed, and Figure 9 and Table 18 price a move in gold alone. Zinc (7.8% of enterprise NAV) and lead (3.0%) are by-products held in every column at their 3-month averages taken to their grids: zinc $2,800 / 3,200 / 3,600 / 4,000 / 4,400/t ($3,671 → $3,600), lead $1,600 / 1,800 / 2,000 / 2,200 / 2,400/t ($1,881 → $1,800); copper is unpaid under the Los Gatos concentrate terms. The World Bank’s April 2026 outlook (silver $70.0 for 2026 and $65.0 for 2027; gold $4,700 and $4,300) is an unweighted cross-check; no spot deck is carried. Discount rate 5% real, after tax — the precious-metals convention, sensitised 4–7%. Share price $17.66 (NYSE close, 1 October 2026); 492.9 m basic and 501.553 m fully diluted shares; balance sheet as of 30 June 2026.

First Majestic is valued on the producer (mining) archetype, run as a sum-of-the-parts of four producing Mexican mines — Los Gatos at its 70% — plus the Jerritt Canyon restart, the 2026 growth capital still to spend and a resource tier. The method is set out in The Commodity Investor, Part 11: How to Value Commodity Stocks. The blended fair value is $6.73 per share at the base prices ($60 silver, $4,000 gold), $4.99 at $50 and $3,500, and $8.48 at $70 and $4,500; each co-moved step moves NAV per share by $1.04 — $0.80 of it from $10/oz of silver and $0.23 from $500/oz of gold (Table 18). The producing mines plus the whole equity bridge are worth $2.83 per share, Jerritt Canyon $0.44 and the resource beyond the plans $0.44.

What §7 starts from. The figures below set the mine builds, the tax basis, the restart value and the bridge. Everything else §7 takes from a filing or a market series is in the register at §10.1 (Table 29).

Table 12. Load-bearing inputs — the filed figures the valuation moves on

Input Value Where §7 uses it Source
Silver and gold bases silver $63.63 (3-month), $70.45 (6-month), $66.80 (12-month); gold $4,237, $4,479, $4,398 · to Aug 2026 §7 opening — the $60 silver and $4,000 gold bases on the fixed grids Market | World Bank Pink Sheet | “Silver”, “Gold”, monthly | release of 2 Sep 2026
San Dimas reserves 3.70 Mt; 23.16 Moz silver, 0.289 Moz gold · 31 Dec 2025 Table 15, block 1 Filed | AIF 2025 | Table 10 | “Total Proven + Probable (UG) Sulphides” | p.36
Los Gatos reserves (70%) 9.55 Mt; 35.28 Moz silver; 685.92 Mlb zinc; 371.41 Mlb lead · 31 Dec 2025 Table 15, block 4 — the largest asset Filed | AIF 2025 | Table 22 | “Proven + Probable CLG” | p.62
Los Gatos mine life 9.4 years from 1 Jan 2026 Table 15, block 4 — the life Filed | AIF 2025 | Los Gatos | “will remain in operation for” | p.66
2026 guidance 14.6–15.5 Moz silver; 128–135 koz gold; AISC $27.69–28.77/AgEq oz · 8 Jul 2026 Table 15 — each mine’s AISC per year; Table 17 — corporate G&A Filed | Q2 2026 production release | 2026 Updated Full Year Mine-by-Mine Guidance | “Total Consolidated” | p.5
2026 expansionary capital $256–274 m, of which Jerritt Canyon $75 m · 30 Jul 2026 Table 15, blocks 5 and 6 Filed | Q2 2026 MD&A | Capital Expenditures in 2026 | “for expansionary projects” | p.13
Jerritt Canyon resource 4.10 Moz gold measured and indicated; no reserves · 31 Dec 2025 Table 15, block 6 — at the in-situ anchor Filed | AIF 2025 | Table 2 | “Total Measured + Indicated (UG + OP) Sulphides” | p.24
Mexican mining taxes Special Mining Duty 8.5%; income tax 30% Table 15 — every Mexican block’s after-tax margin Filed | AIF 2025 | Risk Factors — Taxation | “Special Mining Duty –" | p.136
Cash $1,093.3 m · 30 Jun 2026 Table 17 — the net-cash line Filed | Q2 2026 FS | Statements of Financial Position | “Cash and cash equivalents” | p.7
Convertible notes $350.0 m due 2031 (conversion $22.36); 55,292 2027 notes (conversion $16.56) Table 17 — the convertible line and the share count Filed | Q2 2026 FS | Note 21(a) | “On December 8, 2025, the Company issued $" | p.34
Decommissioning liabilities $188.3 m · 30 Jun 2026 Table 17 — the reclamation line Filed | Q2 2026 FS | Statements of Financial Position | “Decommissioning liabilities” | p.7
Income taxes payable and restricted cash $286.1 m payable; restricted $20.5 m + $138.9 m · 30 Jun 2026 Table 17 — the working-capital line Filed | Q2 2026 FS | Statements of Financial Position | “Income taxes payable” | p.7; Note 19 | p.32
SAT reassessments, PEM $1.28 bn for 2010–2018; 2012 accrued at $147.2 m · 30 Jun 2026 Table 17 — 2012 accrued inside taxes payable; the open years a contingency in note 1 Filed | Q2 2026 FS | Note 27(b) | “which aggregate to $1.28 billion” | p.51; FY2025 FS | Note 24 | p.66
Fully diluted shares 501.553 m — 492,906,383 basic plus options, units and the 2027-note shares · 29 Jul 2026 every per-share figure in §7 Derived | treasury method and if-converted on Q2 2026 MD&A | Outstanding Share Data | “As at July 29, 2026, the Company has” | p.51

Source: the 2025 Annual Information Form (reserves and resources effective 31 December 2025, NI 43-101); the Q2 2026 production and updated guidance release (8 July 2026); the Q2 2026 MD&A and condensed interim consolidated financial statements, 30 June 2026 (30 July 2026); the FY2025 financial statements; monthly averages per the World Bank Pink Sheet. Pages are those of each filed document as rendered on EDGAR; the AIF’s are its printed page numbers. All figures in US dollars. Reserves are effective 31 December 2025, guidance 8 July 2026 and the balance sheet 30 June 2026 — the section’s vintages, each printed with its row. The share price the section is read against ($17.66, 1 October 2026) is in the opening block, not here: it moves the rating, not the valuation. The full register — every figure §7 takes from outside this analysis — is Table 29 in §10.1.

Metal Pilot Premium

Valuation workings — Premium

The workings behind this valuation — the method, the models, the sensitivity grids and the scenarios, 14 tables and 4 figures in all — are for Metal Pilot Premium members.

  • 7.1 Method selection
  • 7.2 Net asset value
  • 7.3 Relative valuation
  • 7.4 FCF-yield support
  • 7.5 Cross-checks
  • 7.6 Scenarios & fair value

Want to see one first? The Newmont (NEM) valuation is open to every reader.

Create a Metal Pilot accountLog in

See Premium plansRead a free example

You are signed in, and your plan does not include valuation workings. They come with Metal Pilot Premium.

Upgrade to Premium

The premium section could not be loaded right now.

Premium — unlocked

8. Near-term catalysts (1–3 years)

Table 27. Near-term catalysts

Catalyst Expected timing Why it benefits First Majestic
Los Gatos at 4,000 tonnes per operating day Second half of 2026 About 14% more throughput than 3,500 tonnes at the lowest-cost mine in the group
Santa Elena plant at 3,500 tonnes a day; Santo Niño and Navidad portals Under way (on track per the Q2 2026 MD&A); portals permitted June 2026 More mill feed at the gold mine; Navidad holds 6.42 Mt of inferred resource at 89 g/t silver and 2.21 g/t gold
San Martín sale closes Q4 2026, subject to antitrust approval $90 m in cash over six years for a mine it cannot operate, and its liabilities leave with it
Jerritt Canyon pre-feasibility study, then restart Study Q4 2026; production targeted H2 2027 A Nevada gold mine on 4.10 Moz of M&I resource — the first non-Mexican production since 2023
SAT ruling on the San Dimas pricing agreement; NAFTA claim Collegiate Court ruling expected H2 2026 A win removes most of a $1.28 bn claim; a loss at least ends the uncertainty
2026 reserve and resource update With the 2026 annual filings The test of whether 308,000 m of drilling extends the short reserve lives

Source: the Q2 2026 MD&A (Los Gatos, Santa Elena, the SAT timetable), the 8 July 2026 guidance release, the San Martín sale release, the Jerritt Canyon restart release and the 2025 Annual Information Form (Navidad resource). Timings are company guidance, not commitments.

The two that matter most are the Jerritt Canyon study, which would turn a resource into a mine plan outside Mexico, and the reserve update, which tests whether drilling replaces what the mills consume.

9. Rating & verdict

First Majestic is scored on the nine dimensions every analysis on this blog uses, against the Section 2.10 peer set, with the producer weighting — 15% each for asset quality, cost, reserves, balance sheet and capital allocation, 6.25% for the other four. None is not-applicable.

Figure 11. Scorecard by dimension, 1 October 2026

Assets & scale★★☆☆☆15%
Cost & margins★★★☆☆15%
Reserves & life★★☆☆☆15%
Balance sheet★★★☆☆15%
Capital allocation★★☆☆☆15%
Growth★★★☆☆6.25%
Management★★☆☆☆6.25%
Jurisdiction★★☆☆☆6.25%
ESG★★★☆☆6.25%
Score by dimension Weighted composite ★★½ (2.43)
Each ring is one star; the outer ring is ★★★★★. Weights in Table 28.

Figure data: Table 28. Each spoke prints its stars and weight; the dashed ring is the weighted composite, 2.43/5.

Table 28. Scorecard rationale

Dimension Weight Score Rationale
1. Asset quality & scale 15% ★★☆☆☆ 15.4 Moz of silver and 147 koz of gold in 2025, the smallest silver output of the five (peers 17.0–48.7 Moz); four mid-sized mines, the largest Los Gatos at 5.87 Moz attributable, whose $15.15/AgEq oz AISC is the one low-cost asset (Tables 2, 5)
2. Cost position & margins 15% ★★★☆☆ 56.8% cash margin in 2025, second of the five (peers 52.6–69.2%); but 2026 AISC guidance of $27.69–28.77/AgEq oz is a third above 2025’s $21.17, with La Encantada above $31 (Tables 3, 5)
3. Reserves, life & replacement 15% ★★☆☆☆ 101.1 Moz of silver reserves is 6.5 years of 2025 output, the shortest of the five (7.4–19.8 years); San Dimas 3.7, Santa Elena 4.8 and La Encantada 5.7 years at current milling, with 145.3 Moz of M&I silver to convert (Tables 2, 4, 5)
5. Balance sheet & liquidity 15% ★★★☆☆ $790.6 m of net cash and $159.9 m undrawn at 30 June 2026 would rate higher alone; against it stand $1.28 bn of SAT reassessments, the 2012 year already lost and $138.9 m of cash frozen (Section 3, Table 7)
6. Capital allocation & returns 15% ★★☆☆☆ Weighted diluted shares from 244.7 m to 484.6 m over 2021–2025 (+98%), against +21% at Hecla, +81% at Pan American, +146% at Coeur and none at Fresnillo; losses in 2021–2024 and a $125.2 m Jerritt Canyon impairment two years after buying it; offset by $315.4 m of 2025 free cash flow and a dividend raised to 2% of revenue (Table 6, Section 4.2)
4. Growth & optionality 6.25% ★★★☆☆ 2026 silver guidance of 14.6–15.5 Moz, −3% on 2025, against −9% to +14% for the peers; the Jerritt Canyon restart on 4.10 Moz of M&I gold and the Santa Elena and Los Gatos expansions (Sections 2.7, 8)
7. Management & governance 6.25% ★★☆☆☆ A founder-CEO since 2001 holding 0.96%; the 2025 say-on-pay failed at 41.01%, where Hecla’s passed with 95.5% and Fresnillo’s remuneration report with 99.22%, and the chair took 50.44%; a board interlock with related party First Mining (Section 4.1)
8. Jurisdiction & geopolitics 6.25% ★★☆☆☆ All four producing mines in Mexico, as at Fresnillo, where Hecla and Coeur earn most of theirs in the US; the 2025 duty reform (8.5% plus 1%), San Martín under criminal control and the SAT disputes (Sections 2, 6)
9. ESG & licence to operate 6.25% ★★★☆☆ Recordable injury rate 0.55 and no fatality in 2025 (one in 2023); ISS ESG top 10%; Jerritt Canyon air-permit notices under appeal (Section 5)
Composite 100% ★★½ Average

Source: each row cites its evidence in this analysis; peer figures are those of Table 5, from each company’s own 2025 filings. Rows 6 and 7 add each peer’s own filings: weighted diluted shares from Hecla’s 2021 and 2025 10-Ks (542.2 m → 655.8 m), Pan American’s 2022 and 2025 statements (210.4 m → 381.6 m), Coeur’s 2021 and 2025 10-Ks (250.0 m → 614.7 m) and Fresnillo’s 2023 and 2025 annual reports (736.9 m throughout); the 2025 votes from Hecla’s 2026 proxy statement and Fresnillo’s 2025 annual report (AGM voting table, all shares). Pan American’s and Coeur’s 2025 say-on-pay results are not in the filings in hand.

Weighted average: (0.15 × 2) + (0.15 × 3) + (0.15 × 2) + (0.15 × 3) + (0.15 × 2) + (0.0625 × 3) + (0.0625 × 2) + (0.0625 × 2) + (0.0625 × 3) = 0.30 + 0.45 + 0.30 + 0.45 + 0.30 + 0.1875 + 0.125 + 0.125 + 0.1875 = 2.43/5 → ★★½, Average (2.425 before rounding).

The two-axis verdict. Quality ★★½ (Average, 2.4/5); value read Overvalued (wide band) as of 1 October 2026, implied −61.9% from $17.66 (501.6 m fully diluted shares) to a $6.73 blended fair value; verdict: Full — the market already sees it. The shares price about $124/oz silver with gold at ~$7,208 against this analysis’s $60 and $4,000 base deck — above both metals’ five-year highs. The target multiples sit 17% below their archetype anchors — P/NAV 0.83×, EV/EBITDA 5.8×, an FCF yield of 8.4% — because asset scale (Dim 1), reserve life (Dim 3), capital allocation (Dim 6) and Mexico (Dim 8) each carry a discount and no dimension earns a premium.

The bull case is cash and torque: an unhedged silver producer with $1.09 bn of cash, a low-cost Los Gatos and a gold restart in Nevada. The bear case is what the price assumes: reserves that run out within six years at three of four mines, a $1.28 bn tax claim in a jurisdiction that has already ruled once against it, and a share count that has nearly doubled. What tips it is the silver price — the read moves up to Modestly overvalued only above about $93/oz with gold near $5,653 — and, over three years, whether conversion keeps the mines’ lives ahead of the mills.

To rank First Majestic against every listed silver producer on the same nine dimensions — reserves, AISC, reserve life and P/NAV — screen the sector on Metal Pilot’s silver mining stock screener.

10. Sources, methodology & disclaimer

10.1 Sources, methodology & data vintage

Company filings. The 2025 Annual Information Form (dated 30 March 2026; reserves and resources, mine descriptions, stream and joint-venture terms, risk factors), the FY2025 audited financial statements and MD&A, the FY2024 MD&A, the 2023 and 2022 statements and MD&As (2023, 2022), the Q2 2026 financial statements and MD&A, the 8 July 2026 production and guidance release, the Jerritt Canyon restart release, the San Martín sale release, the 2026 management information circular, and the 2025 Sustainability Report. Technical reports: San Dimas and La Encantada (NI 43-101, effective 31 August 2025), Santa Elena (NI 43-101, effective 30 June 2021) and Los Gatos (S-K 1300, effective 1 July 2024). Market and peers: stockanalysis.com for the 1 October 2026 close; the World Bank Pink Sheet for metal prices; peer figures per Table 5.

Methodology. The data-as-of date is 1 October 2026: market data is the NYSE close that day ($17.66; 492.9 m basic, 501.6 m fully diluted shares); the balance sheet is 30 June 2026; reserves and resources are effective 31 December 2025; production is FY2025 and H1 2026, with guidance as updated on 8 July 2026. First Majestic reports in US dollars under IFRS. The valuation’s base deck is $60/oz silver and $4,000/oz gold, the representative trailing averages snapped to the fixed $40–80/oz silver and $3,000–5,000/oz gold grids, every grid price run as a scenario. Peers are the listed silver producers above 15 Moz a year; the scorecard uses the producer weighting. Figures not drawn: the asset map (Table 2 carries its read) and the five-year financial chart (it would repeat Table 6). Data gaps to close at the next run: the Los Gatos NI 43-101 technical report effective 25 August 2026 (filed on SEDAR+ only, not in the source set — the AIF’s reserves stand in, which the 25 August 2026 filing release says are unchanged), and the Q3 2026 financial statements (site provisions). Update cadence: refreshed on each annual report and on material events — next, the Jerritt Canyon pre-feasibility study and the FY2026 results.

Re-run log. 2 October 2026 — re-run on the current template from the 11 August 2026 analysis: as-of date moved to 1 October 2026 and the source set to the Q2 2026 filings; the valuation rebuilt on a reproducible model, the accrued SAT liability in the bridge and the open reassessments priced as a sensitivity; composite re-scored from 2.9 to 2.4 against the Fresnillo, Pan American, Coeur and Hecla peer set; value read unchanged at Overvalued (wide band), now implied −62.7% to a $6.59 blended fair value. 18 October 2026 — governance term dropped from the driver line; round 2: peer figures in scorecard rows 6–7, Table 6’s 2021–22 gaps filled from the FY2022–23 MD&As: NAV/share $3.71 unchanged, blend $6.73, implied −61.9%, read unchanged.

Provenance: First Majestic Silver Corp. — Annual Information Form — 2025.

Table 29. Full source register — every figure §7 takes from a filing or a market series

InputValueAs ofWhere §7 uses itSource
Condensed interim consolidated financial statements, 30 June 2026
Cash, revolver and leasescash $1,093.3 m; revolver $0.3 m (accrued fees; undrawn); leases $15.5 m + $12.9 m30 Jun 2026Table 17 — the net-cash line; leases in rows (the AISC carries lease payments)Filed | Q2 2026 FS | Statements of Financial Position | "Cash and cash equivalents" | p.7; Note 21 | p.33
Convertible notes2031 notes $350.0 m, conversion $22.36; 2027 notes: conversion $16.56, 3,338,890 shares issuable, 55,292 notes outstanding30 Jun 2026Table 17 — the 2031 notes at face; the 2027 notes if-converted into the share countFiled | Q2 2026 FS | Note 21(a) | "On December 8, 2025, the Company issued $" | p.34; Note 12 | p.22
HedgesFX derivatives $0.1 m; no long-term metal hedges30 Jun 2026Table 17 — the hedge lineFiled | Q2 2026 FS | Note 25 | "As at June 30, 2026, the Company held $" | p.49
Decommissioning liabilities$188.3 m30 Jun 2026Table 17 — the reclamation line, at carrying valueFiled | Q2 2026 FS | Statements of Financial Position | "Decommissioning liabilities" | p.7
Los Gatos JV (100%)current assets $193.0 m; current liabilities $89.8 m; non-controlling interest $409.3 m (30%)30 Jun 2026Table 17 — the minority line (Dowa's 30% of the JV's balances)Filed | Q2 2026 FS | Note 24 | "Current assets" | p.45
Working capital and restricted cashreceivables $15.7 m; VAT $40.1 m + $11.5 m; payables $202.5 m; income taxes payable $286.1 m; finished goods $15.4 m; coins and bullion $17.9 m; restricted: NDEP trust $20.5 m, SAT-frozen PEM accounts $138.9 m; prepaid expenses and other $23.8 m (declined)30 Jun 2026Table 17 — the working-capital line (prepaid named and declined)Filed | Q2 2026 FS | Statements of Financial Position | "Trade and other receivables", "Value added taxes receivable", "Non-current value added taxes receivable", "Trade and other payables", "Income taxes payable", "Prepaid expenses and other" | p.7; Note 13 | "Finished goods", "Silver coins and bullion" | p.23; Note 19 | "Nevada Division of Environmental Protection", "SAT Primero tax dispute (2)" | p.32
Investments and other assetsmarketable securities $155.1 m; Del Toro deferred consideration $10.0 m; Springpole stream at cost $16.0 m30 Jun 2026Table 17 — the investments lineFiled | Q2 2026 FS | Note 14 | "Total other financial assets" | p.23; Statements of Financial Position | "Non-current trade and other receivable" | p.7; Note 16 | "At June 30, 2026" (Springpole stream) | p.26
Wheaton gold stream, San Dimas25% of gold-equivalent production at 70:1; delivered at $648/oz in Q2 202630 Jun 2026Table 15, block 1 and Table 21 — the Wheaton ounces and their priceFiled | Q2 2026 FS | Note 6(c) | "which entitles WPMI to receive" | p.20
Stock optionsweighted-average exercise price C$13.7430 Jun 2026Table 17 — the treasury-method option countFiled | Q2 2026 FS | Note 23(b) | "Balance, end of the period" | p.41
SAT reassessments, PEM (San Dimas)2010 $39.5 m; 2011 $117.0 m; 2012 $220.9 m; 2013 $199.6 m; 2014–16 $508.7 m; 2017 $75.7 m; 2018 $115 m; $1.28 bn in all30 Jun 2026Table 17 note 1 — the SAT contingency, a sensitivity outside the bridgeFiled | Q2 2026 FS | Note 27(b) | "In 2019, the SAT issued reassessments for the 2010" | p.51
Other SAT assessmentsLa Encantada (MLE, CFM) $43.1, $31.4, $19.9, $250.2, $3.5, $7.5 m (2012–17); San Martín (MEP) $21.9 m + $5.6 m; La Parrilla (FMP) $71.4 m + $2.7 m + $2.5 m; Del Toro (FMDT, retained) $29.6 m; CFM 2016 $84.3 m30 Jun 2026Table 17 note 1 — the SAT contingency; San Martín's excluded (it leaves with El Pilón)Filed | Q2 2026 FS | Note 27(c)–(g) | "La Encantada Tax Re-assessments" | p.54–55
Dividends declared, 2026$0.0152 (29 Jul, after the quarter); $0.0083 (Feb); $0.0171 (May) per share29 Jul 2026Table 17 — the July dividend deducted from cash; Table 24 — the dividend yieldFiled | Q2 2026 FS | Note 28 | "Declaration of Quarterly Dividend" | p.56; Note 23(f) | p.44
H1 2026 depletion and depreciation$104.5 m, of which Los Gatos (100%) $55.7 mH1 2026Table 23 — the cash-tax base, attributable, annualisedFiled | Q2 2026 FS | Statements of Earnings | "Depletion, depreciation and amortization" | p.4; Note 5 | p.17
Jerritt Canyon capital spent, H1 2026$9.8 mH1 2026Table 15, blocks 5 and 6 — the restart budget still to spendFiled | Q2 2026 FS | Note 5 | six months to 30 June 2026 | "Jerritt Canyon (2) | 2026" (capital expenditures column) | p.17
Q2 2026 MD&A, 30 July 2026
Share data492,906,383 shares; 5,955,585 options; share-settled RSUs 1,441,255, DSUs 30,161, PSUs 1,134,07429 Jul 2026Table 17 — the fully diluted share countFiled | Q2 2026 MD&A | Outstanding Share Data | "As at July 29, 2026, the Company has" | p.51
Los Gatos (70%) — H1 2026437,986 t milled; silver 2,462,641 oz, gold 1,427 oz, zinc 31,892,459 lb, lead 17,723,325 lb, copper 515,851 lb; recoveries Ag 86%, Au 48%, Zn 73%, Pb 87%, Cu 63%H1 2026Table 15, block 4 — the depletion to 30 Jun 2026, the recoveries and the throughputFiled | Q2 2026 MD&A | six months to 30 June 2026 | "Total ore processed/tonnes milled" | p.18
Santa Elena — H1 2026589,606 t milled; silver 778,398 oz, gold 42,585 oz; recoveries Ag 68%, Au 95%H1 2026Table 15, block 2 — the depletion to 30 Jun 2026, the recoveries and the throughputFiled | Q2 2026 MD&A | six months to 30 June 2026 | "Total ore processed/tonnes milled" | p.20
San Dimas — H1 2026439,004 t milled; silver 2,239,888 oz, gold 24,926 oz; recoveries Ag 88%, Au 94%H1 2026Table 15, block 1 — the depletion to 30 Jun 2026, the recoveries and the throughputFiled | Q2 2026 MD&A | six months to 30 June 2026 | "Total ore processed/tonnes milled" | p.22
La Encantada — H1 2026633,051 t milled; silver 1,864,578 oz; recovery Ag 72%H1 2026Table 15, block 3 — the depletion to 30 Jun 2026, the recoveries and the throughputFiled | Q2 2026 MD&A | six months to 30 June 2026 | "Ore processed/tonnes milled" | p.24
2026 capital guidancesustaining $62–70 m; expansionary $256–274 m, of which the Jerritt Canyon restart $75 m30 Jul 2026Table 15, blocks 5 and 6 — the remaining 2026 capital; Table 23 — sustaining and growth capitalFiled | Q2 2026 MD&A | Capital Expenditures in 2026 | "for expansionary projects" | p.13
H1 2026 capital spentQ2 attributable $60.1 m; H1 sustaining $27.3 mH1 2026Table 15, block 5 — the capital already spentFiled | Q2 2026 MD&A | Highlights | "Capital expenditures attributable to the Company in the second quarter" | p.6; Non-GAAP free cash flow | "Less: Sustaining capital expenditures" | p.61
2026 AISC build (per AgEq oz)G&A $2.04–2.16; share-based $0.65–0.70; profit sharing $2.16–2.29; leases $0.79–0.8530 Jul 2026Table 17 — capitalised corporate G&A; Tables 21 and 23 — profit sharing, G&A and leasesFiled | Q2 2026 MD&A | 2026 Guidance Update | "Profit Sharing" | p.13
Jerritt Canyon holding costs$4.5 m in Q2 2026Q2 2026Table 15, block 6 — holding to the restartFiled | Q2 2026 MD&A | Jerritt Canyon | "holding costs at Jerritt Canyon" | p.27
Q2 2026 production and updated 2026 guidance release, 8 July 2026
San Dimas — 2026 guidance4.6–4.9 Moz silver; 52–56 koz gold; cash cost $18.79–19.42, AISC $25.38–26.42/AgEq oz8 Jul 2026Table 15, block 1 — the AISC per year; Table 21 — volumes and cash costsFiled | Q2 2026 production release | 2026 Updated Full Year Mine-by-Mine Guidance | "San Dimas, Mexico" | p.5
Santa Elena — 2026 guidance1.4–1.5 Moz silver; 72–76 koz gold; cash cost $19.86–20.32, AISC $25.09–25.83/AgEq oz8 Jul 2026Table 15, block 2 — the AISC per year; Table 21 — volumes and cash costsFiled | Q2 2026 production release | 2026 Updated Full Year Mine-by-Mine Guidance | "Santa Elena, Mexico" | p.5
La Encantada — 2026 guidance3.4–3.6 Moz silver; cash cost $24.50–25.21, AISC $31.18–32.36/AgEq oz8 Jul 2026Table 15, block 3 — the AISC per year; Table 21 — volumes and cash costsFiled | Q2 2026 production release | 2026 Updated Full Year Mine-by-Mine Guidance | "La Encantada, Mexico" | p.5
Los Gatos (70%) — 2026 guidance5.1–5.5 Moz silver; 3–4 koz gold; lead 32–34 Mlb; zinc 53–56 Mlb; copper 1.0–1.1 Mlb; cash cost $16.56–17.10, AISC $20.35–21.11/AgEq oz8 Jul 2026Table 15, block 4 — the AISC per year; Table 21 — volumes and cash costsFiled | Q2 2026 production release | 2026 Updated Full Year Mine-by-Mine Guidance | "Los Gatos (70%), Mexico" | p.5
Consolidated — 2026 guidance14.6–15.5 Moz silver; 128–135 koz gold; consolidated AISC $27.69–28.77/AgEq oz8 Jul 2026Table 17 — the corporate G&A baseFiled | Q2 2026 production release | 2026 Updated Full Year Mine-by-Mine Guidance | "Total Consolidated" | p.5
Prices behind the cost guidancesilver $52.00/oz; gold $3,900/oz; lead $0.90/lb; zinc $1.35/lb; copper $4.80/lb; gold-to-silver 75:18 Jul 2026Table 15 — the payable AgEq the AISC is struck onFiled | Q2 2026 production release | cost guidance basis | "using a fixed gold-to-silver ratio of" | p.6
San Martín sale release, 7 July 2026
San Martín sale to Flextronics$90 m: $2.5 m at closing; $2.5 m within 180 days; $10 m on each of five anniversaries; $35.0 m on 31 Aug 20326 Jul 2026Table 17 — the investments line, at present valueFiled | San Martín sale release | Transaction Details | "for total cash consideration of US$90 million" | p.1
Jerritt Canyon restart release, 2 April 2026
Jerritt Canyon restart budget$75 m in 2026; production targeted H2 20272 Apr 2026Table 15, block 6 — the restart capitalFiled | Jerritt Canyon restart release | Table 1 | "TOTAL" | p.2
Q1 2026 MD&A
Q1 2026 capital spentattributable $44.7 mQ1 2026Table 15, block 5 — the capital already spentFiled | Q1 2026 MD&A | Highlights | "Capital expenditures attributable to the Company in the first quarter" | p.6
Audited consolidated financial statements, year ended 31 December 2025
SAT 2012 reassessment, lostaccrued $147.2 m (net $131.5 m); reassessed at $211.9 m31 Dec 2025Table 17 note 1 — the realisation ratio of the SAT sensitivityFiled | FY2025 FS | Note 24 | "additional tax accrual of $" | p.66; Note 29(b) | p.81
Income-tax noteCanadian statutory rate 27%; Mexican non-capital losses $498.5 m (declined)31 Dec 2025Table 17 — corporate G&A after tax; Table 15 — the no-shield basis and its boundFiled | FY2025 FS | Note 24 | "Combined statutory tax rate" | p.66; p.68
Decommissioning by siteLos Gatos $11.2 m; Jerritt Canyon $119.3 m31 Dec 2025Table 17 — the minority line; the reclamation lineFiled | FY2025 FS | Note 23 | "Balance at December 31, 2025" | p.65
Dividend declared November 2025$0.0052 per share4 Nov 2025Table 24 — the trailing dividend yieldFiled | FY2025 FS | Note 25(f) | "November 4, 2025" | p.74
La Encantada NI 43-101 technical report (effective 31 August 2025)
La Encantada payable sharesilver 99.60% payable (NSR assumption)31 Aug 2025Table 15, block 3 — the payable factorFiled | La Encantada technical report | NSR assumptions | "Ag Payable" | p.141
MD&A, year ended 31 December 2025
2025 production15,435,506 oz silver; 147,433 oz goldFY2025Table 24 — reserve replacementFiled | FY2025 MD&A | Key Performance Metrics | "Silver Ounces Produced" | p.4
2025 Annual Information Form (dated 30 March 2026)
San Dimas reserves3.70 Mt @ 195 g/t Ag, 2.43 g/t Au; 23.16 Moz Ag, 0.289 Moz Au; payable 99.95%31 Dec 2025Table 15, block 1Filed | AIF 2025 | Table 10 | "Total Proven + Probable (UG) Sulphides" | p.36
Santa Elena reservesErmitaño 4.07 Mt @ 1.35 g/t Au, 4.45 Moz Ag; Santa Elena UG 1.60 Mt @ 1.12 g/t Au, 6.01 Moz Ag; stockpile 0.24 Mt @ 1.74 g/t Au, 0.35 Moz Ag; pad 0.39 Mt @ 0.42 g/t Au, 0.33 Moz Ag; Santa Elena ore recovery Ag 92.7%, Au 94.4%; payable Ag 99.85%, Au 99.80%31 Dec 2025Table 15, block 2 — gold as tonnes × gradeFiled | AIF 2025 | Table 16 | "Proven + Probable Ermitaño (UG) Sulphides" | p.49
Royal Gold stream, Santa Elena20% of pad and designated-area gold at the lesser of market and $487.3/oz31 Dec 2025Table 15, block 2 — the Royal Gold ouncesFiled | AIF 2025 | Santa Elena | "Gold to receive 20% of the gold production" | p.41
La Encantada reservesunderground 10.45 + 5.42 Moz Ag; tailings 4.37 Mt, 15.63 Moz Ag at 25% recovery; total 7.87 Mt, 31.50 Moz31 Dec 2025Table 15, block 3Filed | AIF 2025 | Table 28 | "Total Probable (UG + Tailings) All Mineral Types" | p.79
La Encantada LOM cash costmine $47.8/t; tailings $26.6/t31 Dec 2025Table 15, block 3 — the tailings cost ratioFiled | AIF 2025 | La Encantada operating costs | "La Encantada Tailings Mining Operating Costs" | p.83
Los Gatos reserves (70%)9.55 Mt; 35.28 Moz Ag; 0.058 Moz Au; 39.10 Mlb Cu; 371.41 Mlb Pb; 685.92 Mlb Zn; payable Ag 92%, Zn 77%, Pb 94%, Au 84%, Cu 0%; LOM 9.4 years from 1 Jan 202631 Dec 2025Table 15, block 4 — metal, payables and the lifeFiled | AIF 2025 | Table 22 | "Proven + Probable CLG" | p.62; note 4 | p.63; Los Gatos | p.66
Measured and indicated, inclusive of reservesSan Dimas 45.42 Moz Ag, 0.56 Moz Au; Santa Elena 21.09 Moz Ag, 0.51 Moz Au; La Encantada 36.43 Moz Ag; Los Gatos (70%) 42.35 Moz Ag, 0.07 Moz Au, 842.56 Mlb Zn, 450.17 Mlb Pb; Jerritt Canyon 4.10 Moz Au31 Dec 2025Table 15, blocks 6 and 7 — Jerritt Canyon and the exclusive M&IFiled | AIF 2025 | Table 2 | San Dimas "Total Measured + Indicated (UG) Sulphides"; Santa Elena "Total Measured + Indicated (UG + Stockpile) Sulphides"; La Encantada "Total Indicated (UG + Tailings) All Mineral Types"; Los Gatos "Total Measured + Indicated (UG) All Mineral Types"; Jerritt Canyon "Total Measured + Indicated (UG + OP) Sulphides" | p.24
Mexican mining taxesSpecial Mining Duty 8.5%, deductible; income tax 30%31 Dec 2025Table 15 — every Mexican block's after-tax marginFiled | AIF 2025 | Risk Factors — Taxation | "Special Mining Duty –" | p.136
Consolidated reserves and inferredP&P 101.07 Moz silver, 0.61 Moz gold; inferred 113.47 Moz silver, 5.15 Moz gold31 Dec 2025Table 24 — reserve replacement and optionalityFiled | AIF 2025 | Table 1 | "Total Proven and Probable All mineral types" | p.22; Table 3 | "Total Inferred (All Areas) All Mineral Types" | p.24
San Martín closure provision$8.6 m31 Dec 2025Table 17 — leaves with El Pilón on the saleFiled | AIF 2025 | Risk Factors | "for the San Martin Silver Mine" | p.116
2024 Annual Information Form
Consolidated reserves, prior year86,885 koz silver; 594 koz gold31 Dec 2024Table 24 — reserve replacementFiled | AIF 2024 | Table 1 | "Total Proven and Probable | All mineral types" | p.25
Market and price series
Exchange rateUS$1 = C$1.42431 Oct 2026Table 17 — the treasury test on the C$ optionsMarket | Bank of Canada | "USD/CAD" daily rate | 1 Oct 2026
Silver trailing averages3-month $63.63; 6-month $70.45; 12-month $66.80; five-year $34.15to 31 Aug 2026§7 opening — the $60 silver baseMarket | World Bank Pink Sheet | "Silver", monthly | release of 2 Sep 2026, to Aug 2026
Gold trailing averages3-month $4,237; 6-month $4,479; 12-month $4,398; five-year $2,645to 31 Aug 2026§7 opening — the $4,000 gold baseMarket | World Bank Pink Sheet | "Gold", monthly | release of 2 Sep 2026, to Aug 2026
Base-metal 3-month averageszinc $3,671/t; lead $1,881/t; copper $13,807/tto 31 Aug 2026§7 opening — the by-product basesMarket | World Bank Pink Sheet | "Zinc", "Lead", "Copper", monthly | to Aug 2026
Five-year monthly rangesilver $92.1 (Jan 2026) to $18.9 (Sep 2022); gold $5,020 (Feb 2026) to $1,664 (Oct 2022)Sep 2021 – Aug 2026Table 24 — the range the market-implied deck is read againstMarket | World Bank Pink Sheet | "Silver", "Gold", monthly | Sep 2021 – Aug 2026
Agency forecast decksilver $70.0 (2026), $65.0 (2027); gold $4,700, $4,30028 Apr 2026§7 opening and Table 24 — the 0%-weight forecast deckMarket | World Bank Commodity Markets Outlook | "Silver", "Gold" forecasts | April 2026, p.21
Own EV/EBITDA history17.64× (2021), 25.02× (2022), n/m (2023), 13.47× (2024), 11.85× (2025); 8.15× trailing at 1 Oct 20262021–2026Table 24 — own-multiple historyDerived | year-end NYSE close (31 Dec 2021 $11.11; 30 Dec 2022 $8.34; 29 Dec 2023 $6.15; 31 Dec 2024 $5.49; 31 Dec 2025 $16.66) × year-end shares + debt + leases − cash (+ non-controlling interest at book from 2025) ÷ earnings before tax + finance costs + D&A; FY2022–FY2025 FS, statements of financial position, earnings and changes in equity; trailing: FY2025 − H1 2025 + H1 2026 (Q2 2026 FS p.4) at the $17.66 close
Silver precedent transactionsPan American–MAG $2.1 bn for 58 Moz silver reserves; Coeur–SilverCrest $1.7 bn less $122 m treasury for 33.5 Moz silver and 357 koz gold2024–2025Table 24 — transaction comparablesMarket | Pan American release | "Agreement to Acquire MAG Silver" | 11 May 2025; Coeur releases | 4 Oct 2024 and 18 Feb 2025

Source: the filings and market series named in each row — the 2025 Annual Information Form, the 2024 Annual Information Form, the FY2025 financial statements and MD&A, the Q1 2026 MD&A, the Q2 2026 MD&A and financial statements, the Q2 2026 production and guidance release, the San Martín sale release, the Jerritt Canyon restart release, the La Encantada technical report, the World Bank Pink Sheet and Commodity Markets Outlook, April 2026, and stockanalysis.com; page numbers are those of each filed document as rendered on EDGAR, the AIF’s its printed page numbers.

10.2 Disclaimer & disclosure

This analysis is for informational purposes only and is not investment advice, a recommendation, or an offer to buy or sell any security. It is a point-in-time snapshot as of 1 October 2026: the share price, market capitalisation, enterprise value, multiples and valuation read all move, and silver-mining equities are especially volatile. Reserve, resource, study and forecast figures are estimates, prepared on the codes and bases stated beside each table. This report was prepared with AI assistance; figures were sourced from primary filings and reviewed, but readers should verify every number against the original documents before acting on it. The author holds no position in First Majestic Silver Corp. or in any company named here. Please do your own research and consult a licensed financial adviser.