Matador Resources (MTDR) — Stock Analysis 2026 [3.1]
Analysis as of 16 October 2026. Matador Resources stock analysis. Price deck: base WTI US$80/bbl — the representative trailing average on the fixed US$60–100 grid — with every grid price run as a scenario (deep bear US$60, US$70, base US$80, US$90, deep bull US$100), Henry Hub held at US$3.00/MMBtu, and the SEC’s 2025 reserve prices as a 0% cross-check — no spot price. Shares at US$53.77 (NYSE close, 15 October 2026); the market-implied deck is ~US$86.07/bbl WTI. Refreshed on each annual report and each quarterly report. Rating: ★★★ Average / Modestly overvalued (wide band).
Matador Resources is an E&P producer in the oil and gas sector: a Dallas-based operator that produced 207,070 boe/d in 2025, 98% of it from the Delaware Basin, with 667.0 mmboe of SEC proved reserves and a 51% stake in the San Mateo midstream joint venture. The thesis in one line: a low-cost, oil-weighted Permian driller whose cash flow is worth more than its proved book, priced for an oil deck above the US$80 base. It is worth a look now because the US$1.255 billion Paloma acquisition closed on 5 October 2026, lifting debt just as the first-half gas price at Waha turned negative. To screen Matador against every North American upstream name on the same fields, go to Metal Pilot’s upstream oil & gas stock screener.
1. Snapshot & thesis
Figure 1. Matador in numbers, as of 16 October 2026
overvalued
Figure data: Table 1, this analysis.
Table 1. Matador in numbers
| Metric | Value | Basis / date |
|---|---|---|
| Listing | NYSE: MTDR | listed 2 Feb 2012 |
| Share price | US$53.77 | NYSE close, 15 Oct 2026 (US$42.44 at the 2025 year-end) |
| 1-year closing range | US$37.19 – US$65.45 | 5 Nov 2025 – 27 Mar 2026 |
| Shares | 124.0 m outstanding · 125.057 m fully diluted | 30 Jun 2026; equity-settled RSUs and performance stock units added — the valuation’s share basis |
| Market capitalisation | US$6,667.4 m | 15 Oct 2026, outstanding shares |
| Production | 207,070 boe/d FY2025 (75.6 mmboe/yr) · 215,631 boe/d Q2 2026 | 58% oil |
| Proved reserves | 667.0 mmboe · PV-10 US$8,237.8 m | SEC basis, 31 Dec 2025, audited by NSAI |
| Cash margin | US$28.25/boe (66% of revenue per boe) | FY2025; realised oil and gas revenue less LOE, transport, midstream, production taxes and G&A |
| Net debt / Adjusted EBITDA | 1.83× · 2.37× with Paloma | US$4,190.1 m at 30 Jun 2026 on FY2025 US$2,294.6 m |
| NAV per share | US$21.03 (P/NAV 2.56×) | proved, risked; US$80 WTI, 10% |
| Blended fair value | US$45.78 (range US$13.38 – US$86.19) | US$60 – US$100 WTI |
| Valuation read | Modestly overvalued (wide band) · implied −14.9% | §7 |
| Quality rating | ★★★ Average | §9 |
Source: Matador filings on SEC EDGAR — 10-K 2025 (production, reserves, unit costs, EBITDA), 10-Q Q2 2026 (shares, debt, cash); Yahoo Finance MTDR history, 15 Oct 2026; NAV, blend and read from Section 7.
Matador Resources Company (NYSE: MTDR) explores for, develops and produces oil and natural gas, almost all of it in the Delaware Basin of Southeast New Mexico and West Texas, where it holds about 240,000 net acres after its two July 2026 acquisitions. It reports two streams, oil and natural gas, with NGL revenue inside gas. Its midstream business, San Mateo, is 51% owned with Five Point Infrastructure. Reserves are audited each year by Netherland, Sewell & Associates under SEC rules, and it reports in US dollars under US GAAP.
Thesis in brief. The bull case: 173% reserve replacement in 2025, an LOE of US$5.50/boe and US$6.45 a share of forward free cash flow at US$80 WTI — a 12.0% yield. The bear case: the proved book supports only US$21.03 a share once US$7,444.0 m of claims leave the bridge, Paloma lifts net debt to about US$5.4 billion, and gas realised below zero at Waha in the first half. What tips it is WTI against the ~US$86.07 the price assumes: below ~US$73.84 the read turns Overvalued.
How to read this analysis: the statcards and Section 9 carry the verdict; Sections 2–7 carry the evidence, Section 7 the valuation.
2. Assets & operations
Matador sells into the oil market covered in Oil — A Complete Market Guide; 58% of its 2025 output and 88% of its oil and gas revenue was crude.
2.1 Portfolio overview
Table 2. Portfolio at a glance
| Asset | Country | Stage | Interest | Output | Proved reserves | Life | Unit cost | Listing / operator |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Delaware Basin (NM, TX) | United States | Producing | Operated working interests; ~240,000 net acres | 203,330 boe/d (FY2025) | 667.0 mmboe (company total, 31 Dec 2025) | 8.8 yrs | LOE US$5.50/boe | NYSE: MTDR, operator |
| Paloma (Delaware Basin, NM) | United States | Producing; closed 5 Oct 2026 | 100% | ~11,100 boe/d (57% oil) | 55 mmboe | 13.6 yrs | n/d | NYSE: MTDR, operator |
| San Mateo Midstream | United States | Operating | 51% (Five Point 49%) | US$278.3 m segment operating income (FY2025) | — | — | — | NYSE: MTDR, 51% owner |
| Ridge Runner Woodford acreage | United States | Undeveloped | 100% | — | unbooked | — | — | NYSE: MTDR |
| Areas outside the Delaware Basin | United States | Producing | — | 3,740 boe/d (FY2025) | in the company total | — | — | NYSE: MTDR |
Source: Matador filings on SEC EDGAR — 10-K 2025 Item 2 (p.14, p.18) and Item 1 (p.7); Paloma acquisition and closing releases (2026). Paloma’s life is its 55 mmboe over 11,100 boe/d annualised.
Concentration is near total: the Delaware Basin carried 98.2% of 2025 production, and Paloma adds acreage in the same basin. San Mateo gathers and processes Matador’s own volumes, so its margin sits inside the reserve value rather than beside it. Paloma adds about 11,100 boe/d, 5.1% of the second-quarter rate, and 55 mmboe, 8.2% of the year-end proved book; Ridge Runner adds acreage but no booked volume. The 3,740 boe/d outside the Delaware Basin are reported only inside the company total.
2.2 Revenue split
Figure 2. FY2025 oil and gas revenue by product
Figure data: 10-K 2025, Item 2 (p.14) — oil 43.70 mmbbl at US$64.99/bbl, gas 191.3 bcf at US$2.08/mcf.
Figure 3. FY2025 production by area
Figure data: 10-K 2025, Item 2 (p.14).
Oil earned US$2,840.0 m on 43.70 mmbbl and gas US$397.9 m on 191.3 bcf: crude is 57.8% of volume but 87.7% of revenue. Gas earns little: at US$2.08/mcf in 2025 a boe of gas fetched US$12.48 against US$64.99 for a barrel of oil, and in the first half of 2026 it fetched nothing at the wellhead. The other US$458.4 m of 2025’s US$3,696.3 m total revenue came from midstream services, purchased-gas sales and derivatives, which the facts do not split.
2.3 Delaware Basin
The Delaware Basin produced 203,330 boe/d in 2025 and holds the company’s proved book: 667.0 mmboe at 31 December 2025, 408.0 mmboe developed and 259.1 mmboe undeveloped (38.8%), 376.0 mmbbl of oil and 1,746.4 bcf of gas, audited by NSAI within the 10% SPE tolerance at the SEC’s US$61.82/bbl and US$3.39/MMBtu. PV-10 is US$8,237.8 m and the after-tax Standardized Measure US$6,986.6 m. Proved developed reserves carry US$6,042.3 m of that PV-10, 73.3%, on 223.0 mmbbl of oil and 1,109.8 bcf of gas; the undeveloped tranche carries US$2,195.4 m on 153.0 mmbbl and 636.6 bcf and still needs capital — the Standardized Measure deducts US$2,683.4 m of future development costs. Output rose to 215,631 boe/d in the second quarter of 2026 (58% oil), and 2026 guidance is 218,500–223,500 boe/d including the July deals. Lease operating expense was US$5.50/boe in 2025 and US$5.45 in the second quarter. Locations, type curves and well costs are not in the files read. The one asset risk is gas takeaway: first-half 2026 gas realised US$(0.09)/mcf at Waha.
2.4 Paloma acquisition
Paloma was announced in July 2026 at US$1.275 billion cash and closed on 5 October 2026 for US$1.255 billion. It brings about 11,100 boe/d (57% oil), 55 mmboe of proved reserves and 156 net locations, with a PV-10 of US$816 m at US$70/bbl and US$3.00/MMBtu (31 May 2026). The price is 1.54× that PV-10 and about US$113,000 per flowing boe/d. Its reserves enter the valuation as their own row; the cash enters as post-period debt.
2.5 San Mateo Midstream
San Mateo, 51% Matador and 49% Five Point, earned segment operating income of US$278.3 m in 2025 plus US$57.4 m of D&A, and US$134.0 m in the first half of 2026. Segment assets were US$1,900.6 m at 30 June 2026. Its US$911.0 m credit facility is non-recourse to Matador. In the first half, San Mateo distributed US$61.7 m to Matador and US$59.3 m to Five Point. The segment also holds wholly owned midstream assets, so it overstates San Mateo alone. Its value reaches Matador twice: as the margin on Matador’s own barrels, already inside the reserve values, and as distributions. Five Point’s 49% is a claim on that cash flow, and Section 7 deducts it in the bridge.
2.6 Woodford acreage and other interests
Ridge Runner, the second July 2026 deal, adds mostly undeveloped Woodford acreage, taking the Woodford position to about 50,000 contiguous net acres; its price is not disclosed and no reserves are booked. Matador also holds about 19% of Piñon Midstream’s parent, with no filed carrying value.
2.7 Production, reserves & costs
Table 3. Production, reserves and unit costs
| Metric | FY2024 | FY2025 | 2026 to date |
|---|---|---|---|
| Production (boe/d) | 170,751 | 207,070 | 215,631 (Q2) |
| Oil (bbl/d) | 99,808 | 119,723 | 126,106 (Q2) |
| Realised oil (US$/bbl) | 75.89 | 64.99 | 85.86 (H1) |
| Realised gas incl. NGLs (US$/mcf) | 2.38 | 2.08 | (0.09) (H1) |
| Lease operating (US$/boe) | 5.20 | 5.50 | 5.45 (Q2) |
| Transportation & processing (US$/boe) | 0.94 | 0.88 | n/d |
| Midstream operating (US$/boe) | 2.68 | 2.75 | n/d |
| Production & ad valorem taxes (US$/boe) | 4.30 | 3.65 | n/d |
| G&A (US$/boe) | 2.04 | 1.81 | n/d |
| DD&A (US$/boe) | 15.59 | 15.82 | n/d |
| Proved reserves (mmboe) | 611.5 | 667.0 | — |
Source: Matador filings on SEC EDGAR — 10-K 2025 Item 2 (p.14, p.18); 10-Q Q2 2026 MD&A (p.28, p.31); Q2 2026 results release.
Figure 4. Production, FY2024 to 2026 guidance
Figure data: Table 3; H1 2026 211,635 boe/d (10-Q Q2 2026, p.31); 2026 guidance 218,500–223,500 boe/d (Q2 2026 results release, p.5).
Proved reserves rose 9.1% in 2025 after 75.6 mmboe of production — 173% replacement, acquisitions included — but the proved life is 8.8 years, the short span of an SEC proved-only shale book. Oil realised 14% less in 2025 than 2024; the cost lines moved by cents. DD&A of US$15.82/boe against LOE of US$5.50 shows where the cost sits: in drilling the wells, not in running them.
2.8 Peer positioning
The peer set is three US oil-weighted independents: Permian Resources (NYSE: PR), SM Energy (NYSE: SM) and Crescent Energy (NYSE: CRGY), on their FY2025 10-Ks; none is in a pending deal.
Table 4. Peer reserve metrics, 31 December 2025
| Company | Listing | Proved reserves (mmboe) | Undeveloped share | Proved PV-10 (US$ m) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Matador Resources | NYSE: MTDR | 667.0 | 38.8% | 8,237.8 |
| Permian Resources | NYSE: PR | 1,116.3 | 28.9% | 9,439.3 |
| SM Energy | NYSE: SM | 673.0 | 38.7% | 6,847 |
| Crescent Energy | NYSE: CRGY | 975.5 | 20.4% | 8,633 |
Source: SEC EDGAR — FY2025 10-Ks: Matador Item 2 (p.18), Permian Resources Item 2 (p.10), SM Energy Item 2 (p.13), Crescent Energy Item 2 (p.15). Permian Resources’ PV-10 is its filed pre-tax PV 10%.
Matador’s proved book is the smallest of the four and third on PV-10, but it carries the most value per barrel: US$12.35 of PV-10 per proved boe against US$10.17 at SM, US$8.85 at Crescent and US$8.46 at Permian Resources.
3. Financials & balance sheet
Table 5. Five-year financial summary (US$ m unless stated)
| Metric | 2021 | 2022 | 2023 | 2024 | 2025 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue | 1,663.0 | 3,058.0 | 2,806.8 | 3,505.0 | 3,696.3 |
| Revenue YoY | — | +83.9% | −8.2% | +24.9% | +5.5% |
| Adjusted EBITDA, attributable | 1,052.0 | 2,127.2 | 1,849.5 | 2,298.8 | 2,294.6 |
| Adjusted EBITDA margin | 63.3% | 69.6% | 65.9% | 65.6% | 62.1% |
| Net income, attributable | 585.0 | 1,214.2 | 846.1 | 885.3 | 759.2 |
| Diluted EPS (US$) | 4.91 | 10.11 | 7.05 | 7.14 | 6.09 |
| Operating cash flow | 1,053.4 | 1,978.7 | 1,867.8 | 2,246.9 | 2,425.0 |
| D/C/E capex (sustaining / growth n/d) | 431.1 | 771.8 | 1,192.8 | 1,222.8 | 1,542.3 |
| FCF (OCF − D/C/E capex) | 622.2 | 1,206.9 | 675.0 | 1,024.1 | 882.8 |
| Net debt, year-end | 1,479.4 | 655.1 | 2,154.0 | 3,302.4 | 3,386.8 |
| Net debt / Adj. EBITDA | 1.41× | 0.31× | 1.16× | 1.44× | 1.48× |
| Diluted shares (m) | 119.2 | 120.1 | 120.0 | 124.1 | 124.6 |
| DPS declared (US$) | 0.125 | 0.30 | 0.65 | 0.85 | 1.3125 |
Source: Matador filings on SEC EDGAR — 10-K 2025 (2023–2025: statements of operations and cash flows, MD&A p.81, EPS note p.117) and 10-K 2023 (2021–2022, p.79, p.85, p.123); net debt from the debt notes (10-K 2023 p.136, 10-K 2024 p.134). FCF excludes midstream capex. Net income: 10-K 2023 p.81 and 10-K 2025 p.77; DPS declared: equity statements, 10-K 2023 p.115 and 10-K 2025 p.109. Net debt for 2021: 10-K 2022 balance sheet (p.112).
Figure 5. Free cash flow, 2021–2025 (US$ m)
Figure data: Table 5.
Revenue rose 5.5% in 2025 on more volume and a lower oil price; Adjusted EBITDA was flat at US$2,294.6 m and operating cash flow, US$2,425.0 m, ran well ahead of US$759.2 m of net income because US$15.82/boe of DD&A and US$165.6 m of deferred tax are non-cash. In the first half of 2026 operating cash flow was US$1,407.7 m against US$745.3 m of D/C/E capex. The Adjusted EBITDA margin has eased from 69.6% in 2022 to 62.1% as realised oil fell from US$77.88 in 2023 to US$64.99 in 2025. The Financial Metrics guide defines each line.
Table 6. Cost deck — FY2025 and 2026 guidance
| Item | FY2025 | 2026 guidance (prior → new, 5 Aug 2026) |
|---|---|---|
| Operating expenses, six lines incl. DD&A (US$/boe) | 30.41 | 31.00–33.00 → 32.00–34.00 |
| of which DD&A (US$/boe) | 15.82 | 15.85–16.15 |
| Production & ad valorem taxes (% of revenue) | 8.5% | — |
| Current income tax (% of pretax income) | US$7.1 m current tax | 0–1% |
| D/C/E capex (US$ m) | 1,542.3 | midpoint 1,395 → 1,520 (range 1,480–1,560) |
| Midstream capex, Matador share (US$ m) | n/d | 100–110 → 145–165 |
Source: Matador filings on SEC EDGAR — 10-K 2025 Item 2 (p.14) and MD&A; Q2 2026 results release, guidance table (p.5). The FY2025 total is LOE, transport, midstream, production taxes, G&A and DD&A per boe; the guidance includes Paloma and Ridge Runner from their close.
Production taxes take 8.5% of revenue and move with price. Cash taxes stay low: US$43.0 m paid in 2025, US$26.8 m refunded in the first half of 2026, with US$118.9 m of loss carryforwards booked as a deferred-tax asset.
Table 7. Debt and liquidity, 30 June 2026
| Instrument | Maturity | US$ m | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Credit Agreement (reserve-based) | 2029 | 939.0 | US$1,180 m drawn on 5 Aug 2026; base US$3.25 bn, commitments US$2.75 bn |
| San Mateo Credit Facility | 2029 | 911.0 | Non-recourse to Matador |
| 6.500% senior notes | 2032 | 900.0 | |
| 6.250% senior notes | 2033 | 750.0 | |
| 6.000% senior notes | 2034 | 750.0 | |
| Issuance costs and discounts | — | (33.6) | |
| Total long-term debt | 4,216.4 | ||
| Cash | (26.3) | Restricted cash of US$64.6 m excluded | |
| Net debt | 4,190.1 | 1.83× FY2025 Adjusted EBITDA | |
| Paloma cash paid, 5 Oct 2026 | 1,255.0 | Post-period | |
| Net debt with Paloma | 5,445.1 | 2.37× FY2025; 1.87× forward EBITDA at US$80, 2.21× at US$70 |
Source: Matador 10-Q Q2 2026 on SEC EDGAR — Note 5 debt (p.11) and balance sheet (p.3); Paloma closing release. Forward EBITDA from the model in Section 7.
The credit agreement caps debt at 3.5× EBITDA. No note matures before 2032. The asset-retirement obligation is US$155.2 m. The reserve-based facility is the swing line: US$398.0 m drawn at the 2025 year-end, US$939.0 m at 30 June and US$1,180 m on 5 August, before Paloma’s cash. Net debt has risen every year since 2022, from US$655.1 m to US$3,386.8 m, while Adjusted EBITDA rose from US$2,127.2 m to US$2,294.6 m.
Table 8. Hedge book, 30 June 2026
| Instrument | Period | Volume | Strikes (US$) | Fair value (US$ m) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| WTI costless collars | Jul–Dec 2026 | 12.33 mmbbl (~67,000 bbl/d) | 52.75 / 66.36 | (66.1) |
| WTI costless collars | 2027 | 3.65 mmbbl (10,000 bbl/d) | 55.00 / 76.00 | (2.8) |
| WTI calls sold | Jul–Dec 2026 | 12.24 mmbbl | 100.00 | (57.1) |
| Henry Hub costless collars | Jul–Dec 2026 | 27.6 m MMBtu | 3.50 / 6.70 | 9.2 |
| Waha basis swaps | Jul–Dec 2026 | 27.6 m MMBtu | (2.52) | (11.9) |
| Waha fixed-price gas swap | Jul 2026 | 3.1 m MMBtu | (0.53) | (4.0) |
| Houston Ship Channel basis swaps | Jul 2026–Sep 2029 | 135.4 m MMBtu | (0.37) | (3.3) |
| Net derivative position | (136.0) |
Source: Matador 10-Q Q2 2026 on SEC EDGAR — Note 8 derivative financial instruments (p.15–16).
The collars cover about 53% of second-quarter oil output to December 2026, with upside capped above US$100 by the calls; 2027 cover falls to 10,000 bbl/d. Shareholders received a quarterly dividend raised from US$0.3125 in 2025 to US$0.375 in 2026 — US$93.3 m paid in the first half — and 1,351,328 shares were bought back in 2025 at US$41.31 under a US$400 m program.
4. Management, strategy & structure
4.1 Management & governance
Joseph Wm. Foran founded Matador in July 2003 and is its Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, one person in both roles. Christopher P. Calvert, 47, is Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer. Ten directors are independent under SEC and NYSE rules, and the board is classified: three nominees stood for election in 2026. Directors and executive officers owned about 5.8% of the shares on 24 February 2026. The committee list and related-party transactions are not in the files read. Combining the two top roles concentrates authority in the founder, and the classified board puts only a third of the seats to a vote each year, which slows any change in its make-up.
4.2 Strategy
Matador grows inside one basin by drilling and by bolt-on purchase. The 2026 plan raised D/C/E capex to US$1.48–1.56 billion and production guidance to 218,500–223,500 boe/d, both including Paloma and Ridge Runner from their close, and lifted midstream capex to US$145–165 m for Matador’s share. The 2026 deals add drilling inventory faster than the balance sheet adds capacity: net debt rose from US$3,386.8 m at the 2025 year-end to US$4,190.1 m at 30 June 2026, before Paloma’s cash. The second-quarter rate of 215,631 boe/d sat 1.3% below the bottom of the new range before Paloma’s volumes arrived.
4.3 Ownership & structure
Table 9. Acquisitions, joint ventures and stakes
| Item | Year | Counterparty | Asset | Consideration | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Paloma acquisition | 2026 | Paloma Permian | ~11,100 boe/d, 55 mmboe proved, 156 net locations | US$1.255 bn cash (announced US$1.275 bn) | Closed 5 Oct 2026 |
| Ridge Runner acquisition | 2026 | Ridge Runner | Undeveloped Woodford acreage | n/d | Announced Jul 2026 |
| San Mateo Midstream | — | Five Point Infrastructure | Gathering, processing and water | 49% held by Five Point | Consolidated |
| Piñon Midstream parent | — | — | Minority equity | ~19% stake | Not valued |
Source: Matador filings on SEC EDGAR — 10-K 2025 Item 1 (p.4, p.7); Paloma acquisition and closing releases (2026).
Matador has 124,511,431 shares issued and 123,998,298 outstanding at 30 June 2026; with 37,000 service restricted stock units and 1,022,000 performance stock units, all equity-settled, the fully diluted count is 125.057 m. It has no stock options outstanding.
5. ESG & sustainability
Matador reports direct greenhouse-gas emissions intensity down 65% and methane intensity down 88% in 2024 against 2019, mainly by connecting wells to gathering lines and capturing gas. No safety rate, framework alignment or decarbonisation target with a baseline was found in the 10-K 2025 or the 2026 proxy, so Dimension 9 rests on the emissions figures alone. Tailings do not apply to an oil producer. The emissions figures appear in the 10-K’s sustainability highlights rather than in a separately assured report, so they are scored as disclosed, not as verified.
6. Risks
Table 10. Risk register
| Risk | Type | Likelihood / impact | Exposure | Mitigant |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oil below the US$73.84 flip price | Commodity | Medium / High | The whole cash flow; the blend is US$13.38 at US$60 | 12.33 mmbbl collared at US$52.75 to December 2026 |
| Waha gas realisation | Commodity / marketing | High / Medium | Gas realised US$(0.09)/mcf in H1 2026 | Waha and Houston Ship Channel basis swaps |
| Leverage after Paloma | Balance sheet | Medium / Medium | Net debt US$5,445.1 m, 2.37× FY2025 EBITDA | Covenant at 3.5×; no note maturity before 2032 |
| Undeveloped reserves slip | Operational | Medium / Medium | 38.8% of proved volume; a one-year slip lowers the blend to US$45.09 | 2026 D/C/E budget of US$1.48–1.56 bn |
| Integration of the 2026 deals | Operational | Low / Medium | 11,100 boe/d and unbooked Woodford acreage | Same basin as the core position |
| Five Point’s San Mateo claim | Structure | Low / Medium | 49% of the midstream segment | US$911.0 m facility non-recourse to Matador |
| Concentrated authority | Governance | Low / Low | Founder Chairman-CEO, classified board | Ten independent directors |
Source: Matador filings on SEC EDGAR — 10-K 2025, 10-Q Q2 2026; Section 7 scenario and slip cases.
Figure 6. Risk matrix
Figure data: Table 10.
Section 7 prices four of these: the oil deck in every scenario, the gas discount held at its 2025 level, the undeveloped-reserves slip and Five Point’s claim in the bridge. The oil price dominates: between US$70 and US$90 the blend moves from US$25.94 to US$65.13, a wider swing than any other case in Section 7. Waha is the live risk; leverage is the one management chose. Both show first in two quarterly lines: the realised gas price and the balance drawn on the reserve-based facility.
7. Valuation
Valuation as of 15 October 2026, in US dollars. Horizon: spot fair value. Oil deck: WTI US$60, 70, 80, 90 and 100/bbl, base US$80/bbl — the trailing averages of the daily WTI Cushing price (3-month US$90.93, 6-month US$90.85, 12-month US$80.27, EIA, to 14 October 2026) snapped to the grid, leaning on the 12-month window because the two shorter ones sit on the 2026 run-up from December 2025’s US$57.97 monthly low. Second deck: Henry Hub US$3.00/MMBtu (3-month US$2.88, 6-month US$2.93, 12-month US$3.54, EIA, to 14 October 2026), held in every scenario; it carries 12.6% of enterprise NAV. Discount rate 10% real after-tax. Share basis 125.057 m fully diluted (outstanding shares plus equity-settled RSUs); market data at the 15 October 2026 close (US$53.77 on the NYSE).
Matador is valued as an oil-weighted exploration and production company with the method set of the commodity stock valuation guide: a net asset value on its proved reserves at the target P/NAV (50%), a forward EV/EBITDA (30%) and a forward P/CF (20%). The base WTI price sits 0.5% above the US$79.58 five-year average (EIA daily, October 2021 to September 2026), so both the deck and the target multiples move across the scenarios.
Three choices shape the numbers. First, Matador files proved reserves only, audited by Netherland, Sewell & Associates at the SEC’s US$61.82/bbl and US$3.39/MMBtu: each proved category is re-priced from that deck to this one on its own oil and gas volumes, over the life its discounted and undiscounted totals imply, then taxed on the Standardized Measure’s own schedule — its filed income tax is 15.2% of PV-10. The net asset value therefore carries no unbooked inventory, which is why the two cash-flow methods hold half the weight. Second, Paloma closed on 5 October 2026, after the 30 June balance sheet: its US$1,255.0 m cash enters the bridge and its announced US$816 m PV-10 enters as its own row, so both sides of the deal sit on one date. Third, San Mateo is consolidated: its margin on Matador’s own barrels is already inside the reserve rows, and Five Point’s 49% is charged as a claim at the midstream segment’s EBITDA on the infrastructure anchor less the non-recourse facility — the segment also holds wholly owned assets, so the claim leans high.
Table 11. Load-bearing inputs — the filed figures the valuation moves on
| Input | Value | Where §7 uses it | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Proved reserves, 31 Dec 2025 (MBOE, 6:1) | total 667,047 · developed 407,987 · undeveloped 259,060 | Table 14, blocks 1–2 | Filed | 10-K 2025 | Item 2 | Estimated proved reserves | “Total (MBOE)" | p.18 — full register Table 25 |
| NSAI audit, PW10 / undiscounted at the SEC deck (US$000s) | PDP 6,020,231.2 / 9,350,763.5 · PDNP 22,099.8 / 36,395.9 · PUD 2,195,419.2 / 4,726,342.1 | Table 14, PV-10 and life of each block | Filed | NSAI reserve audit letter 2025 | Letter | net reserves and future net revenue | “Proved Developed Producing” | p.1; Filed | NSAI reserve audit letter 2025 | Letter | net reserves and future net revenue | “Proved Developed Non-Producing” | p.1; Filed | NSAI reserve audit letter 2025 | Letter | net reserves and future net revenue | “Proved Undeveloped” | p.1 — full register Table 25 |
| Reserve volumes by category (oil MBbl · gas MMcf) | PDP 222,250.7 · 1,106,843.5; PUD 152,952.1 · 636,649.1 | Table 14, re-pricing lines | Filed | NSAI reserve audit letter 2025 | Letter | net reserves and future net revenue | “Proved Developed Producing” | p.1; Filed | NSAI reserve audit letter 2025 | Letter | net reserves and future net revenue | “Proved Undeveloped” | p.1 — full register Table 25 |
| PV-10 and Standardized Measure, YE2025 (US$ m); SEC prices | PV-10 8,237.8 · SM 6,986.6; US$61.82/bbl · US$3.39/MMBtu | Table 14, tax line and reference deck | Filed | 10-K 2025 | Item 2 | Estimated proved reserves | “PV-10” | p.18 — full register Table 25 |
| Realised prices FY2025, without derivatives | oil US$64.99/Bbl · natural gas US$2.08/Mcf | Tables 14 and 18, realisation | Filed | 10-K 2025 | Item 2 | Operating summary | “Oil, without realized derivatives (per Bbl)" | p.14; Filed | 10-K 2025 | Item 2 | Operating summary | “Natural gas, without realized derivatives (per Mcf)" | p.14 — full register Table 25 |
| Unit costs FY2025 (US$/BOE) | LOE 5.50 · transportation and processing 0.88 · midstream 2.75 · taxes other than income 3.65 · G&A 1.81 | Table 18 | Filed | 10-K 2025 | Item 2 | Production, prices and costs | “Lease operating” | p.14; Filed | 10-K 2025 | Item 2 | Operating summary | “Transportation and processing” | p.14; Filed | 10-K 2025 | Item 2 | Operating summary | “Midstream operating” | p.14; Filed | 10-K 2025 | Item 2 | Operating summary | “Taxes other than income” | p.14; Filed | 10-K 2025 | Item 2 | Operating summary | “General and administrative” | p.14 — full register Table 25 |
| Production, Q2 2026; Paloma at announcement | 215,631 BOE/d (oil 126,106 Bbl/d); Paloma approx. 11,100 BOE/d, 57% oil | Table 18, forward volume | Filed | 10-Q Q2 2026 | Management’s Discussion and Analysis | Results of operations | “Average daily production (BOE/d)" | p.28; Filed | Paloma acquisition release | Announcement | “Paloma Acquisition” | p.1 — full register Table 25 |
| Paloma — PV-10, proved reserves, cash paid | PV-10 US$816 m · 55 MMBOE · US$1.255 bn | Table 14 block 3; Table 16 | Filed | Paloma acquisition release | Announcement | highlights | “Adds $816 million of PV-10” | p.1; Filed | Paloma closing release | Announcement | “cash consideration” | p.1 — full register Table 25 |
| Debt and cash, 30 Jun 2026 (US$000s) | total long-term debt 4,216,410 incl. San Mateo facility 911,000; cash 26,318 | Table 16, net debt | Filed | 10-Q Q2 2026 | Note — debt | “Total long-term debt” | p.11; Filed | 10-Q Q2 2026 | Note 5 — debt | “San Mateo Credit Facility due 2029” | p.11; Filed | 10-Q Q2 2026 | Condensed consolidated balance sheet | “Cash” | p.3 — full register Table 25 |
| Midstream segment FY2025 (100%); Five Point share | operating income US$278,269k + D&A US$57.4 m; 49% | Table 16, minority interest | Filed | 10-K 2025 | Note 16 — segment information | “Operating income” | p.141; Filed | 10-K 2025 | Note 16 — segment information | “Includes depletion, depreciation and amortization expenses of” | p.142; Filed | 10-K 2025 | Item 1 | Midstream | “owned 51% by us” | p.7 — full register Table 25 |
| Oil hedges, Jul–Dec 2026 | collars 12,328,000 Bbl at US$52.75/66.36; calls sold 12,236,000 Bbl at US$100.00 | Table 16, hedge line | Filed | 10-Q Q2 2026 | Note 8 — derivative financial instruments | “Oil - WTI” | p.15; Filed | 10-Q Q2 2026 | Note 8 — derivative financial instruments | “Total open price call contracts” | p.15 — full register Table 25 |
| Share basis | 123,998,298 outstanding; equity-settled units 37k service RSUs · 630k performance stock units (31 Dec 2025) · 392,000 performance stock units granted H1 2026 | Table 16, fully-diluted count | Filed | 10-Q Q2 2026 | Condensed consolidated balance sheet | “Common stock” | p.3; Filed | 10-K 2025 | Note 9 — stock-based compensation | “Non-vested at December 31, 2025” | p.133; Filed | 10-Q Q2 2026 | Note 7 — equity | stock-based compensation | “service-based restricted stock units to be settled in cash” | p.14 — full register Table 25 |
| 2026 guidance (5 Aug 2026) | DD&A US$15.85–16.15/BOE · current tax 0–1% · D/C/E US$1.48–1.56 bn | Tables 20 and 21 | Filed | Q2 2026 results release | Full-Year 2026 Guidance Update | “for DD&A” | p.5; Filed | Q2 2026 results release | Full-Year 2026 Guidance Update | “Current income taxes (% of pretax income)" | p.5; Filed | Q2 2026 results release | Full-Year 2026 Guidance Update | “D/C/E CapEx” | p.5 — full register Table 25 |
| Interest H1 2026; G&A FY2025 (US$000s) | interest 112,344; G&A 137,069 | Tables 16 and 20 | Filed | 10-Q Q2 2026 | Condensed consolidated statement of operations | “Interest expense” | p.4; Filed | 10-K 2025 | Management’s Discussion and Analysis | Results of operations | Expenses | “General and administrative” | p.77 — full register Table 25 |
Source: the filings named in each row; the full source register is Table 25 in Section 10.1. Matador filings on SEC EDGAR.
8. Near-term catalysts (1–3 years)
Table 23. Near-term catalysts
| Catalyst | Timing | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| First quarter with Paloma | Q4 2026 results, early 2027 | ~11,100 boe/d and the US$1.255 bn payment in one quarter’s numbers |
| 2027 guidance | With the FY2026 results, February 2027 (FY2025’s came on 24 Feb 2026) | The first full-year guide with both 2026 deals; Section 7’s forward year still runs on the Q2 2026 rate |
| Year-end 2026 reserves | 10-K 2026, February 2027 | Paloma’s 55 mmboe and any Woodford bookings enter the audited proved book |
| Hedge roll-off | 31 Dec 2026 | The US$100 calls and the 2026 collars expire; 2027 cover is 3.65 mmbbl |
| Debt reduction after Paloma | 2027 | Net debt of US$5,445.1 m against 1.87× forward EBITDA at US$80 |
Source: Matador filings on SEC EDGAR — 10-Q Q2 2026 (Note 8, p.15–16), Q2 2026 results release, Paloma closing release.
The reserve report matters most: it decides how much of the 2026 spending the proved book, and so the net asset value, can carry. The hedge roll-off cuts both ways: it removes the US$66.36 ceiling that carried US$(66.1) m of fair value at 30 June, and the US$52.75 floor with it.
9. Rating & verdict
Figure 10. Scorecard by dimension, 16 October 2026
Figure data: Table 24. Each spoke prints its stars and weight; the dashed ring is the weighted composite, 3.13/5.
Table 24. The Metal Pilot Company Scorecard — Matador Resources
| Dimension | Weight | Score | Sourced rationale |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Asset quality & scale | 15% | ★★★★ | 207,070 boe/d in FY2025, 98.2% Delaware Basin, 58% oil; PV-10 US$12.35 per proved boe, the highest of the four, on the smallest proved book: 667.0 mmboe against SM’s 673.0, Crescent’s 975.5 and Permian Resources’ 1,116.3 (§2, 10-K 2025) |
| 2. Cost position & margins | 15% | ★★★ | Cash margin US$28.25/boe (66%) and LOE US$5.50/boe in FY2025; Adjusted EBITDA margin 62.1%, the lowest of five years; gas realised US$(0.09)/mcf at Waha in H1 2026; peer margins not compared (§2.7, §3, 10-K 2025) |
| 3. Reserves, life & replacement | 15% | ★★★ | Proved life 8.8 years with 38.8% undeveloped, level with SM’s 38.7% and above Permian Resources’ 28.9% and Crescent’s 20.4%; 173% replacement in 2025, acquisitions included (§2.7, 10-K 2025) |
| 5. Balance sheet & liquidity | 15% | ★★ | Net debt US$4,190.1 m at 30 Jun 2026, 1.83× FY2025 Adjusted EBITDA and 2.37× with Paloma, from 0.31× in 2022; covenant 3.5×, no notes before 2032; peer leverage not compared (§3, 10-Q Q2 2026) |
| 6. Capital allocation & returns | 15% | ★★★ | Quarterly dividend US$0.3125 → US$0.375; 1,351,328 shares bought back in 2025; Paloma at 1.54× its PV-10; diluted shares +4.6% since 2021; peer records not compared (§2.4, §3) |
| 4. Growth & optionality | 6.25% | ★★★★ | 2026 guidance 218,500–223,500 boe/d, +5.5% to +7.9% on FY2025; Paloma’s 156 net locations and ~50,000 unbooked Woodford acres; peer growth plans not compared (§2.4, §2.6, Q2 2026 release) |
| 7. Management & governance | 6.25% | ★★★ | Founder Chairman-CEO since 2003; ten independent directors on a classified board; insiders ~5.8%; committees and related parties not in the files read; peer boards not compared (§4.1, 10-K 2025, Proxy 2026) |
| 8. Jurisdiction & geopolitics | 6.25% | ★★★★ | United States only — New Mexico and Texas under the SEC reserve regime; the Waha discount is regional, shared with every Delaware peer in §2.8 (§2, 10-K 2025) |
| 9. ESG & licence to operate | 6.25% | ★★★ | Direct GHG intensity −65% and methane intensity −88%, 2024 against 2019; no safety rate or baseline target in the files read; peers not compared (§5, 10-K 2025) |
| Composite | 100% | ★★★ | Average |
| Value read | — | Modestly overvalued (wide band) | Blend US$45.78 against US$53.77; implied −14.9% (§7) |
| Verdict | — | Full | Average quality × Modestly overvalued |
Σ(weight × stars) = 0.15 × (4 + 3 + 3 + 2 + 3) + 0.0625 × (4 + 3 + 4 + 3) = 2.25 + 0.88 = 3.13/5 → ★★★ Average.
Source: this analysis; every score cites its home section. Scored as an E&P producer — all nine dimensions apply, Dimension 3 on proved life, Dimension 2 on cash margin — against the peer set in §2.8; the five dominant dimensions at 15%, the other four at 6.25%. Matador filings on SEC EDGAR.
The two-axis verdict (16 October 2026). ★★★ Average × Modestly overvalued (wide band) — Full: at US$53.77 the blend of US$45.78 implies −14.9%, and the price assumes ~US$86.07/bbl WTI (the market-implied deck), above the US$80 base. The target multiples carry Dimension 1 (+0.03) and Dimension 8 (+0.01) against Dimension 5 (−0.03), a net +0.01. This is an analytical read, not an instruction. Dimension 1 is the only dominant dimension above the median; Dimension 5 sits below it on debt the company chose to take on. The composite falls from the July post’s 3.94 because each star is now scored only on the filed figures and peer data in the source set, which carry no well-cost or finding-cost series to lift the cost and reserve scores.
The bull case is the cash flow: at US$90 WTI the blend is US$65.13, and the forward free cash flow is a 12.0% yield at the base. The bear case is the proved book: NAV is US$21.03 a share, and at US$60 the blend falls to US$13.38. WTI above ~US$81.98 tips the read to Fairly valued; below ~US$73.84 it turns Overvalued. To rank Matador against US oil producers on these dimensions, screen the sector on Metal Pilot’s upstream oil & gas stock screener.
10. Sources, methodology & disclaimer
10.1 Sources, methodology & data vintage
Company filings. Matador’s filings on SEC EDGAR: the 10-K for 2025 with NSAI’s reserve audit letter (effective 31 December 2025), the 10-Ks for 2024, 2023 and 2022, the 10-Qs for Q3 2025, Q1 2026 and Q2 2026, the FY2025, Q1 2026 and Q2 2026 results releases, the Paloma acquisition and closing releases (2026) and the 2026 proxy statement. Peers from their FY2025 10-Ks on EDGAR.
Market data. NYSE closes from Yahoo Finance; WTI Cushing and Henry Hub from the EIA — to the 15 October 2026 close and the 14 October 2026 print.
Methodology. The valuation runs a base WTI deck of US$80/bbl on the fixed US$60–100 grid, Henry Hub held at US$3.00/MMBtu, a 10% real after-tax rate and weights of 50% NAV, 30% EV/EBITDA and 20% P/CF. The scorecard uses the E&P weights against the three peers in §2.8. Refreshed on each annual report and each quarterly report. The model’s out file, claude/valuation-models/matador-resources-mtdr.out.md, holds the deck sensitivity, the P/NAV map, the cross-checks and the stage-risk, slip and Henry Hub cases.
Re-run log. 16 October 2026: rebuilt from the 29 July 2026 post (US$47.17; ★★★★ Solid at 3.94, Modestly undervalued) as a standalone valuation on filed figures — price US$53.77, NAV/share US$21.10, blend US$46.47, implied −13.6%, Modestly overvalued (wide band); composite 3.94 → 3.13, ★★★ Average. The peer-multiples table and the data-provider figures are gone, and every star is re-scored on the filings. 16 October 2026, pre-launch fixes: share basis 124.665 → 125.057 m with the H1 2026 performance stock units, and Paloma’s funding interest deducted in the P/CF build — NAV/share US$21.10 → US$21.03, blend US$46.47 → US$45.78, implied −13.6% → −14.9%, read unchanged; peer cells, net income and dividends filled from the filings. Second fix round (same day): 2021 net debt US$1,479.4 m and own multiple 5.6× from the 10-K 2022; no weighted figure moves.
Omitted figures and data gaps. The asset map is not built; revenue by area is not disclosed, so Figure 3 shows production. Not in the files read (n/d): a safety rate (10-K 2025, proxy 2026), the committee list and related parties (proxy 2026), the sustaining and growth capex split, locations, type curves and well costs for the core position, the Ridge Runner price, the Piñon stake’s value, San Mateo’s stand-alone EBITDA, peer production, margins and leverage, and analyst consensus.
The load-bearing inputs (Table 11) open Section 7; the full source register below closes this section.
Table 25. Full source register for the valuation
| Input | Value | As of | Where §7 uses it | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Form 10-K, year ended 31 December 2025 (filed 26 Feb 2026) | ||||
| Production, FY2025 (Delaware / total) | 203,330 BOE/d Delaware Basin, 207,070 BOE/d total; oil 119,723 Bbl/d total | FY2025 | §1 statcard; §2 scale; §7 volume base | Filed | 10-K 2025 | Item 2 | Production, prices and costs | "Total oil equivalent (BOE/d)" | p.14 |
| Total proved reserves (SEC), 31 Dec 2025 and 2024 | 667.0 MMBOE at YE2025 vs 611.5 MMBOE at YE2024 | 31 Dec 2025 | §1 statcard; §7 NAV reserve block | Filed | 10-K 2025 | Item 2 | Estimated proved reserves | "estimated total proved oil and natural gas reserves" | p.18 |
| PV-10 and Standardized Measure, YE2025 / 2024 / 2023 (US$ m) | PV-10 8,237.8 / 9,233.8 / 7,704.1; Standardized Measure 6,986.6 / 7,376.6 / 6,113.5 | 31 Dec 2025 | §1 statcard; §7 NAV | Filed | 10-K 2025 | Item 2 | Estimated proved reserves | "PV-10" | p.18 |
| SEC 12-month average prices used for YE2025 reserves | US$61.82/bbl oil · US$3.39/MMBtu gas | 31 Dec 2025 | §7 deck note | Filed | 10-K 2025 | Item 2 | Estimated proved reserves | "PV-10" | p.18 |
| Lease operating expense per BOE | FY2025 US$5.50 (FY2024 5.20, FY2023 4.83) | FY2025 / Q2 2026 | §2 cost star; §7 opex | Filed | 10-K 2025 | Item 2 | Production, prices and costs | "Lease operating" | p.14 |
| San Mateo midstream JV ownership | Matador 51% · Five Point 49% | 31 Dec 2025 | §7 midstream / NCI | Filed | 10-K 2025 | Item 1 | Midstream | "owned 51% by us" | p.7 |
| SM build: future income tax expense YE2025 / 2024 (US$k) | US$(2,089,975)k / (3,326,489)k | 31 Dec 2025 | §7 NAV build; tax basis | Filed | 10-K 2025 | Supplemental oil and natural gas disclosures | Standardized measure | "Future income tax expense" | p.149 |
| Proved natural gas: total / PD / PUD, YE2025 (Bcf) | 1,746.4 / 1,109.8 / 636.6 | 31 Dec 2025 | §7 tiered NAV; gas share | Filed | 10-K 2025 | Item 2 | Estimated proved reserves | "Natural Gas (Bcf)" | p.18 |
| Proved reserves total / PD / PUD, YE2025 (MBOE, 6:1) | 667,047 / 407,987 / 259,060 | 31 Dec 2025 | §7 tiered NAV | Filed | 10-K 2025 | Item 2 | Estimated proved reserves | "Total (MBOE)" | p.18 |
| Average sales prices FY2025 / 2024 / 2023 — oil without realized derivatives (US$/Bbl) | US$64.99 / 75.89 / 77.88 | FY2025 | §7 realised differential vs WTI | Filed | 10-K 2025 | Item 2 | Operating summary | "Oil, without realized derivatives (per Bbl)" | p.14 |
| Average sales prices FY2025 / 2024 / 2023 — natural gas without realized derivatives (US$/Mcf; two streams, NGL inside gas) | US$2.08 / 2.38 / 3.25 | FY2025 | §7 realised gas vs HH (Waha basis) | Filed | 10-K 2025 | Item 2 | Operating summary | "Natural gas, without realized derivatives (per Mcf)" | p.14 |
| Transportation and processing FY2025 / 2024 / 2023 (US$/BOE) | US$0.88 / 0.94 / 1.25 | FY2025 | §7 unit-cost deck | Filed | 10-K 2025 | Item 2 | Operating summary | "Transportation and processing" | p.14 |
| Midstream operating FY2025 / 2024 / 2023 (US$/BOE) | US$2.75 / 2.68 / 2.58 | FY2025 | §7 unit-cost deck | Filed | 10-K 2025 | Item 2 | Operating summary | "Midstream operating" | p.14 |
| Taxes other than income (production and ad valorem) FY2025 / 2024 / 2023 (US$/BOE) | US$3.65 / 4.30 / 4.59 | FY2025 | §7 price-linked cost line | Filed | 10-K 2025 | Item 2 | Operating summary | "Taxes other than income" | p.14 |
| General and administrative FY2025 / 2024 / 2023 (US$/BOE) | US$1.81 / 2.04 / 2.29 | FY2025 | §7 corporate cost | Filed | 10-K 2025 | Item 2 | Operating summary | "General and administrative" | p.14 |
| Midstream segment FY2025: operating income; total assets; capital expenditures (US$k, 100% basis) | US$278,269k; 1,833,673k; 286,294k | FY2025 | §7 San Mateo row; NCI | Filed | 10-K 2025 | Note 16 — segment information | "Operating income" | p.141 |
| Segment DD&A FY2025: E&P (US$ bn) / midstream (US$ m) | US$1.14 bn / US$57.4 m | FY2025 | §7 midstream EBITDA = op. income + D&A | Filed | 10-K 2025 | Note 16 — segment information | "Includes depletion, depreciation and amortization expenses of" | p.142 |
| Adjusted EBITDA attributable to Matador FY2025 / 2024 / 2023 (non-GAAP) | US$2,294,551k / 2,298,777k / 1,849,547k | FY2025 | leverage; EV/EBITDA | Filed | 10-K 2025 | Management’s Discussion and Analysis | "Adjusted EBITDA attributable to Matador Resources Company shareholders" | p.81 |
| Federal cash income taxes paid, net of refunds, FY2025 / 2024 / 2023 | US$43,000k / 22,622k / (8,864)k | FY2025 | §7 cash-tax line | Filed | 10-K 2025 | Note — income taxes | cash paid | "Federal" | p.132 |
| General and administrative FY2025 / 2024 / 2023 (US$k, expensed) | US$137,069k / 127,454k / 110,373k | FY2025 | §7 corporate cost | Filed | 10-K 2025 | Management’s Discussion and Analysis | Results of operations | Expenses | "General and administrative" | p.77 |
| Interest expense FY2025 / 2024 / 2023 (US$k, net of capitalised) | US$(208,520)k / (171,687)k / (121,520)k | FY2025 | EV/EBITDA; P/CF; coverage | Filed | 10-K 2025 | Management’s Discussion and Analysis | Results of operations | Other income (expense) | "Interest expense" | p.77 |
| Net income attributable to non-controlling interest FY2025 / 2024 / 2023 (US$k) | US$101,548k / 86,021k / 64,285k | FY2025 | §7 NCI (San Mateo 49%) | Filed | 10-K 2025 | Management’s Discussion and Analysis | Results of operations | "Net income attributable to non-controlling interest in subsidiaries" | p.77 |
| Non-vested equity-settled awards at 31 Dec 2025 (thousands): restricted stock; service RSUs; performance RSUs (0–200%) | 830; 37; 630 | 31 Dec 2025 | fully-diluted count | Filed | 10-K 2025 | Note 9 — stock-based compensation | "Non-vested at December 31, 2025" | p.133 |
| Stake in Piñon Midstream parent | approx. 19% | 26 Feb 2026 | §7 investments | Filed | 10-K 2025 | Item 1 | "Piñon Midstream" | p.4 |
| Form 10-Q, quarter ended 30 June 2026 (filed 7 Aug 2026) | ||||
| Production, Q2 2026 and H1 2026 | Q2 215,631 BOE/d (oil 126,106 Bbl/d, 58%) | 30 Jun 2026 | §2 current run-rate | Filed | 10-Q Q2 2026 | Management’s Discussion and Analysis | Results of operations | "Average daily production (BOE/d)" | p.28 |
| Average sales prices H1 2026 (H1 2025): oil / natural gas without realized derivatives — two streams, NGL revenue inside natural gas | oil US$85.86/Bbl (US$68.20); natural gas US$(0.09)/Mcf (US$2.79) | 30 Jun 2026 | §7 realised differentials; stream count | Filed | 10-Q Q2 2026 | Management’s Discussion and Analysis | Revenues | "Oil, without realized derivatives (per Bbl)" | p.31 |
| Cash; restricted cash, 30 Jun 2026 | US$26,318k; restricted US$64,597k | 30 Jun 2026 | §7 bridge (net debt) | Filed | 10-Q Q2 2026 | Condensed consolidated balance sheet | "Cash" | p.3 |
| Total long-term debt, 30 Jun 2026 (YE2025) | US$4,216,410k (US$3,402,102k) | 30 Jun 2026 | §7 bridge (net debt) | Filed | 10-Q Q2 2026 | Note — debt | "Total long-term debt" | p.11 |
| Net debt, 30 Jun 2026 (excl. restricted cash) | US$4,190,092k | 30 Jun 2026 | §7 bridge; leverage (pre-Paloma: US$1.255 bn cash deal closed 5 Oct 2026) | Derived | total long-term debt − cash |
| Balance-sheet face, 30 Jun 2026 | AP and accrued US$836,776k · royalties payable 399,711k · inventory 50,177k · ARO 155,191k · NCI 322,275k · Matador equity 5,928,623k | 30 Jun 2026 | §7 bridge; rehabilitation provision (ARO non-current) | Filed | 10-Q Q2 2026 | Condensed consolidated balance sheet | "Asset retirement obligations" | p.3 |
| Common shares issued / outstanding, 30 Jun 2026 | 124,511,431 issued; 123,998,298 outstanding | 30 Jun 2026 | per-share basis | Filed | 10-Q Q2 2026 | Condensed consolidated balance sheet | "Common stock" | p.3 |
| Senior notes and RBL at 30 Jun 2026 | 2034 notes 6.000% US$750,000k; RBL borrowings under Credit Agreement US$939,000k (YE2025 398,000k) | 30 Jun 2026 | §7 bridge; maturities | Filed | 10-Q Q2 2026 | Note — debt | "6.000 % senior notes due 2034" | p.11 |
| H1 2026 (H1 2025) taxes other than income; G&A; interest expense (US$k) | US$173,685k (145,059k); 80,297k (65,919k); (112,344)k ((102,834)k) | 30 Jun 2026 | §7 run-rate; P/CF | Filed | 10-Q Q2 2026 | Condensed consolidated statement of operations | "Interest expense" | p.4 |
| Credit Agreement due 2029 borrowings, 30 Jun 2026 (YE2025) | US$939,000k (US$398,000k) | 30 Jun 2026 | §7 bridge | Filed | 10-Q Q2 2026 | Note 5 — debt | "Credit Agreement due 2029" | p.11 |
| San Mateo Credit Facility due 2029, 30 Jun 2026 (YE2025) — non-recourse to Matador, inside Total long-term debt | US$911,000k (US$883,000k) | 30 Jun 2026 | §7 bridge / San Mateo row | Filed | 10-Q Q2 2026 | Note 5 — debt | "San Mateo Credit Facility due 2029" | p.11 |
| Oil - WTI costless collars Jul–Dec 2026: Bbl; floor; ceiling (US$/Bbl); fair value (US$k) | 12,328,000 Bbl; US$52.75; US$66.36; US$(66,064)k | 30 Jun 2026 | §7 bridge line 2 | Filed | 10-Q Q2 2026 | Note 8 — derivative financial instruments | "Oil - WTI" | p.15 |
| Oil - WTI costless collars 2027: Bbl; floor; ceiling (US$/Bbl); fair value (US$k) | 3,650,000 Bbl; US$55.00; US$76.00; US$(2,807)k | 30 Jun 2026 | §7 bridge line 2 | Filed | 10-Q Q2 2026 | Note 8 — derivative financial instruments | "Oil - WTI" | p.15 |
| Natural Gas - Henry Hub costless collars Jul–Dec 2026: MMBtu; floor; ceiling; fair value (US$k) | 27,600,000 MMBtu; US$3.50; US$6.70; US$9,226k | 30 Jun 2026 | §7 bridge line 2 | Filed | 10-Q Q2 2026 | Note 8 — derivative financial instruments | "Natural Gas - Henry Hub" | p.15 |
| Oil - WTI price calls (sold) Jul–Dec 2026: Bbl; fixed price (US$/Bbl) | 12,236,000 Bbl at US$100.00 | 30 Jun 2026 | §7 bridge line 2 | Filed | 10-Q Q2 2026 | Note 8 — derivative financial instruments | "Total open price call contracts" | p.15 |
| Net derivative position, 30 Jun 2026 (YE2025) (US$k) | US$(135,965)k (US$34,052k) | 30 Jun 2026 | §7 bridge line 2 | Filed | 10-Q Q2 2026 | Note 8 — derivative financial instruments | "Total" | p.16 |
| H1 2026 grants: cash-settled service RSUs; performance-based stock units; service-based restricted shares | 392,000; 392,000; 2,500 | 30 Jun 2026 | fully-diluted count | Filed | 10-Q Q2 2026 | Note 7 — equity | stock-based compensation | "service-based restricted stock units to be settled in cash" | p.14 |
| San Mateo distributions H1 2026: to Matador; to Five Point (US$ m) | US$61.7; US$59.3 | 30 Jun 2026 | §7 NCI value cross-check | Filed | 10-Q Q2 2026 | Note 7 — equity | "San Mateo distributed" | p.14 |
| Q2 2026 results and guidance release (8-K, 5 Aug 2026) | ||||
| 2026 production guidance (updated 5 Aug 2026) | 218,500–223,500 BOE/d; oil 127,500–129,000 Bbl/d | 5 Aug 2026 | §7 guidance-year volume. guidance columns prior → new (table header) | Filed | Q2 2026 results release | Full-Year 2026 Guidance Update | "Total Oil Equivalent Production, BOE per day" | p.5 |
| FY2026 guidance (prior → new, 5 Aug 2026): total operating expenses per BOE | US$31.00–33.00 → US$32.00–34.00/BOE | 5 Aug 2026 | §7 unit-cost deck; incl. Paloma and Ridge Runner | Filed | Q2 2026 results release | Full-Year 2026 Guidance Update | "Total operating expenses per BOE" | p.5 |
| FY2026 guidance: non-cash DD&A and non-cash G&A inside total operating expenses (US$/BOE) | DD&A US$15.85–16.15; non-cash G&A US$0.20–0.30 | 5 Aug 2026 | §7 cash unit cost = total less non-cash | Filed | Q2 2026 results release | Full-Year 2026 Guidance Update | "for DD&A" | p.5 |
| FY2026 guidance (prior → new): Midstream CapEx (Matador share, US$ m) | US$100–110 → US$145–165 m | 5 Aug 2026 | §7 forward FCF | Filed | Q2 2026 results release | Full-Year 2026 Guidance Update | "Midstream CapEx" | p.5 |
| FY2026 guidance: current income taxes (% of pretax income) | 0% to 1% (no change) | 5 Aug 2026 | §7 cash-tax line | Filed | Q2 2026 results release | Full-Year 2026 Guidance Update | "Current income taxes (% of pretax income)" | p.5 |
| 2026 D/C/E capex guidance (updated 5 Aug 2026) | US$1.48–1.56 bn (midpoint raised from US$1.395 bn to US$1.52 bn) | 5 Aug 2026 | §7 capex | Filed | Q2 2026 results release | Full-Year 2026 Guidance Update | "D/C/E CapEx" | p.5 |
| Paloma closing release (8-K, 5 Oct 2026) | ||||
| Paloma Permian acquisition — closed | cash consideration US$1.255 bn, subject to customary adjustments; closed 5 Oct 2026 | 5 Oct 2026 | §2 M&A; §7 bridge (post-period debt) | Filed | Paloma closing release | Announcement | "cash consideration" | p.1 |
| Paloma and Ridge Runner acquisition announcement (8-K, 24 Jul 2026) | ||||
| Paloma acquisition — announced terms | cash payment US$1.275 bn; approx. 11,100 BOE/d (57% oil) | 24 Jul 2026 | §2 M&A; §7 production add | Filed | Paloma acquisition release | Announcement | "Paloma Acquisition" | p.1 |
| Ridge Runner acquisition (the second 23 Jul deal) — Woodford acreage | approx. 50,000 contiguous undeveloped net Woodford acres (with prior additions); Delaware total approx. 240,000 net acres after both deals; price n/d in the release | 24 Jul 2026 | §2 M&A; §7 unbooked acreage | Filed | Paloma acquisition release | Announcement | "net acres" | p.1 |
| Paloma acquisition: PV-10 at 31 May 2026 (US$70/bbl, US$3.00/MMBtu) and total proved reserves | PV-10 US$816 m; 55 million BOE proved; 156 net locations | 31 May 2026 | §7 Paloma asset row | Filed | Paloma acquisition release | Announcement | highlights | "Adds $816 million of PV-10" | p.1 |
| Netherland, Sewell & Associates reserve audit letter, 31 Dec 2025 (10-K 2025 EX-99.1) | ||||
| NSAI: proved developed producing — oil MBbl · gas MMcf · FNR undiscounted · PW at 10% (US$k) | 222,250.7 · 1,106,843.5 · US$9,350,763.5k · US$6,020,231.2k | 31 Dec 2025 | §7 tiered NAV — PD tranche, pre-tax | Filed | NSAI reserve audit letter 2025 | Letter | net reserves and future net revenue | "Proved Developed Producing" | p.1 |
| NSAI: proved developed non-producing — oil MBbl · gas MMcf · FNR undiscounted · PW at 10% (US$k) | 777.2 · 2,910.9 · US$36,395.9k · US$22,099.8k | 31 Dec 2025 | §7 tiered NAV — PD tranche, pre-tax | Filed | NSAI reserve audit letter 2025 | Letter | net reserves and future net revenue | "Proved Developed Non-Producing" | p.1 |
| NSAI: proved undeveloped — oil MBbl · gas MMcf · FNR undiscounted · PW at 10% (US$k) | 152,952.1 · 636,649.1 · US$4,726,342.1k · US$2,195,419.2k | 31 Dec 2025 | §7 tiered NAV — PUD tranche, pre-tax | Filed | NSAI reserve audit letter 2025 | Letter | net reserves and future net revenue | "Proved Undeveloped" | p.1 |
| NSAI: total proved — oil MBbl · gas MMcf · FNR undiscounted · PW at 10% (US$k; = PV-10) | 375,980.0 · 1,746,403.5 · US$14,113,501.5k · US$8,237,750.2k | 31 Dec 2025 | §7 NAV tie-out to PV-10 | Filed | NSAI reserve audit letter 2025 | Letter | net reserves and future net revenue | "Total Proved" | p.1 |
| Market and price series | ||||
| WTI Cushing spot — last and trailing means | last US$101.91 (14 Oct 2026); 3/6/12-month US$90.93 / 90.85 / 80.27/bbl | 14 Oct 2026 | §7 deck | Market | EIA | "RWTC Cushing WTI spot FOB" | 14 Oct 2026 |
| Henry Hub spot — last and trailing means | last US$3.22 (14 Oct 2026); 3/6/12-month US$2.88 / 2.93 / 3.54/MMBtu | 14 Oct 2026 | §7 secondary deck | Market | EIA | "RNGWHHD Henry Hub natural gas spot price" | 14 Oct 2026 |
Source: the filings and market series named in each row, as of 16 October 2026; the model claude/valuation-models/matador-resources-mtdr.py and its facts file claude/analysis-facts/matador-resources-mtdr.py. Matador filings on SEC EDGAR.
10.2 Disclaimer & disclosure
This analysis is for information only and is not investment advice; do your own research or consult a licensed advisor. It is a point-in-time snapshot as of 16 October 2026: the share price, the multiples and the valuation read move, and reserves are SEC proved estimates on trailing prices that do not represent market value. The scorecard and the two-axis verdict are an analytical read of quality and price, not a buy or sell instruction. This report was prepared with AI assistance (Claude Opus 5.5) from the filings cited, under this blog’s company-analysis template, and reviewed before publication. Verify every figure before acting on it. As of 18 November 2026, the author holds no position in the company this analysis covers.