Pan American Silver (PAAS) — Stock Analysis 2026 [3.2]
Analysis as of 8 August 2026. Pan American Silver stock analysis. A point-in-time snapshot. Fundamentals: the 2025 annual filings and Q1 2026 interim filings; the Q2 2026 results (12 August) postdate it. Market data: NYSE close on 7 August 2026 — $51.22 a share, 421.7 m fully diluted shares. Rating: ★★★, Average — Modestly overvalued (wide band) → full: the price already assumes more than the base deck. Market-implied deck ~$4,767/oz gold with silver ~$75.3/oz. Price deck: base gold $4,000/oz and silver $60/oz — the 3-month trailing averages of $4,296 and $67.83 taken to the fixed grids — with every grid price run as a scenario (deep bear $3,000 · $40 / bear $3,500 · $50 / base $4,000 · $60 / bull $4,500 · $70 / deep bull $5,000 · $80); 5% real after-tax discount rate. All figures are US dollars. Refreshed each annual report and on material events. AI-assisted — see the disclaimer.
Pan American Silver holds the largest silver reserve in its peer group yet earned about 72% of its 2025 revenue from gold, across eleven mines in seven countries. The thesis in one line: a well-financed, widely spread producer whose shares already price both metals above this analysis’s base deck. Why now: 2025 was its first clean year after the Yamana and MAG deals — $1.0 bn of free cash flow and up to $1 bn of returns pledged for 2026 — and the Skarn is moving from study to decline. To screen it against every listed silver producer, go to Metal Pilot’s silver mining stock screener.
1. Snapshot & thesis
Pan American Silver Corp. (TSX: PAAS; NYSE: PAAS) is a senior silver-and-gold producer headquartered in Vancouver. It runs eleven producing mines — Jacobina in Brazil; El Peñon and Minera Florida in Chile; Shahuindo and Huaron in Peru; Cerro Moro in Argentina; Timmins in Canada; La Colorada, Dolores and a 44% stake in Juanicipio in Mexico; and San Vicente in Bolivia — and holds the suspended Escobal mine in Guatemala, the La Colorada Skarn study and the Navidad deposit in Argentina. By archetype it is a producer / operator (mining), so the full nine-dimension rubric applies (Section 9) and the valuation runs sum-of-the-parts, with the Skarn, Escobal and Navidad as non-producing tiers (Section 7). (AISC = all-in sustaining cost, net of by-product credits; koz / Moz = thousand / million ounces; 2P = proven and probable reserves; M&I = measured and indicated resources; NSR = net smelter return royalty.)
Figure 1. Pan American Silver in numbers
overvalued
Figure data: audited 2025 financial statements (revenue, cash margin) and the 2025 MD&A (production, reserves); the 2025 production and 2026 guidance release (guidance); the Q1 2026 MD&A (net cash) and returns release (dividend); market data per stockanalysis.com as of the NYSE close on 7 August 2026. Rating per Section 9, valuation read per Section 7.
Table 1. Pan American Silver in numbers
| Metric | Value | As of |
|---|---|---|
| Share price / market capitalisation | $51.22 / $21.6 bn | 7 Aug 2026 |
| Enterprise value | $20.9 bn | 7 Aug 2026 |
| Shares outstanding / fully diluted | 421.4 m / 421.7 m | 31 Mar 2026 |
| Revenue | $3,619 m (FY2025); $2,818.9 m (FY2024) | FY2025 |
| Cash margin (revenue less production costs and royalties) | 52.6% | FY2025 |
| Q1 2026 revenue / operating cash flow | $1,154 m / $505 m | Q1 2026 |
| 2025 production | 22.84 Moz silver · 742.2 koz gold | FY2025 |
| 2026 production guidance | 25.0–27.0 Moz silver · 700–750 koz gold | 20 Jan 2026 |
| 2026 AISC guidance | $15.75–18.25/oz silver segment · $1,700–1,850/oz gold segment | 20 Jan 2026 |
| Proven & probable reserves | 452.3 Moz silver · 6,338.7 koz gold (excl. Juanicipio) | 30 Jun 2025 |
| Measured & indicated resources (excl. reserves) | 1,130.6 Moz silver · 7,882 koz gold | 30 Jun 2025 |
| Reserve life at 2025 output | silver 19.8 years (8.2 excl. Escobal) · gold 8.5 years | 30 Jun 2025 |
| Cash & short-term investments / total debt | $1,614 m / $845 m | 31 Mar 2026 |
| Net cash / net debt ÷ EBITDA | $679 m / not meaningful (net cash) | 31 Mar 2026 |
| Dividend per share | $0.18 quarterly ($0.72 annualised) | 5 May 2026 |
| NAV per share (fully diluted) / P/NAV | $30.19 (producing $21.23 · development $3.81 · resource $5.15) / 1.70× | 8 Aug 2026 |
| Quality rating / valuation read | 3.2/5 (Average) / Modestly overvalued (wide band), implied −29.1% | 8 Aug 2026 |
Source: audited 2025 financial statements (revenue, p.8); 2025 MD&A for production (p.7) and reserves and resources (p.54–56), prepared under NI 43-101 and CIM definitions; 2025 production and 2026 guidance release (p.4); Q1 2026 financial statements (revenue, operating cash flow, shares) and Q1 2026 MD&A (cash, debt and net cash, p.20); the returns release (dividend); market data per stockanalysis.com, 7 Aug 2026. Enterprise value is market capitalisation less the company’s $679 m of net cash, which already deducts leases; fully diluted shares add equity-settled RSUs and in-the-money options by the treasury method and exclude the 15.6 m CVR shares that issue only on an Escobal restart. Net cash excludes equity securities held as investments. Reserve life = reserves ÷ 2025 output. NAV and the read per Section 7.
Thesis in brief. Bull: no mine above 18% of revenue and no country above 23%; net cash and $2.4 bn of liquidity; $1.0 bn of 2025 free cash flow with 35–40% of it pledged back; silver guided up 14% in 2026; and a Skarn study worth $2.6 bn after tax at $45/oz silver. Bear: the lowest cash margin in its peer group, producing reserves of about eight years without Escobal, a share count doubled since 2021, and jurisdictions where fiscal terms keep moving. At $51.22 the shares sit 1.70× a NAV struck at $4,000 gold and $60 silver. What tips it: the metal prices, and whether the Skarn is sanctioned on terms that add value per share. The full rating is in Section 9.
How to read this analysis: here for the verdict? The statcards above and the rating in Section 9 are the whole story. Want the evidence? Read Section 2 (the assets) through Section 7 (the valuation).
2. Assets & operations
Pan American does not hedge precious metals. For how silver is priced and why miners gear it, see the Silver — A Complete Market Guide; this section is about the company.
2.1 Portfolio overview & map
Table 2. Asset base
| Asset | Location | Ownership | Stage | 2025 attributable output | 2026 guidance (output · AISC) | 2025 AISC | 2P reserves (30 Jun 2025) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jacobina | Bahia, Brazil | 100%, Jacobina Mineração e Comércio | Producing (underground) | 190.5 koz Au | 181–191 koz Au · $1,550–1,650/oz | $1,306/oz Au | 3,127.5 koz Au @ 1.77 g/t |
| El Peñon | Antofagasta, Chile | 100%, Minera Meridian | Producing (underground and pits) | 115.2 koz Au · 3.91 Moz Ag | 104–111 koz Au · 3.65–3.95 Moz Ag · $275–500/oz | $1,104/oz Au | 625.6 koz Au · 22.1 Moz Ag |
| Shahuindo | Peru | 100%, Shahuindo S.A.C. | Producing (heap leach) | 132.2 koz Au | 125.5–135.0 koz Au · $1,825–1,950/oz | $1,614/oz Au | 977.4 koz Au · 16.3 Moz Ag |
| Cerro Moro | Santa Cruz, Argentina | 100%, Estelar Resources | Producing (underground) | 2.51 Moz Ag · 83.1 koz Au | 2.80–3.00 Moz Ag · 80–86 koz Au · $(25.75)–(21.75)/oz | $(14.04)/oz Ag | 5.0 Moz Ag · 149.8 koz Au |
| Timmins | Ontario, Canada | 100%, Lake Shore Gold | Producing (two underground mines) | 103.6 koz Au | 105.5–115.0 koz Au · $2,575–2,675/oz | $2,443/oz Au | 845.9 koz Au |
| La Colorada (vein) | Zacatecas, Mexico | 100%, Plata Panamericana | Producing (underground) | 6.02 Moz Ag | 5.80–6.25 Moz Ag · $33.25–35.75/oz | $24.85/oz Ag | 90.7 Moz Ag @ 297 g/t |
| Minera Florida | Chile | 100%, Minera Florida | Producing (underground) | 68.6 koz Au | 66–71 koz Au · $2,550–2,675/oz | $2,537/oz Au | 270.9 koz Au |
| Huaron | Peru | 100%, Pan American Silver Huaron | Producing (underground) | 3.34 Moz Ag | 3.25–3.50 Moz Ag · $27.75–29.75/oz | $21.55/oz Ag | 40.7 Moz Ag |
| Dolores | Mexico | 100%, Compañía Minera Dolores | Residual leaching; mining ended Q3 2024 | 37.6 koz Au · 0.97 Moz Ag | 18–20 koz Au · $2,550–2,800/oz | $516/oz Au | none |
| Juanicipio | Zacatecas, Mexico | 44%, Minera Juanicipio (Fresnillo 56%, operator) | Producing; equity-accounted | 2.50 Moz Ag (from 4 Sep 2025) | 6.00–6.50 Moz Ag · $2.25–4.25/oz | $(3.18)/oz Ag | 8.2 Mt @ 221 g/t Ag, 44% basis (30 Jun 2024) |
| San Vicente | Bolivia | 95%, Pan American Silver (Bolivia) | Producing (underground) | 2.93 Moz Ag | 2.70–2.90 Moz Ag · $41.00–43.00/oz | $21.77/oz Ag | 11.4 Moz Ag |
| Escobal | Guatemala | 100%, Pan American Silver Guatemala | Suspended since 2017 | — | care and maintenance, $16–18 m | — | 264.5 Moz Ag @ 333 g/t (not updated since 2019) |
| La Colorada Skarn | Zacatecas, Mexico | 100%, Plata Panamericana | Preliminary economic assessment; access decline approved | — | project capital $92–95 m | — | none (308.7 Moz Ag indicated) |
| Navidad | Chubut, Argentina | 100%, Minera Argenta | Blocked by provincial law | — | — | — | none (632.3 Moz Ag measured and indicated) |
| Total | 22.84 Moz Ag · 742.2 koz Au | 25.0–27.0 Moz Ag · 700–750 koz Au · $15.75–18.25/oz silver segment · $1,700–1,850/oz gold segment | $13.88/oz silver segment · $1,590/oz gold segment | 452.3 Moz Ag · 6,338.7 koz Au (excl. Juanicipio) |
Source: Pan American Silver 2025 MD&A, “Operating Metrics” (p.30) for 2025 output, the AISC reconciliations (p.36, p.38) for mine AISC and “Mineral Reserves as of June 30, 2025” (p.54), prepared under NI 43-101 and CIM definitions; 2026 guidance per the 2025 production and 2026 guidance release, 20 January 2026 (p.4, p.6); ownership, holding entities, Juanicipio and Escobal per the 2025 Annual Information Form (p.12–16, p.36–39, p.57–59). Output, AISC and reserves are attributable — San Vicente at 95%, Juanicipio at 44% and only from the 4 September 2025 closing; AISC is by-product, per ounce sold. The Juanicipio reserve is Fresnillo’s JORC estimate, reviewed for Pan American; the AIF prints tonnes and grade only, so the contained ounces (≈58.3 Moz Ag, derived) sit outside the 452.3 Moz. Escobal’s reserve uses $20/oz silver and has not been updated since the 2019 Tahoe acquisition. Measured and indicated resources are reported exclusive of reserves — 1,130.6 Moz Ag and 7,882 koz Au, with 405.6 Moz Ag and 7,818 koz Au inferred (MD&A p.55–56); by mine, Jacobina 5,021.8 koz, El Peñon 451.0 koz, Minera Florida 405.3 koz, Timmins 305.1 koz and Shahuindo 182.0 koz of gold, and Huaron 16.2 Moz, La Colorada 14.8 Moz, Cerro Moro 8.3 Moz and San Vicente 6.0 Moz of silver; Juanicipio’s 44% resource is reported inclusive of its reserve (≈76.7 Moz Ag, derived; AIF p.39). Mineral resources are not mineral reserves and do not have demonstrated economic viability. Listed: Public (TSX: PAAS; NYSE: PAAS).
Two facts matter. Silver is the name, gold is the business: four of the five largest earners are gold-segment mines and the fifth, Cerro Moro, earns mostly gold, while Escobal holds 58% of the silver reserve and produces nothing. And producing reserves are short: excluding Escobal, silver reserves cover 8.2 years of 2025 output and gold 8.5. No asset exceeds 18% of 2025 attributable revenue and no country 23% (Chile). The asset map is not drawn (Section 10.1).
2.2 Where the revenue and the value sit
Figure 2. Revenue by metal, 2025
Figure data: derived from the 2025 MD&A, “Quantities and realized prices of metal sold” (p.14) — 752.9 koz of gold at $3,459/oz and 20,067 koz of silver at $40.78/oz, plus zinc, lead and copper — which sums to $3,614 m against reported revenue of $3,619 m. The audited 2025 financial statements, Note 26 (p.52), report “Refined silver and gold” as one $2,930 m line and concentrates by type ($688 m), so no filed split by metal exists.
Figure 3. Attributable revenue by operation, 2025
Figure data: audited 2025 financial statements, Note 26 “Segmented Information” (p.49), “Attributable Consolidated Total” $3,776 m; reported revenue of $3,619 m removes the 44% Juanicipio share and adds the non-controlling interests. In Q1 2026 Juanicipio earned $181 m, 13.6% of attributable revenue (Q1 2026 financial statements, p.17).
2.3 Jacobina
Jacobina, in Bahia, Brazil, is the largest earner ($658 m) and the gold-reserve anchor: 3.13 Moz at 1.77 g/t, 49% of group gold reserves and 16 years of 2025 output, mined by long-hole stoping at about 8,500 t/d. It pays Brazil’s 1.5% CFEM levy and no other royalty, and a SUDENE incentive cuts its income-tax rate to 6.25% until 2031. 2026 brings $53–57 m of project capital for new carbon-in-pulp tanks while filtration and paste plants are engineered; the asset risk is tailings capacity beyond 2032.
2.4 El Peñon
El Peñon, in Chile’s Antofagasta Region, earned $596 m at $1,104/oz, the gold segment’s cheapest full-scale mine. It pays NSRs of 1–2% to Triple Flag Precious Metals and 2% to Soquimich, plus Chile’s Specific Mining Tax. Its weakness is life: 625.6 koz of gold reserves is 5.4 years of output, so it depends on converting its 451 koz of exclusive measured and indicated resource.
2.5 Juanicipio
Pan American bought 44% of Juanicipio, in Zacatecas, with MAG Silver, closing on 4 September 2025 for $2,042 m — $500 m in cash and 60.2 m shares. Fresnillo holds 56% and operates; the stake is equity-accounted ($2,009 m on 31 March 2026) and pays Pan American only through dividends ($44 m in December 2025). At $(3.18)/oz AISC and 6.00–6.50 Moz guided for 2026, it is the portfolio’s best mine and this year’s largest silver contributor, with about 13 years of life. The risk is control: Pan American neither operates it nor sets its dividend.
2.6 La Colorada and the Skarn
The La Colorada vein mine produced 6.02 Moz in 2025 from 90.7 Moz of reserves, with a plan to 2039. Its costs are rising — 29% of 2025’s silver came from a neighbour’s concession under a net-profit share (about $30 m paid) — and Triple Flag streams its payable gold at $650/oz.
The value is below it. The La Colorada Skarn revised preliminary economic assessment (24 March 2026) shows an after-tax NPV(5%) of $2.6 bn and a 17% IRR at $45/oz silver ($4.2 bn at $60/oz and $3,400/t zinc), on $1.9 bn of initial capital: construction in 2026–2031, two years of ramp-up, then 15.8 Moz a year in 2034–38 (19.1 Moz for the expanded mine) over 37 years, on resource, not reserve. Approvals: the 588-level decline needs no further permit; 2025 permits cover twin declines, ventilation shafts, waste storage, camp and roads; the federal environmental (MIA), land-use (CUS) and water permits for the shafts, the 15,000 t/d plant and the tailings facility are outstanding. On 27 April 2026 the board approved $265 m over five years for the decline ($8 m spent in Q1), lifting 2026 Skarn spend to $92–95 m; a partner is under discussion. The project is not sanctioned.
2.7 Shahuindo
Shahuindo, a Peruvian heap-leach gold mine, earned $482 m from 132.2 koz at $1,614/oz in 2025, on reserves of 977.4 koz at about 0.4 g/t (7.4 years). Leaching costs lift 2026 AISC guidance to $1,825–1,950/oz, and a 2025 fatality cost the site its Towards Sustainable Mining (TSM) Level A rating.
2.8 Cerro Moro
Cerro Moro, in Argentina’s Santa Cruz province, produced 2.51 Moz of silver and 83.1 koz of gold; gold credits put its silver AISC at $(14.04)/oz. Royal Gold’s stream stepped down in July 2025 to 9% of silver at 30% of spot. Reserves of 149.8 koz of gold and 5.0 Moz of silver cover about two years, so the mine lives on resource conversion; a late-2025 Santa Cruz law requires 90% of mine workers to be local residents.
2.9 Timmins
Timmins — the Timmins West and Bell Creek underground mines in Ontario — produced 103.6 koz at $2,443/oz, the high-cost end of the segment, on 8.2 years of reserves. A $146 m first phase of the Timmins Camp Project, launched on 1 June 2026, deepens the Bell Creek shaft to 1,705 m for commissioning in the first half of 2029.
2.10 Escobal
Escobal, in Guatemala, holds 264.5 Moz of silver reserves at 333 g/t — 58% of the group total — and produces nothing. Its licence was suspended in July 2017 over the State’s failure to consult the Xinka people, and a Constitutional Court order of 3 September 2018 keeps it suspended until the Ministry of Energy and Mines completes a consultation under ILO 169, the International Labour Organization’s convention on Indigenous peoples. That consultation, slowed since January 2024, has no timeline and no restart date; holding the mine cost $21 m in 2025. The reserve has not been updated since the 2019 Tahoe acquisition, and Tahoe’s contingent value rights would hand 15.6 m shares to former holders on a restart.
2.11 Other operations and the pipeline
- Huaron (Peru): 3.34 Moz at $21.55/oz on 40.7 Moz of reserves.
- San Vicente (Bolivia, 95%): 2.93 Moz, with 2026 AISC guided at $41.00–43.00/oz and under four years of reserves.
- Minera Florida (Chile): 68.6 koz at $2,537/oz on 3.9 years of reserves.
- Dolores (Mexico): mining ended in Q3 2024; residual leaching and $15–17 m of 2026 reclamation.
- Navidad (Argentina): 632.3 Moz of silver measured and indicated, but Chubut law bans open pits and cyanide, likely making development “uneconomic or not possible” (AIF); carried at $191 m, under a silver stream whose terms are undisclosed.
- Manantial Espejo and Alamo Dorado (reclamation), La Bolsa and Canadian exploration ground, including Larder from MAG.
2.12 Group production, reserves & costs
Table 3. Group production and segment AISC, 2021–2025
| Metric | 2021 | 2022 | 2023 | 2024 | 2025 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Silver production (Moz) | 19.2 | 18.5 | 20.4 | 21.1 | 22.8 |
| Gold production (koz) | 579.3 | 552.5 | 882.9 | 892.5 | 742.2 |
| Silver segment AISC ($/oz) | 15.62 | 16.48 | 18.17 | 18.70 | 13.88 |
| Gold segment AISC ($/oz) | 1,214 | 1,649 | 1,371 | 1,530 | 1,590 |
Source: 2025 MD&A, “Consolidated” operating table (p.7) and AISC reconciliation (p.33) for 2024–2025; 2024 MD&A (p.6, p.29) and 2023 MD&A (p.7, p.30) for 2022–2023; 2022 MD&A (p.35) for 2021 AISC and the 2023 Annual Information Form (p.20) for 2021 production. Gold includes the Yamana mines from 31 March 2023 and La Arena until its 2 December 2024 sale; 2025 is attributable and includes 44% of Juanicipio from 4 September. AISC is per ounce sold, net of by-product credits; the 2021–2022 gold segment predates Yamana. Production history before 2021 is not shown because the source set’s filings do not reach it.
Figure 4. Attributable silver production, 2021–2025
Figure data: Table 3. The 2026 guidance of 25.0–27.0 Moz is a forecast and is not charted.
Reserves. Silver reserves fell from 468.0 to 452.3 Moz and gold from 6,651 to 6,339 koz in the year to 30 June 2025, after depletion and two sales; exploration replaced 10.3 Moz of silver and nearly 500 koz of gold. Behind them sit 1,130.6 Moz of exclusive silver measured and indicated resource, 83% of it at Navidad and the Skarn.
Costs. 2026 guidance — $15.75–18.25/oz silver segment, $1,700–1,850/oz gold — assumes $70 silver and $4,200 gold, which lift royalties and by-product credits alike (Q1 2026 silver AISC: $6.63/oz).
Figure 5. Reserves and resources by producing mine, 30 June 2025 (silver-equivalent)
Figure data: Pan American Silver 2025 MD&A, “Mineral Reserves as of June 30, 2025” and “Measured and Indicated Mineral Resources as of June 30, 2025” (pp.54–55) — proven and probable reserves (as in Table 2) and measured and indicated resources, which Pan American reports exclusive of reserves; NI 43-101 / CIM, attributable (San Vicente at 95%). Silver-equivalent is this analysis’s conversion: silver plus gold at the §7 base-deck ratio, $4,000/oz gold over $60/oz silver = 66.7:1, on contained ounces with no recovery or payability adjustment; copper, lead and zinc at Huaron, La Colorada and San Vicente are not on this scale. Timmins excludes the Whitney, Gold River, Marlhill and Vogel resources reported separately. Not drawn: Juanicipio (44%, equity-accounted, a 2024 statement), Dolores (residual leaching), Escobal (suspended), and the La Colorada Skarn, Navidad and La Bolsa resources outside any mine plan. The 30 June 2026 statement (16 September 2026) postdates this analysis. Inferred resources are not drawn.
By mine (Figure 5), Pan American’s largest reserve is a gold mine: Jacobina’s 3.1 Moz of gold is about 208 Moz AgEq, more than La Colorada’s 91 Moz of silver, and Jacobina carries more M&I beside it than the rest of the portfolio combined. Beside the silver mines’ reserves the M&I is thin, 6 to 20 Moz AgEq each, so the silver growth case — the La Colorada Skarn’s 309 Moz of indicated silver — sits outside every plan and off this chart.
2.13 Peer positioning
The peer set for every “vs peers” claim here is the listed silver and silver-gold producers of more than 15 Moz a year — Fresnillo, Coeur Mining, Hecla Mining and First Majestic Silver. None was under an unclosed takeover on 8 August 2026: Coeur closed its New Gold acquisition on 20 March 2026 (its 2025 figures are pre-deal), and First Majestic is selling San Martin, not being sold.
Table 4. Peer positioning — quality metrics, 2025
| Company | Listing | Silver | Gold | Revenue | Cash margin | P&P silver reserves · life | Largest country | 2026 silver guide vs 2025 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fresnillo | Public (LSE: FRES) | 48.7 Moz | 600 koz | $4,561 m | 69.2% | 362.6 Moz · 7.4 yr | Mexico, 100% | −9% |
| Pan American Silver | Public (TSX/NYSE: PAAS) | 22.8 Moz | 742 koz | $3,619 m | 52.6% | 452.3 Moz · 19.8 yr (8.2 yr ex-Escobal) | Chile, 23% | +14% |
| Coeur Mining | Public (NYSE: CDE) | 17.9 Moz | 419 koz | $2,070 m | 56.6% | 274.4 Moz · 15.3 yr | US, 57% of sales | +13% |
| Hecla Mining | Public (NYSE: HL) | 17.0 Moz | 151 koz | $1,423 m | 55.0% | 231.1 Moz · 13.6 yr | US, 82% of silver | −8% |
| First Majestic Silver | Public (NYSE/TSX: AG) | 15.4 Moz | 147 koz | $1,257 m | 56.8% | 101.1 Moz · 6.5 yr | Mexico, 100% | −3% |
Source: each company’s own 2025 filings — Fresnillo 2025 preliminary results, Coeur 2025 fourth-quarter results and year-end 2025 reserves, Hecla 2025 results and year-end 2025 reserves, First Majestic 2025 audited financial statements, 2025 reserves and 2026 outlook; Pan American per Tables 2 and 5. Cash margin = revenue less cost of sales excluding depreciation, over revenue (Pan American: production costs and royalties). Reserve life = silver reserves ÷ 2025 silver output. Reserves are proven and probable under each company’s regime — JORC (Fresnillo), NI 43-101 (Pan American, First Majestic), S-K 1300 (Coeur, Hecla) — effective 31 Dec 2025 except Fresnillo’s 30 Apr 2025 (2025 annual report, p.19) and Pan American’s 30 Jun 2025, so the comparison is P&P across three regimes. Fresnillo’s silver includes Silverstream ounces; its and Coeur’s AISC are not published on a comparable basis, so AISC is left out. Screen the silver producers on grade, cost and reserve life at Metal Pilot’s silver mining stock screener.
Pan American is second in silver and first in gold; its reserve life leads only through Escobal, its cash margin trails. What no peer matches is the spread: five countries above 10% of revenue each. For the five side by side on one construction, see Silver Producers Compared; ranked on silver output and placed on five measures, the group lines up in Best Silver Stocks.
3. Financials & balance sheet
The three statements are read as the Financial Metrics for Commodity Investing guide sets out: is the margin real, does the balance sheet survive a lower price, does the cash arrive?
Table 5. Five-year financial summary (years ended 31 December)
| Metric | 2021 | 2022 | 2023 | 2024 | 2025 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue | $1,632.7 m | $1,494.7 m | $2,316.1 m | $2,818.9 m | $3,619 m |
| Revenue YoY % | — | −8.5% | +55.0% | +21.7% | +28.4% |
| Cash margin | 41.1% | 24.4% | 33.7% | 39.7% | 52.6% |
| Net earnings (attributable) | $97.4 m | $(341.7) m | $(103.7) m | $111.5 m | $978 m |
| EPS (diluted) | $0.46 | $(1.62) | $(0.32) | $0.31 | $2.56 |
| Operating cash flow | $392.1 m | $31.8 m | $450.2 m | $724.1 m | $1,333 m |
| Capex (cash paid) | $243.5 m | $274.7 m | $379.0 m | $323.3 m | $314 m |
| Sustaining capital | $207.6 m | $223.8 m | $288.5 m | $279.0 m | $284 m |
| Project capital | $50.0 m | $71.0 m | $94.5 m | $93.4 m | $94 m |
| Free cash flow | $148.6 m | $(242.9) m | $71.2 m | $400.8 m | $1,019 m |
| Cash & short-term investments | $335.3 m | $142.3 m | $440.9 m | $887.3 m | $1,319 m |
| Total debt incl. leases | $45.9 m | $226.8 m | $801.6 m | $803.3 m | $852 m |
| Net cash / (net debt) | $289.4 m | $(84.5) m | $(360.7) m | $84.0 m | $467 m |
| Net debt / EBITDA | net cash | 1.6× | 0.7× | net cash | net cash |
| Diluted shares (weighted) | 210.4 m | 210.5 m | 326.5 m | 363.4 m | 381.6 m |
| Dividend paid per share | $0.34 | $0.45 | $0.40 | $0.40 | $0.46 |
Notes to Table 5
- Cash margin = revenue less production costs and royalties, over revenue; free cash flow = operating cash flow less capex paid; EBITDA = earnings from operations plus depreciation and amortization — all three derived from filed lines, as the company publishes no EBITDA.
- Sustaining capital is the company’s non-GAAP measure — cash capex plus lease payments and loan repayments, less project (investment) capital — so the two capital lines do not add to the cash line; from 2025 it includes Pan American’s share of Juanicipio’s capital.
- The company’s own “net cash” excludes equity securities held as investments: $391 m at 31 December 2025.
Source: audited 2025 financial statements (p.7–9) and 2025 MD&A (p.5, p.28, p.34) for 2025; 2024 financial statements (p.6–8) and 2024 MD&A (p.4, p.30) for 2024; 2023 financial statements (p.8–10) and 2023 MD&A (p.5, p.25, p.31) for 2022–2023 and the 2022 MD&A, “Reconciliation of payments for mineral properties, plant and equipment and sustaining capital” (p.36), for the 2021 capital split; 2022 financial statements (p.6–8) for 2021, whose figures are in thousands of US dollars, converted here. 2021 revenue growth is not shown because the 2020 comparative is outside the source set. IFRS, US dollars, calendar year.
Earnings and cash. The record is an acquisition digested. Yamana’s mines lifted 2023 revenue 55%, but 2022–2023 carried $157 m of deal costs, a $99 m impairment, inventory write-downs and net losses. 2025 is the first clean year: a 52.6% cash margin, $978 m of net earnings (adjusted: $959 m, so no large add-backs) and $1,019 m of free cash flow. Cash backs the profit: five-year operating cash flow of $2.93 bn against $0.74 bn of net earnings, free cash flow positive in four years of five, and sustaining capital flat near $280 m while output grew.
Balance sheet. On 31 March 2026 Pan American held $1,614 m of cash and short-term investments — plus $199 m inside Juanicipio attributable to its 44% — against $845 m of debt carried on the balance sheet: the 4.63% notes due December 2027 ($279 m; $283 m face), the 2.63% notes due August 2031 ($433 m; $500 m face), $4 m of construction loans and $129 m of leases. Net cash was $679 m, the $750 m revolver (to November 2028) was undrawn, liquidity was $2.4 bn, the current ratio 2.8×, and the ratings Baa3 and BBB−. Stress test: a 10% move in all metal prices moves annual revenue by about $355 m, so a 30% fall would take roughly $1.07 bn off 2025’s $1.73 bn of EBITDA and still leave net cash; cash covers the only pre-2028 maturity five times. Other 31 March claims the valuation bridges: $212 m of receivables, $565 m of payables, $223 m of tax payable, $36 m of litigation and $68 m of severance provisions, $90 m of equity securities and the $37 m La Arena contingent payment. The real long-dated liability is closure: the asset-retirement provision is $590 m, against an undiscounted, inflated estimate of $935 m.
Hedging. No precious-metal, base-metal or diesel hedges — only Canadian-dollar ($27 m at C$1.40) and Brazilian-real ($9 m at R$6.95) forwards to December 2026.
Table 6. Cost deck handed to the valuation
| Line | Value | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Silver segment AISC, 2026 guidance | $15.75–18.25/oz | at $70/oz silver and $4,200/oz gold |
| Gold segment AISC, 2026 guidance | $1,700–1,850/oz | same deck |
| Sustaining / project capital, 2026 | $320–340 m / $240–255 m | project capital raised 5 May 2026 for the Skarn |
| Project capital by mine, 2026 | Skarn $92–95 m · Jacobina $53–57 m · Timmins $40–43 m · Huaron $16–17 m · Cerro Moro $13–14 m · Juanicipio $11–12 m · La Colorada vein $9–10 m · Shahuindo $6–7 m | original split; only the Skarn line was revised |
| Base metals, 2026 guidance | zinc 58.5–62.5 kt · lead 30.5–32.5 kt · copper 2.0 kt | guidance deck $3,000/t zinc, $2,000/t lead, $10,000/t copper |
| Exploration, G&A, care and maintenance, 2026 | $132–135 m · $100–105 m · $26–28 m | exploration partly inside sustaining and project capital |
| Mexico mining duties | 8.5% of an EBITDA-type base + 1.0% of gold and silver sales | raised from 7.5% and 0.5% for 2025 |
| Chile Specific Mining Tax | 5–7% applied (4–14% scale) | El Peñon, Minera Florida |
| Brazil CFEM | 1.5% of revenue | Jacobina; SUDENE income-tax cut to 2031 |
| Streams | Cerro Moro: 9% of silver at 30% of spot · La Colorada: gold at $650/oz | Royal Gold · Triple Flag |
| Unit-cost profile, 2025 → 2026 guidance | La Colorada $24.85 → $33.25–35.75/oz · San Vicente $21.77 → $41.00–43.00/oz · El Peñon $1,104 → $275–500/oz | third-party concession share at La Colorada; labour at San Vicente; silver credits at El Peñon |
| Royalties in AISC, 2025 | $113 m (3.1% of revenue) | largest: La Colorada $32 m, San Vicente $33 m |
| Income tax | 21% effective rate 2025; $318 m paid; $500–550 m guided for 2026; 27% Canadian statutory rate in the reconciliation | already a full cash taxpayer; the $1,160 m of unrecognised losses sit mostly in Canada, away from the mines |
| Depreciation and amortization, 2026 | $500–525 m | guidance |
| Cost inflation | no rate disclosed | 2026 AISC rise attributed to price-linked royalties, workers’ participation and smelting charges, plus labour, haulage and leaching costs |
Source: 2025 production and 2026 guidance release (p.4–6); 2025 MD&A (p.20–23, p.36, p.38); Q1 2026 MD&A (p.3) for the revised project capital; 2025 Annual Information Form (p.23, p.30, p.42, p.50) for duties, streams and the Jacobina incentive; audited 2025 financial statements, Note 23 (p.44–45), and the cash-flow statement (p.9) for tax. Guidance is a forecast, not a result.
Capital returns and dilution. Pan American returned $221 m in 2025 ($175 m of dividends, $46 m of buybacks) and on 5 May 2026 committed 35–40% of attributable free cash flow — up to $1 bn in 2026: $305 m of dividends ($0.18 a quarter) and buybacks under a bid for up to 21.1 m shares to March 2027. The red flag is the share count: diluted shares rose from 210 m to 382 m over 2021–2025 (Yamana cost 153.8 m shares, MAG 60.2 m), with 421.4 m outstanding on 31 March 2026 — though operating cash flow per diluted share still rose from $1.86 to $3.49.
4. Management, strategy & corporate structure
4.1 Management & governance
Michael Steinmann, a geologist (PhD, ETH Zurich) with the company since 2004, has been CEO since January 2016. Ignacio Couturier, also there since 2004, has been CFO since March 2022. Scott Campbell, formerly of Dundee Precious Metals, became COO on 20 October 2025, succeeding Steven Busby, now special advisor to the CEO. Christopher Lemon is Chief Legal Officer and General Counsel.
The board has ten directors, nine independent, chaired since May 2021 by Gillian Winckler, who spent 16 years in strategy and M&A at BHP Billiton. Its five committees are Audit (Jennifer Maki), Human Resources and Compensation (Charles Jeannes), Health, Safety and Environment (John Begeman), Nominating and Governance (Neil de Gelder) and Communities and Sustainable Development, whose chair Kathleen Sendall retired at the 30 April 2026 meeting, when Ignacio Bustamante, a former Hochschild Mining CEO, joined. No shareholder holds over 10% and directors and officers own 0.07%. The signal to weigh: say-on-pay fell to 80.8% from 95.4% after C$14.8 m of 2025 CEO pay.
4.2 Strategy & capital allocation
The stated mission is to be “the world’s premier silver producer”, through growth, reserve replacement and acquisitions where it already works. The last decade was built by acquisition — Tahoe Resources (2019: Escobal), Yamana Gold’s Latin American mines (2023: Jacobina, El Peñon, Minera Florida, Cerro Moro) and MAG Silver (2025: 44% of Juanicipio) — with non-core sales behind them, chiefly La Arena to Zijin (December 2024).
The 5 May 2026 framework ranks uses of cash as sustaining capital, balance sheet, organic growth, then returns. The named growth is organic — the Skarn decline ($265 m), Jacobina, the Bell Creek shaft ($146 m) and a $132–135 m, 600,000-metre exploration programme — toward 25–27 Moz of silver and 700–750 koz of gold in 2026 and, if the Skarn is built, 19.1 Moz a year from La Colorada in 2034–38.
4.3 Ownership & corporate structure
Table 7. Capital structure and corporate events
| Item | Detail | As of |
|---|---|---|
| Common shares outstanding | 421.4 m | 31 Mar 2026 |
| Options / RSUs (equity-settled) | 0.12 m / 0.18 m | 31 Mar 2026 |
| Tahoe contingent value rights | 313.9 m CVRs, convertible into 15.6 m shares on the first commercial concentrate shipment after an Escobal restart; 10-year term from 22 Feb 2019 | 31 Mar 2026 |
| Normal course issuer bid | up to 21.1 m shares, 6 Mar 2026 – 5 Mar 2027 | 4 Mar 2026 |
| Juanicipio | 44% (Minera Juanicipio); Fresnillo 56% and operator; equity method | 4 Sep 2025 |
| San Vicente | 95%; Urion Holdings (Malta) 5% | 31 Dec 2025 |
| Cerro Moro | 100% of Estelar Resources; Fomento Minero de Santa Cruz holds preferred shares equal to 5% | 31 Dec 2025 |
| MAG Silver acquisition | $500 m cash + 60.2 m shares ($2,042 m in total) | 4 Sep 2025 |
| La Arena sale (to Zijin) | $307 m cash on closing + $50 m contingent on La Arena II production + a 1.5% gold NSR | 2 Dec 2024 |
| Yamana Latin American mines | 153.8 m shares | 31 Mar 2023 |
| Listings | TSX and NYSE, symbol PAAS (NYSE since 18 Apr 2023) | — |
| Credit ratings | Baa3 (Moody’s) / BBB− (S&P) | 18 Feb 2026 |
Source: Q1 2026 financial statements, Notes 11 and 14 (p.13–15), for shares, options, RSUs and CVRs; NCIB release, 4 March 2026; 2025 Annual Information Form (p.10, p.16–17, p.36, p.90) for the CVR terms, subsidiaries, Juanicipio, listings and ratings; audited 2025 financial statements, Notes 8 and 12 (p.26, p.36–37), for MAG and La Arena; 2024 financial statements, Note 8 (p.25), for Yamana. Listed: Public (TSX: PAAS; NYSE: PAAS).
The structure is simple — mostly wholly-owned mines, one joint venture, no controlling holder — with two overhangs: the Tahoe rights (15.6 m shares, 3.7% of today’s count, if Escobal restarts) and a register doubled since 2021 by share-funded deals.
5. ESG & sustainability
Table 8. ESG snapshot
| Pillar | Named programme or issue | Measurable attribute | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Social licence | Escobal ILO 169 consultation (Guatemala) | Licence suspended July 2017; court order of 3 Sep 2018; substantive consultation since 2022 | Ongoing — no timeline |
| Safety | Critical Risk Management; Human and Organizational Performance | 2 fatalities; lost-time injury frequency 0.61 per million hours; 570 advocates trained | Missed 2025 objectives |
| Climate | Scope 1+2 reduction target | ≥30% by 2030 vs a 2019 baseline; renewable certificates at six sites | 2025 annual target beaten |
| Standards | Towards Sustainable Mining; Responsible Gold Mining Principles | TSM Level A or higher at all sites except Shahuindo and Jacobina; RGMP implementation completed | 2025 |
| Community | Community investment | $20.4 m, three new local economic-development initiatives | 2025 |
| Land | Rehabilitation | 62 hectares rehabilitated | Above annual goal |
| Environment | Water and waste reduction projects (Huaron, Minera Florida) | Delayed | Goal missed |
| Disclosure | GRI, SASB, TCFD; partial TNFD; UN Global Compact since 2020 | Annual sustainability report | Published 28 May 2026 |
Source: 2025 Annual Information Form (p.19, p.24–28, p.57, p.66); 2025 Sustainability Report release, 28 May 2026. Absolute emissions, water volumes, the tailings-facility count and TRIFR are not in the source set (Section 10.1).
The defining ESG fact is Escobal: a mine stopped not by geology but by the State of Guatemala’s failure to consult the Xinka people, and restartable only when that consultation ends. Elsewhere the record is mixed. Two workers died in 2025 — at Shahuindo and Jacobina, which lost their TSM Level A ratings — and the injury rate was, in the AIF’s words, “substantially higher than our objectives”. Against that: no significant environmental incident, clean regulatory inspections, an emissions target on track and a top-5% S&P Global sustainability ranking. Every operation but Timmins sits in a country that has ratified ILO 169, so consultation risk is not unique to Guatemala.
6. Risks
Table 9. Risk register
| Risk | Type | Likelihood / impact (1–5) | Who or what is exposed | Mitigant |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Silver and gold fall back from 2026 levels | Commodity | 3 / 5 | Every mine; the policy is not to hedge precious metals | Net cash; $2.4 bn of liquidity; Jacobina, El Peñon and Juanicipio low on the cost curve |
| Fiscal and regulatory change in Mexico, Peru, Bolivia and Argentina | Jurisdiction | 4 / 4 | Mexico’s 2023 mining-law reform and 2025 duty increases; Bolivia’s contractual title at San Vicente; Peru’s tax proposals; Santa Cruz hiring law | Spread across seven producing countries, none above 23% of revenue |
| Escobal stays suspended | Jurisdiction / licence | 4 / 3 | 58% of silver reserves; $16–18 m a year of holding cost | No restart assumed in guidance; the Tahoe rights share any restart value |
| La Colorada Skarn capital and permits | Execution | 3 / 3 | $1.9 bn of study capital on a preliminary assessment with no reserve; federal permits outstanding | Only the $265 m decline is committed; partnering under discussion |
| Short reserve lives at producing mines | Operational | 4 / 2 | Cerro Moro, San Vicente, Minera Florida and El Peñon under six years of reserves | $132–135 m exploration budget; resource conversion record |
| Minority position at Juanicipio | Counterparty | 2 / 3 | The largest 2026 silver contributor; cash only via dividends | Fresnillo’s operating record; 44% of joint-venture cash |
| Safety and social licence at the mines | ESG | 3 / 2 | Two fatalities in 2025; informal miners at Shahuindo; Quiruvilca labour claims at Huaron | Critical Risk Management rollout; TSM protocols |
| Navidad stays blocked | Jurisdiction | 4 / 1 | 56% of silver measured and indicated resource | Carried at $191 m; not in the valuation’s producing tier |
Source: risk factors in the 2025 Annual Information Form, “Risks Related to Our Business” (p.64–88) — Mexico (p.68–69), Bolivia (p.66, p.71), Argentina (p.68–69, p.72), Peru (p.67, p.72, p.75), Guatemala (p.66), Juanicipio (p.73); the Q1 2026 MD&A (p.17–18) for Escobal and the Skarn. Likelihood and impact scores are the author’s assessment on a 1–5 scale, not disclosed figures.
Figure 6. Risk matrix — likelihood against impact
Rare
Likely
Figure data: Table 9. Each point prints its likelihood × impact score; the shaded region is the high-likelihood, high-impact quadrant. Scores are the author’s assessment, not disclosed figures.
Two risks carry the thesis. The metal price is the obvious one: an unhedged producer with most of its revenue in gold and a silver name on the door moves with both metals, and the valuation’s bear cases in Section 7 price exactly that. The fiscal and regulatory risk is the permanent one: Mexico raised its mining duties for 2025 and restricted concessions and water in 2023; Bolivia’s state holds title at San Vicente; Peru’s government has floated higher mining taxes; Santa Cruz legislated local hiring in late 2025. Escobal and Navidad are the same risk made concrete. The Skarn is the risk management chooses to take; Section 7 values it as an unsanctioned study.
7. Valuation
Valuation as of 8 August 2026, in US dollars (Pan American reports in US dollars and the valuation is struck on the NYSE listing, so no FX conversion is needed). Horizon: spot fair value. Price deck: base gold $4,000/oz — the 3-month trailing average of $4,296/oz (May–July 2026), against a 6-month average of $4,581 and a 12-month average of $4,311, all LBMA monthly averages per the World Bank Pink Sheet to 31 July 2026. The 3-month window is the representative one because the 6- and 12-month windows still carry the January–February peak of $5,020; it sits $46 above the midpoint between two grid prices, inside a window whose monthly prices fell from $4,587 to $4,073, so it takes the lower grid price, $4,000. Every grid price from $3,000 to $5,000/oz is run as a scenario (deep bear $3,000 / bear $3,500 / base $4,000 / bull $4,500 / deep bull $5,000). Silver, 31.9% of enterprise NAV, is decked at $60/oz — its own 3-month average of $67.83 (6-month $73.20, 12-month $64.53, same series), which takes the lower price of the $40–80 silver grid for the same reason (monthly prices fell from $78.0 to $58.8 over the window) — and co-moves step-for-step with gold in every scenario (gold $3,500 pairs with silver $50), because the two are a documented co-moving pair; the ratio is not fixed, and Figure 9 and Table 16 price a move in silver alone. Zinc, lead and copper are by-products — zinc, the largest, is 6.1% of enterprise NAV — held in every column at their 3-month averages taken to their grids: zinc $2,800 / 3,200 / 3,600 / 4,000 / 4,400/t ($3,540 → $3,600), lead $1,600 / 1,800 / 2,000 / 2,200 / 2,400/t ($1,926 → $2,000), copper the fixed $4–8/lb grid ($6.14 → $6.00). The Reuters poll’s 2026 averages of $4,509/oz gold and $72/oz silver are an unweighted cross-check; no spot deck is carried. Discount rate 5% real, after tax — the precious-metals convention, sensitised 4–7%. Share price $51.22 (NYSE close, 7 August 2026); 421.4 m basic and 421.7 m fully diluted shares; balance sheet as of 31 March 2026.
Pan American is valued on the producer (mining) archetype, run as a sum-of-the-parts of eleven producing mines — Juanicipio at its equity-accounted 44% — plus the La Colorada Skarn study, the suspended Escobal reserve and a resource tier. The method is set out in The Commodity Investor, Part 11: How to Value Commodity Stocks. The blended fair value is $36.29 per share at the base prices ($4,000 gold, $60 silver), $25.18 at $3,500 and $50, and $47.05 at $4,500 and $70; each co-moved step moves NAV per share by $8.34 — $4.74 of it from $500/oz of gold and $3.60 from $10/oz of silver (Table 16). The producing mines plus the equity bridge are worth $21.23 per share, the risked Skarn and Escobal $3.81 and the resource beyond the plans $5.15.
What §7 starts from. The figures below set the builds, the tax bases and the bridge; every other filed or market input is in the §10.1 register (Table 27).
Table 10. Load-bearing inputs — the filed figures the valuation moves on
| Input | Value | Where §7 uses it | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jacobina guidance | 181.0–191.0 koz gold at an AISC of $1,550–1,650/oz · 20 Jan 2026 | Table 13, block 1 — the largest asset | Filed | 2025 production release | “2026 Silver and Gold Production and AISC Forecasts” | “Jacobina (Brazil)" | p.4 |
| Juanicipio guidance (44%) | 6.00–6.50 Moz silver at an AISC of $2.25–4.25/oz · 20 Jan 2026 | Table 13, block 8 | Filed | 2025 production release | “2026 Silver and Gold Production and AISC Forecasts” | “Juanicipio (Mexico) (3)" | p.4 |
| El Peñon guidance | 104.0–111.0 koz gold and 3.65–3.95 Moz silver at an AISC of $275–500/oz · 20 Jan 2026 | Table 13, block 2 | Filed | 2025 production release | “2026 Silver and Gold Production and AISC Forecasts” | “El Peñon (Chile)" | p.4 |
| Group production guidance | 25.00–27.00 Moz silver; 700.0–750.0 koz gold · 20 Jan 2026 | Table 19 — the next-twelve-month revenue | Filed | 2025 production release | “2026 Silver and Gold Production and AISC Forecasts” | “Total Attributable Production” | p.4 |
| Price deck behind the AISC guidance | silver $70.00/oz; gold $4,200/oz · 20 Jan 2026 | Table 13 — every by-product credit is moved from this deck to the base prices | Filed | 2025 production release | 2026 Silver and Gold Production and AISC Forecasts, note 1 | “The AISC forecasts assume” | p.4 |
| Sustaining and project capital | $320–340 m sustaining · 20 Jan 2026; $240–255 m project · 5 May 2026 | Table 21 — free cash flow before and after growth capital | Filed | 2025 production release | “2026 Expenditures Forecast” | “Sustaining Capital Total” | p.6; Q1 2026 MD&A | “2026 Operating Outlook” | “increasing full year consolidated project capital expenditures to be between” | p.3 |
| La Colorada Skarn PEA after-tax NPV5% | $4.2 bn at $60/oz silver and $3,400/t zinc · 24 Mar 2026 | Table 13, block 13 — before the roll and the 0.30× weight | Filed | La Colorada TR 2026 | Table 24-19 | “NPV (5%) (After-tax) (US$ billion)" | p.166 |
| Gold reserves, gold-segment mines | 5,847.2 koz · 30 Jun 2025 | Table 13 — each gold mine’s life and the gold in-plan value per ounce | Filed | MD&A 2025 | “Mineral Reserves as of June 30, 2025” | “Total Gold Segment (5)" | p.54 |
| Gold M&I exclusive of reserves, same mines | 6,365.2 koz · 30 Jun 2025 | Table 13, block 15 — the gold resource tier at 0.25× | Filed | MD&A 2025 | “Measured and Indicated Mineral Resources as of June 30, 2025” | “Contained Au (koz)" | p.55 1 |
| Statutory tax rates | Mexico 8.5% duty + 30% income tax; Chile 5–7% + 27%; Jacobina 15.25% to 2031, then 34%; elsewhere 27% | Table 13 — every author-built block’s after-tax margin; Table 21 — the cash-tax line | Filed | AIF 2025 | “Juanicipio” | “conventional profit-based tax using the 30% corporate tax rate” | p.37; “El Peñon” | “Minera Meridian is subject to the Specific Mining Tax” | p.50; “Jacobina” | “resulting in a combined decrease in income tax and social contribution rates from” | p.42; FS 2025 | Note 23 | “Statutory Canadian income tax rate” | p.45 2 |
| Cash and debt | cash $1,495 m; debt $4 m + $712 m · 31 Mar 2026 | Table 15 — the net-cash line, $808.0 m with the leases in the rows | Filed | Q1 2026 FS | Statements of Financial Position | “Cash and cash equivalents (Note 15)" | p.2 |
| Reclamation provision | $590 m · 31 Mar 2026 | Table 15 — the reclamation line, at carrying value | Filed | Q1 2026 FS | Note 9 | “Asset retirement obligations, closing balance” | p.11 |
| Fully diluted shares | 421.688 m — 421,424 thousand basic plus equity-settled RSUs and options · 31 Mar 2026 | every per-share figure in §7 | Filed | Q1 2026 FS | Statements of Changes in Equity | “Balance, March 31, 2026” | p.5 |
Notes to Table 10
- The sum of the filed measured and indicated rows for Jacobina, El Peñon, Shahuindo, Timmins and Minera Florida; every company resource is reported exclusive of reserves.
- Mexico’s duty is the 8.5% special mining duty on an EBITDA-type base, so the combined rate on margin is 35.95% (8.5% + 30% × 91.5%); Chile’s Specific Mining Tax is taken at 6%, the middle of the 5–7% applied, for 31.38% with the 27% first-category tax. The Peru, Bolivia, Argentina and Ontario rows take the 27% Canadian rate of the company’s own tax reconciliation, because their country rates are not in the source set (Table 24, field 11).
Source: the 2025 production and 2026 guidance release (20 January 2026); the Q1 2026 MD&A and condensed interim consolidated financial statements, 31 March 2026 (5 May 2026); the La Colorada NI 43-101 technical report (effective 24 March 2026); the 2025 MD&A, FY2025 financial statements and 2025 Annual Information Form. Page numbers are those of each filed document as rendered on EDGAR. All figures in US dollars. Reserves and resources are effective 30 June 2025 (Juanicipio 30 June 2024), guidance 20 January 2026 with project capital revised 5 May 2026, and the balance sheet 31 March 2026 — the section’s vintages, each printed with its row. The share price the section is read against ($51.22, 7 August 2026) is in the opening block, not here: it moves the rating, not the valuation. The full register — every figure §7 takes from outside this analysis — is Table 27 in §10.1.
8. Near-term catalysts (1–3 years)
Table 25. Near-term catalysts
| Catalyst | Expected timing | Why it benefits Pan American |
|---|---|---|
| Juanicipio’s first full year at 44% | 2026 | 6.00–6.50 Moz of silver at $2.25–4.25/oz AISC — the largest single silver contributor, against 2.50 Moz for four months of 2025 |
| Silver growth to 25–27 Moz | 2026 | +14% on 2025 at the midpoint, with gold held at 700–750 koz |
| Shareholder-return framework | 2026, then annually | 35–40% of attributable free cash flow — $305 m of dividends plus buybacks under a bid for up to 21.1 m shares to March 2027 |
| Jacobina optimisation | New CIP tanks due Q2 2026; engineering through 2026 | Recovery and throughput at the largest gold reserve; filtration and paste plants to carry the plan past 2032 |
| 30 June 2026 reserve statement | Second half of 2026 | The first estimate at 2026 prices, against a 2025 statement struck at $22–28/oz silver and $1,900–2,500/oz gold |
| La Colorada Skarn decline and funding decision | Decline 2026–2031; partnering under discussion | $265 m commits access to a deposit the study values at $2.6 bn after tax; a partner would share the $1.9 bn initial capital |
| Timmins Bell Creek shaft | Commissioning H1 2029 | $146 m phase 1 to deepen the shaft to 1,705 m and extend the mine |
Source: 2025 production and 2026 guidance release (p.4); returns release, 5 May 2026; Q1 2026 MD&A (p.3, p.17) for Jacobina and the Skarn; 2025 MD&A, “Metal Price Assumptions” (p.57), for the reserve price deck; Timmins Camp Project release, 1 June 2026. Timing is company guidance, not a guarantee.
Every catalyst here is already funded or scheduled; none needs a government to act. Juanicipio’s full year and the return framework carry 2026. The reserve statement is the quiet one: 2025’s reserves were struck at $22/oz silver at La Colorada and Huaron and $1,900/oz gold at Jacobina, far below the Section 7 base deck, so a re-pricing is more likely to add ounces than remove them. Escobal and Navidad are left out: neither has a date.
9. Rating & verdict
Pan American is scored on the nine dimensions every Metal Pilot analysis uses, against the Section 2.13 peer set, with the producer weighting — 15% each for asset quality, cost, reserves, balance sheet and capital allocation, 6.25% for the other four. None is not-applicable.
Figure 11. Scorecard by dimension, 8 August 2026
Figure data: Table 26. Each spoke prints its stars and weight; the dashed ring is the weighted composite, 3.15/5.
Table 26. Scorecard rationale
| Dimension | Weight | Score | Rationale |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Asset quality & scale | 15% | ★★★★☆ | $3,619 m of 2025 revenue, second of the five, from eleven mines with none above 18% and no country above 23%; Juanicipio’s $(3.18)/oz AISC and Jacobina’s 3.13 Moz reserve are the tier-one pieces (Tables 2, 4) |
| 2. Cost position & margins | 15% | ★★☆☆☆ | 52.6% cash margin in 2025, lowest of the five (peers 55.0–69.2%); gold segment AISC $1,590/oz with Timmins, Minera Florida and San Vicente at the high end (Tables 2, 4, 5) |
| 3. Reserves, life & replacement | 15% | ★★★☆☆ | 452.3 Moz of P&P silver reserves reads as 19.8 years, the longest of the five, but 8.2 years excluding Escobal — beside Fresnillo’s 7.4 and First Majestic’s 6.5, short of Hecla’s 13.6 and Coeur’s 15.3; gold 8.5 years; exploration replaced 10.3 Moz of 22.8 Moz silver produced (Section 2.12) |
| 5. Balance sheet & liquidity | 15% | ★★★★☆ | $679 m net cash and $2.4 bn of liquidity at 31 March 2026, Baa3/BBB−, cash five times the only pre-2028 maturity; net cash through a 30% metal-price fall; at end-2025 its $501 m net cash (cash less debt) was level with First Majestic’s $501.2 m, behind Fresnillo’s $1,916.6 m and ahead of Coeur’s $213.1 m net cash and Hecla’s $34.2 m net debt (Section 3) |
| 6. Capital allocation & returns | 15% | ★★★☆☆ | Share count from 210 m to 421 m since 2021 on the Yamana and MAG deals — diluted weighted shares +81% over 2021–2025 (210.4 m to 381.6 m), against +21% at Hecla, +98% at First Majestic, +146% at Coeur and none at Fresnillo — with 2022–23 losses; offset by operating cash flow per share up 88% and a framework returning 35–40% of free cash flow (Section 3, 4.2) |
| 4. Growth & optionality | 6.25% | ★★★★☆ | 2026 silver guidance +14%, against −9% to +13% for the peers; the Skarn study (19.1 Moz a year for the expanded mine) and the Bell Creek shaft funded from cash (Sections 2.6, 8) |
| 7. Management & governance | 6.25% | ★★★☆☆ | A CEO and CFO with the company since 2004, an independent chair and nine of ten directors independent; against that, say-on-pay fell to 80.8% and directors and officers own 0.07% (Section 4.1) |
| 8. Jurisdiction & geopolitics | 6.25% | ★★☆☆☆ | Mexico, Peru, Bolivia, Argentina and Guatemala carry most of the value, where Hecla and Coeur earn most of theirs in the US; Mexico raised mining duties for 2025, and Escobal and Navidad are stranded by government action (Sections 2.10, 6) |
| 9. ESG & licence to operate | 6.25% | ★★★☆☆ | Two fatalities and injury rates above objective in 2025, and the Escobal consultation unresolved; no significant environmental incident and a top-5% S&P Global sustainability ranking (Section 5) |
| Composite | 100% | ★★★ | Average |
Source: each row cites its evidence in this analysis; peer figures are those of Table 4, from each company’s own 2025 filings. Rows 5 and 6, net cash or debt at 31 December 2025 and diluted weighted shares in 2021 and 2025, each from the company’s own filings: Pan American FY2025 statements (p.7, p.8) and FY2022 statements (p.7); Fresnillo 2025 annual report (net cash, p.13; shares, p.50) and 2022 annual report (p.14); Coeur 2025 Form 10-K (net debt, p.64; shares, p.104) and 2021 Form 10-K (p.95); Hecla FY2025 results release (net debt, p.26), 2025 Form 10-K and 2021 Form 10-K (p.119); First Majestic FY2025 statements (p.13, p.10) and FY2022 statements (p.8).
Weighted average: (0.15 × 4) + (0.15 × 2) + (0.15 × 3) + (0.15 × 4) + (0.15 × 3) + (0.0625 × 4) + (0.0625 × 3) + (0.0625 × 2) + (0.0625 × 3) = 0.60 + 0.30 + 0.45 + 0.60 + 0.45 + 0.25 + 0.1875 + 0.125 + 0.1875 = 3.15/5 → ★★★, Average.
The two-axis verdict. Quality ★★★ (Average, 3.2/5); value read Modestly overvalued (wide band) as of 8 August 2026, implied −29.1% from $51.22 to a $36.29 blended fair value; verdict: Full — the market already sees it. The shares price about $4,767/oz gold with silver at ~$75.3 against this analysis’s $4,000 and $60 base deck, so the price already pays for roughly one step up in both metals. The target multiples sit 6% below their archetype anchors — P/NAV 0.94×, EV/EBITDA 6.6×, an FCF yield of 7.4% — because the cost position (Dim 2) and jurisdiction (Dim 8) outweigh the asset spread (Dim 1) and the balance sheet (Dim 5), with a small charge for reserve replacement (Dim 3).
The bull case is breadth and cash: a producer this diversified, with net cash and $1 bn of 2025 free cash flow, needs no single asset to go right. The bear case is what the breadth hides: thin margins at several gold mines, short producing reserves, and a price that already assumes more than trailing-average metal prices. What tips it is the metal price — the read turns Overvalued below about $3,977/oz gold and Fairly valued above about $4,504/oz, each with silver moving in step — and, over three years, whether the Skarn is sanctioned and funded without another share issue.
To rank Pan American against every listed silver producer on the same nine dimensions — reserves, AISC, reserve life and P/NAV — screen the sector on Metal Pilot’s silver mining stock screener.
10. Sources, methodology & disclaimer
10.1 Sources, methodology & data vintage
Sources — company filings: the FY2025 Annual Information Form, MD&A and audited financial statements (18 February 2026); the Q1 2026 interim statements, MD&A and results (5 May 2026); the 2025 production and 2026 guidance release, FY2025 results release, returns release and NCIB release; the 2026 information circular and voting results; the 2025 Sustainability Report release and Timmins Camp Project release; for 2021–2024, the FY2024, FY2023 and FY2022 financial statements and MD&As and the 2023 Annual Information Form.
Sources — technical reports: the NI 43-101 technical report for La Colorada (effective 24 March 2026) with the revised Skarn assessment and its release; every other mine’s reserves and resources as summarised in the 2025 AIF and MD&A.
Sources — market data and peers: share price per stockanalysis.com (NYSE close, 7 August 2026); monthly metal prices per the World Bank Pink Sheet to July 2026; USD/CAD per the Bank of Canada; each peer’s own 2025 filings, linked under Table 4 — the same five names are compared on one construction in Silver Producers Compared.
Methodology. Data as of 8 August 2026, refreshed on each annual report and on material events: market data at the 7 August close; balance sheet at 31 March 2026; financials for FY2025 and Q1 2026; reserves effective 30 June 2025 (Juanicipio 30 June 2024). No filing released after 8 August is used — the Q2 2026 results and the 30 June 2026 reserve statement are for the next run. IFRS, US dollars; resources exclusive of reserves; AISC by segment. The valuation’s base deck is $4,000/oz gold and $60/oz silver at a 5% real after-tax rate, every grid price run as a scenario; scorecard weights follow the producer reference case. Where filings disagreed, the audited statements won (FY2023 diluted EPS: $(0.32), not the 2025 MD&A’s $(0.25)).
Figures not drawn. The asset map is skipped because the blog’s figure library has no map component (Table 2 carries the footprint), and the financial-summary chart because one series would only repeat Table 5.
Data gaps — documents to request. Income-tax rates for Peru, Bolivia, Argentina and Ontario (27% used; +5 points costs about $0.55 a share) — a rate reconciliation by jurisdiction; Escobal restart capital and timing — a restart study; concentrate payable terms; the Timmins phase-1 schedule beyond 2026; and the 2025 Sustainability Report itself for emissions, water, tailings and TRIFR.
Re-run log. 30 September – 1 October 2026: re-aligned to the current template; valuation rebuilt on a new model — price re-read at the 7 August close ($51.22, was $48.05 at 6 August), trailing-average decks on fixed grids replacing the spot-anchored deck, reserve lives depleted to 31 March 2026, every figure re-sourced to the filings. Composite 3.3 → 3.2 (Solid → Average), chiefly on cost position against the declared peers; value read Fairly valued → Modestly overvalued (wide band), implied −29.1%. 18 October 2026: pre-launch fixes to locators, peer context and wording; no headline figure moved.
Provenance: Pan American Silver Corp. — Annual Information Form — 2025.
The full input register. Every figure Section 7 takes from a filing, a study or a market series, once, by document, with the table that uses it and its address — the long form of Table 10. The arithmetic and judgements are in Tables 13–15 and 19–21, marked Derived, Input or Estimate.
Table 27. Full source register — every figure §7 takes from a filing or a market series
| Input | Value | As of | Where §7 uses it | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 production and 2026 guidance release, 20 January 2026 | ||||
| Jacobina — 2026 guidance | 181.0–191.0 koz gold; AISC $1,550–1,650/oz | 20 Jan 2026 | Table 13, block 1; Table 14 | Filed | 2025 production release | "2026 Silver and Gold Production and AISC Forecasts" | "Jacobina (Brazil)" | p.4 |
| El Peñon — 2026 guidance | 104.0–111.0 koz gold; 3.65–3.95 Moz silver; AISC $275–500/oz | 20 Jan 2026 | Table 13, block 2; Table 14 | Filed | 2025 production release | "2026 Silver and Gold Production and AISC Forecasts" | "El Peñon (Chile)" | p.4 |
| Shahuindo — 2026 guidance | 125.5–135.0 koz gold; 0.20 Moz silver; AISC $1,825–1,950/oz | 20 Jan 2026 | Table 13, block 3; Table 14 | Filed | 2025 production release | "2026 Silver and Gold Production and AISC Forecasts" | "Shahuindo (Peru)" | p.4 |
| Timmins — 2026 guidance | 105.5–115.0 koz gold; AISC $2,575–2,675/oz | 20 Jan 2026 | Table 13, block 4; Table 14 | Filed | 2025 production release | "2026 Silver and Gold Production and AISC Forecasts" | "Timmins (Canada)" | p.4 |
| Minera Florida — 2026 guidance | 66.0–71.0 koz gold; 0.25 Moz silver; AISC $2,550–2,675/oz | 20 Jan 2026 | Table 13, block 5; Table 14 | Filed | 2025 production release | "2026 Silver and Gold Production and AISC Forecasts" | "Minera Florida (Chile)" | p.4 |
| Dolores — 2026 guidance | 18.0–20.0 koz gold; 0.35–0.45 Moz silver; AISC $2,550–2,800/oz | 20 Jan 2026 | Table 13, block 6; Table 14 | Filed | 2025 production release | "2026 Silver and Gold Production and AISC Forecasts" | "Dolores (Mexico)" | p.4 |
| La Colorada — 2026 guidance | 5.80–6.25 Moz silver; 2.5 koz gold; AISC $33.25–35.75/oz | 20 Jan 2026 | Table 13, block 7; Table 14 | Filed | 2025 production release | "2026 Silver and Gold Production and AISC Forecasts" | "La Colorada (Mexico)" | p.4 |
| Juanicipio (44%) — 2026 guidance | 6.00–6.50 Moz silver; 17.5–18.5 koz gold; AISC $2.25–4.25/oz | 20 Jan 2026 | Table 13, block 8; Table 14 | Filed | 2025 production release | "2026 Silver and Gold Production and AISC Forecasts" | "Juanicipio (Mexico) (3)" | p.4 |
| Cerro Moro — 2026 guidance | 2.80–3.00 Moz silver; 80.0–86.0 koz gold; AISC $(25.75)–(21.75)/oz | 20 Jan 2026 | Table 13, block 9; Table 14 | Filed | 2025 production release | "2026 Silver and Gold Production and AISC Forecasts" | "Cerro Moro (Argentina)" | p.4 |
| Huaron — 2026 guidance | 3.25–3.50 Moz silver; AISC $27.75–29.75/oz | 20 Jan 2026 | Table 13, block 10; Table 14 | Filed | 2025 production release | "2026 Silver and Gold Production and AISC Forecasts" | "Huaron (Peru)" | p.4 |
| San Vicente (95%) — 2026 guidance | 2.70–2.90 Moz silver; AISC $41.00–43.00/oz | 20 Jan 2026 | Table 13, block 11; Table 14 | Filed | 2025 production release | "2026 Silver and Gold Production and AISC Forecasts" | "San Vicente (Bolivia) (4)" | p.4 |
| Attributable production — 2026 guidance | 25.00–27.00 Moz silver; 700.0–750.0 koz gold | 20 Jan 2026 | Table 19 — the next-twelve-month volumes | Filed | 2025 production release | "2026 Silver and Gold Production and AISC Forecasts" | "Total Attributable Production" | p.4 |
| Base metals — 2026 guidance | zinc 58.5–62.5 kt; lead 30.5–32.5 kt; copper 2.0 kt | 20 Jan 2026 | Table 13, block 12; Table 19, row 6 | Filed | 2025 production release | "2026 Attributable Base Metal Production Forecasts" | "Attributable Production" | p.4 |
| Price deck behind the AISC guidance | silver $70.00/oz; gold $4,200/oz; zinc $3,000/t; lead $2,000/t; copper $10,000/t | 20 Jan 2026 | Table 13 — the by-product credits re-marked from this deck to the base prices | Filed | 2025 production release | 2026 Silver and Gold Production and AISC Forecasts, note 1 | "The AISC forecasts assume" | p.4 1 |
| Capital — 2026 guidance | sustaining $320–340 m; project: Jacobina $53–57 m, Timmins $40–43 m, Huaron $16–17 m, Cerro Moro $13–14 m, Juanicipio $11–12 m, La Colorada $9–10 m, Shahuindo $6–7 m | 20 Jan 2026 | Table 13 — the project capital in each block; Table 21, row 2 | Filed | 2025 production release | "2026 Expenditures Forecast" | "Sustaining Capital Total" | p.6 |
| Corporate costs — 2026 guidance | G&A $100–105 m; exploration and project development $22–25 m; care and maintenance $26–28 m (Escobal $16–18 m, other $10 m) | 20 Jan 2026 | Table 15, row 11; Table 13, block 14; Table 19, rows 9–11 | Filed | 2025 production release | "2026 Expenditures Forecast" | "General & Administrative" | p.6 |
| Depreciation and tax payments — 2026 guidance | D&A $500–525 m; income tax payments $500–550 m | 20 Jan 2026 | Table 21, row 3 — the D&A in the cash-tax base; the guided payments are context only | Filed | 2025 production release | "2026 Expenditures Forecast" | "Depreciation and Amortization" | p.6 |
| Q1 2026 MD&A, 5 May 2026 | ||||
| Project capital — revised | $240–255 m, from $195–210 m; Skarn $92–95 m | 5 May 2026 | Table 21, row 10 — growth capital after the Skarn increase | Filed | Q1 2026 MD&A | "2026 Operating Outlook" | "increasing full year consolidated project capital expenditures to be between" | p.3 |
| Skarn capital spent, Q1 2026 | $8 m | 31 Mar 2026 | Table 13, block 13, row 5 — added back after the roll to 31 March | Filed | Q1 2026 MD&A | "Alternative Performance (Non-GAAP) Measures" | "La Colorada (Skarn) project capital" | p.25 |
| Skarn access decline approved | $265 m over five years, approved 27 April 2026 | 27 Apr 2026 | §7.2 — the Skarn's milestone status | Filed | Q1 2026 MD&A | "Project Development Update" | "approved $265 million of project capital" | p.17 |
| Net cash (company measure) and investments other than equity securities | $679 m net cash; $29 m investments | 31 Mar 2026 | Table 15, row 7; the EV in Table 20 | Filed | Q1 2026 MD&A | "Liquidity and Financial Position" | "Investments, excluding equity securities" | p.20 |
| Condensed interim consolidated financial statements, 31 March 2026 | ||||
| Cash, debt and leases | cash $1,495 m; debt $4 m + $712 m; lease obligations $51 m + $78 m | 31 Mar 2026 | Table 15, row 7 — net cash with the leases in the rows | Filed | Q1 2026 FS | Statements of Financial Position | "Cash and cash equivalents (Note 15)" | p.2 |
| Working-capital lines | trade and other receivables $212 m; income tax receivables $24 m; payables $565 m; income tax payables $223 m | 31 Mar 2026 | Table 15, row 14 | Filed | Q1 2026 FS | Statements of Financial Position | "Trade and other receivables" | p.2 |
| Derivatives and other financial assets | derivative assets $3 m; La Arena contingent consideration $37 m; Galleon facility $8 m; non-current receivables $12 m; equity securities $90 m | 31 Mar 2026 | Table 15, rows 8 and 15 | Filed | Q1 2026 FS | Note 4 | "Derivative assets (3)" | p.7 |
| Saleable inventory | concentrate $46 m; doré and finished $123 m | 31 Mar 2026 | Table 15, row 14 | Filed | Q1 2026 FS | Note 5 | "Doré and finished inventory" | p.9 |
| Juanicipio at 44% — balance sheet | cash $199 m; other current assets $93 m; current liabilities $39 m; non-current liabilities $33 m; carrying amount $2,009 m | 31 Mar 2026 | Table 12; Table 15, row 15 — the JV's net monetary assets, not its carrying value | Filed | Q1 2026 FS | Note 7 | "Carrying amount of Investment in Juanicipio" | p.10 |
| Provisions | asset retirement obligations $590 m; litigation $36 m | 31 Mar 2026 | Table 15, rows 9 and 14 | Filed | Q1 2026 FS | Note 9 | "Asset retirement obligations, closing balance" | p.11 |
| Shares, options and equity-settled RSUs | 421,424 thousand shares; 123 thousand options at C$22.62; 180 thousand RSUs | 31 Mar 2026 | Table 15, row 17 | Filed | Q1 2026 FS | Statements of Changes in Equity | "Balance, March 31, 2026" | p.5 |
| Tahoe contingent value rights | 313.9 million CVRs into 15.6 million shares, 10-year term | 31 Mar 2026 | Table 15, row 17 — excluded from the count | Filed | Q1 2026 FS | Note 11 | "As at March 31, 2026 and 2025, there were 313.9 million CVRs outstanding" | p.13 |
| La Colorada NI 43-101 technical report (revised Skarn PEA), effective 24 March 2026 | ||||
| Skarn after-tax NPV5% — silver × zinc sensitivity | $4.2 bn at $60/oz and $3,400/t zinc; $3.9 bn at $60/oz and $3,100/t; $2.6 bn at $45/oz and $2,800/t | 24 Mar 2026 | Table 13, block 13, rows 1–3 — at every grid price | Filed | La Colorada TR 2026 | Table 24-19 | "NPV (5%) (After-tax) (US$ billion)" | p.166 2 |
| Skarn cash-flow schedule | NPV 5% $2,554 m; cumulative after-tax cash flow $7,075 m; initial capital $1,947 m | 24 Mar 2026 | Figure 8, note 2 — the profile the rate rows re-strike on; the calibration check | Filed | La Colorada TR 2026 | Table 24-18 | "NPV 5% | US$ M" | p.165 3 |
| Skarn permits outstanding | MIA, CUS and water permits for the shafts, plant and tailings | 24 Mar 2026 | §7.2 — the 0.30× weight's milestone status | Filed | La Colorada TR 2026 | §24.1.5 | "will require MIA, CUS, and water-related permits" | p.155 |
| Timmins Camp Project release, 1 June 2026 | ||||
| Timmins Camp Project, phase 1 | about $146 m, its initial spending inside the 2026 guidance of $40–43 m | 1 Jun 2026 | Table 13, block 4 — the $104.5 m balance at 1.75 years | Filed | Timmins release | "with a total investment of approximately $146 million" | p.1 4 |
| Audited consolidated financial statements, year ended 31 December 2025 | ||||
| Statutory income tax rate | 27% Canadian | FY2025 | Table 13 — the Peru, Bolivia, Argentina and Ontario rows; Table 21, row 3 | Filed | FS 2025 | Note 23 | "Statutory Canadian income tax rate" | p.45 |
| Unrecognised operating tax losses | $1,160 m | 31 Dec 2025 | §7.2 — the shield declined, bound $0.74/share | Filed | FS 2025 | Note 23 | "Operating tax loss" | p.46 |
| Streams and severance | Navidad deferred credit $21 m; deferred revenue $13 m; severance $68 m | 31 Dec 2025 | Table 15, rows 13 and 14 | Filed | FS 2025 | Note 19 | "Severance liabilities (3)" | p.40 |
| MD&A, year ended 31 December 2025 | ||||
| Gold reserves — gold-segment mines | 5,847.2 koz; Jacobina 3,127.5, El Peñon 625.6, Shahuindo 977.4, Timmins 845.9, Minera Florida 270.9 koz | 30 Jun 2025 | Table 13 — each gold mine's life; block 15, row 2 | Filed | MD&A 2025 | "Mineral Reserves as of June 30, 2025" | "Total Gold Segment (5)" | p.54 5 |
| Silver reserves — silver-segment mines and Escobal | La Colorada 90.7 Moz; Huaron 40.7; San Vicente 11.4; Cerro Moro 149.8 koz gold; Escobal 264.5 Moz | 30 Jun 2025 | Table 13, blocks 7, 9–11 and 14 | Filed | MD&A 2025 | "Mineral Reserves as of June 30, 2025" | "La Colorada (3) | Mexico | Proven" | p.54 5 |
| Gold M&I exclusive of reserves — gold-segment mines | 6,365.2 koz: Jacobina 5,021.8, El Peñon 451.0, Shahuindo 182.0, Timmins 305.1, Minera Florida 405.3 | 30 Jun 2025 | Table 13, block 15, row 4 | Filed | MD&A 2025 | "Measured and Indicated Mineral Resources as of June 30, 2025" | "Jacobina | Brazil | Measured" | p.55 5 |
| Silver M&I exclusive of reserves | La Colorada 14.8, Huaron 16.2, San Vicente 6.0, Cerro Moro 8.3 Moz; Navidad 632.3 Moz | 30 Jun 2025 | Table 13, block 16 | Filed | MD&A 2025 | "Measured and Indicated Mineral Resources as of June 30, 2025" | "Navidad | Argentina | Measured" | p.55 5 |
| Reclamation — undiscounted estimate | $935 m inflated and undiscounted | 31 Dec 2025 | Table 15, row 9 — the basis behind the carrying value | Filed | MD&A 2025 | "Asset Retirement Obligation Provision" | "The total inflated and undiscounted amount" | p.19 |
| 2025 Annual Information Form | ||||
| Mexican taxes | special mining duty 8.5%; extraordinary duty 1.0% of sales; income tax 30% | FY2025 | Table 13, blocks 6–8 — 35.95% on margin | Filed | AIF 2025 | "Juanicipio" | "conventional profit-based tax using the 30% corporate tax rate" | p.37 |
| Chilean taxes | Specific Mining Tax 4–14% (5–7% applied); first-category 27% | FY2025 | Table 13, blocks 2 and 5 — 31.38% on margin | Filed | AIF 2025 | "El Peñon" | "Minera Meridian is subject to the Specific Mining Tax" | p.50 |
| Jacobina SUDENE incentive | combined rate 34% → 15.25%, term expires 2031 | FY2025 | Table 13, block 1 — two tax periods | Filed | AIF 2025 | "Jacobina" | "resulting in a combined decrease in income tax and social contribution rates from" | p.42 |
| La Colorada gold stream | 100% of payable gold from certain concessions at $650/oz; 1,437 oz in 2025 | FY2025 | Table 13, block 7, row 4; Table 19, row 5 | Filed | AIF 2025 | "La Colorada" | "less a fixed price of USD$650 per ounce" | p.30 |
| Cerro Moro silver stream | 9.0% of silver for the life of the mine at 30% of the price | Jul 2025 | Table 13, block 9, row 2; Table 19, row 2 | Filed | AIF 2025 | "Silver and Gold Doré" | "the silver stream will reduce to 9.0% of the silver produced" | p.23 |
| Cerro Moro minority | preferred shares equal to 5% | FY2025 | Table 15, row 10 | Filed | AIF 2025 | "Subsidiaries", chart note 2 | "holds subordinated preferred shares in Estelar Resources S.A. equal to" | p.16 |
| Juanicipio reserve and resource (44%) | reserve 8.2 Mt at 221 g/t silver (58.3 Moz); measured and indicated, inclusive, 76.7 Moz | 30 Jun 2024 | Table 13, block 8 — life; block 16 — 18.4 Moz exclusive | Filed | AIF 2025 | "Juanicipio Mineral Reserves (44% ownership basis)" | "TOTAL" | p.39 6 |
| Reserve replacement, 2025 | 10.3 Moz silver and nearly 500 koz gold replaced | 30 Jun 2025 | Table 18, Dim 3 term; Table 22 | Filed | AIF 2025 | "Key Developments Over the Last Three Financial Years" | "Exploration successfully replaced 10.3 million ounces of silver" | p.20 |
| Year-end statements, FY2021–FY2025 — the own-multiple inputs | ||||
| Year-end EV and EBITDA inputs, 2021 and 2022 | $ thousands, 2021 / 2022: cash 283,550 / 107,005; debt 3,400 + 11,900 / 13,712 + 180,010; leases 10,663 + 19,898 / 13,608 + 19,506; earnings (loss) from operations 320,911 / (262,261); D&A 302,958 / 316,036; shares 210,457,524 / 210,680,834 | 31 Dec 2021, 2022 | Table 22, note 1 — the own-multiple history | Filed | FS 2022 | Statements of Financial Position | "Cash and cash equivalents (Note 27)" | p.6; Statements of Earnings and Comprehensive Earnings | "(Loss) earnings from operations" | p.7; Statements of Changes in Equity | "Balance, December 31, 2021" | p.9 |
| Year-end EV and EBITDA inputs, 2023 | $ m: cash 399.6; debt 6.7 + 697.0; leases 45.7 + 52.2; earnings from operations 38.1; D&A 484.2; shares 364,660 thousand | 31 Dec 2023 | Table 22, note 1 — the own-multiple history | Filed | FS 2023 | Statements of Financial Position | "Cash and cash equivalents (Note 28)" | p.8; Statements of Earnings and Comprehensive Earnings | "Earnings (loss) from operations" | p.9; Statements of Changes in Equity | "Balance, December 31, 2023" | p.11 |
| Year-end EV and EBITDA inputs, 2024 | $ m: cash 862.8; debt 6.8 + 702.0; leases 40.6 + 53.9; earnings from operations 530.7; D&A 571.7; shares 363,041 thousand | 31 Dec 2024 | Table 22, note 1 — the own-multiple history | Filed | FS 2024 | Statements of Financial Position | "Cash and cash equivalents (Note 27)" | p.6; Statements of Earnings and Comprehensive Earnings | "Earnings from operations" | p.7; Statements of Changes in Equity | "Balance, December 31, 2024" | p.9 |
| Year-end EV and EBITDA inputs, 2025 | $ m: cash 1,215; debt 5 + 709; leases 53 + 85; earnings from operations 1,233; D&A 497; shares 421,847 thousand | 31 Dec 2025 | Table 22, note 1 — the own-multiple history | Filed | FS 2025 | Statements of Financial Position | "Cash and cash equivalents (Note 25)" | p.7; Statements of Earnings and Comprehensive Earnings | "Earnings from operations" | p.8; Statements of Changes in Equity | "Balance, December 31, 2025" | p.10 |
| Market and price series | ||||
| Gold trailing averages | 3-month $4,296; 6-month $4,581; 12-month $4,311; five-year $2,601 | to 31 Jul 2026 | §7 opening — the $4,000 base; §7.3's cycle test | Market | World Bank Pink Sheet | "Gold", monthly | to Jul 2026 |
| Silver trailing averages | 3-month $67.83; 6-month $73.20; 12-month $64.53; five-year $33.46 | to 31 Jul 2026 | §7 opening — the $60 silver base | Market | World Bank Pink Sheet | "Silver", monthly | to Jul 2026 |
| Base-metal 3-month averages | zinc $3,540/t; lead $1,926/t; copper $13,546/t | to 31 Jul 2026 | §7 opening — the by-product bases | Market | World Bank Pink Sheet | "Zinc", "Lead", "Copper", monthly | to Jul 2026 |
| Five-year monthly range | gold $5,020 (Feb 2026) to $1,664 (Oct 2022); silver $92.1 (Jan 2026) to $18.9 (Sep 2022) | Aug 2021 – Jul 2026 | Table 22 — the range the market-implied deck is read against | Market | World Bank Pink Sheet | "Gold", "Silver", monthly | Aug 2021 – Jul 2026 |
| Forecast deck | gold $4,509/oz, silver $72/oz (2026) | 28 Jul 2026 | §7 opening and Table 22 — the 0%-weight forecast deck | Market | Reuters analyst poll | "median gold forecast of $4,509" | 28 Jul 2026 |
| Exchange rate | US$1 = C$1.3943 | 7 Aug 2026 | Table 15, row 17 — the treasury test on the C$ options | Market | Bank of Canada | "USD/CAD" daily rate | 7 Aug 2026 |
| Year-end share prices | $24.97 / $16.34 / $16.33 / $20.22 / $51.81, 2021–25 | 31 Dec 2021–25 | Table 22 — the own-multiple history | Market | Yahoo Finance daily history | "Close", last trading day of each year | US listing (Nasdaq to Apr 2023, NYSE after) |
Notes to Table 27
- The deck the company’s 2026 AISC guidance is struck on; §7 moves every by-product credit from it to the base prices.
- The study prints NPV5% at silver prices of $30, $45, $60 and $75/oz and zinc prices of $2,200–3,400/t; §7 interpolates between them and extends the nearest slope to $3,600/t zinc and $80/oz silver, an author step marked as one in Table 13.
- The schedule’s $2,554 m reproduces within 0.9% on mid-year discounting from 1 January 2026; it is the profile the rate rows re-strike the study on.
- The release places the phase’s initial spending inside the 2026 Timmins guidance and gives no later schedule; the $104.5 m balance is §7’s estimate.
- Per-mine totals are the sums of the filed proven and probable (or measured and indicated) rows; the MD&A prints the segment totals only.
- The AIF prints Juanicipio’s tonnes and grade on a 44% basis; the contained ounces are derived from them.
Source: the 2025 production and 2026 guidance release; the Q1 2026 MD&A and interim financial statements, 31 March 2026; the La Colorada technical report; the Timmins Camp Project release; the FY2025 financial statements, 2025 MD&A and 2025 Annual Information Form; the year-end lines of the 2022, 2023 and 2024 financial statements; metal prices per the World Bank Pink Sheet; exchange rate per the Bank of Canada; the forecast deck per Reuters via Kitco; year-end closes per Yahoo Finance. Page numbers are those of each filed document as rendered on EDGAR; every filed figure was read back from the copy in the verification folder.
10.2 Disclaimer & disclosure
This analysis is for informational purposes only and is not investment advice, a recommendation, or an offer to buy or sell any security. It is a point-in-time snapshot as of 8 August 2026: the share price, market capitalisation, enterprise value, multiples and valuation read all move, and precious-metals equities are volatile. Reserve, resource, study and guidance figures are estimates on the codes and bases stated beside each table; the Skarn study and any Escobal restart are not achieved results. The Quality × Value verdict is an analytical read, never an instruction to the reader. This report was prepared with AI assistance; figures were sourced from primary filings and reviewed, but readers should verify every number against the original documents before acting on it. As of 18 November 2026, the author holds no position in the company this analysis covers. Please do your own research and consult a licensed financial adviser.